al-Hasani
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2013
- Messages
- 14,060
- Reaction score
- 43
- Country
- Location
Phoenix:
I am sorry but that does not correspondent with the reality. A ordinary Portuguese, Italian, German, Brit etc. has no ties to India, Pakistan, Iran, Kazakhstan etc. Be it culture, look, language, religion, history etc. The Aryans were small in numbers and Aryans hardly ever reached Europe in the first place. There is no way that Pakistani, Indian genetics are similar to any European population in terms of subclades. Besides an distant ancient connection with a smaller amount of people. By your logic then Black Africans in West Africa and Europeans who happen to belong to the same ANCIENT haplogroup, for example Haplogroup E-P147, that predated the foundation of languages/ethnic groups are the same people.
Besides Indo-European and Indo-Iranians are two different things. Even linguistically. Not to mention in terms of actual ancestry since those groups are not even homogenous themselves. It's beyond ridiculous to suggest anything else.
A Greek living on Crete or Southern Greece just across North Africa/Levant has more ties to those areas than he has to Afghanistan 12.000 km away. Be it geography, look, history, cuisine, culture etc.
I am sorry but that does not correspondent with the reality. A ordinary Portuguese, Italian, German, Brit etc. has no ties to India, Pakistan, Iran, Kazakhstan etc. Be it culture, look, language, religion, history etc. The Aryans were small in numbers and Aryans hardly ever reached Europe in the first place. There is no way that Pakistani, Indian genetics are similar to any European population in terms of subclades. Besides an distant ancient connection with a smaller amount of people. By your logic then Black Africans in West Africa and Europeans who happen to belong to the same ANCIENT haplogroup, for example Haplogroup E-P147, that predated the foundation of languages/ethnic groups are the same people.
Besides Indo-European and Indo-Iranians are two different things. Even linguistically. Not to mention in terms of actual ancestry since those groups are not even homogenous themselves. It's beyond ridiculous to suggest anything else.
A Greek living on Crete or Southern Greece just across North Africa/Levant has more ties to those areas than he has to Afghanistan 12.000 km away. Be it geography, look, history, cuisine, culture etc.