Who Really Killed Osama Bin Laden?

[TMA]

But you have yet to explain how the US took note of it in regards to the bin-Laden raid, before China ever made such a pledge to Pakistan.



So I'm to believe that some vague, unnamed, "members on the forum" are the definitive authorities on this issue?

How about we look at what we actually do know about it. President Musharraff only made this claim for the first time, in a single interview on the American TV show '60 Minutes' years after the fact. And even he admitted in the interview, that he was only repeating what he had been told happened, in a conversation immediately after 9/11/2001 between a Pakistani ISI officer, and Deputy Sec. of State, Richard Armitage. When Musharraff was later pressed for details by other reporters, he repeatedly dodged the questions until he then claimed he was, "unable to provide details due to restrictions by the publisher" of his upcoming book, 'In the Line of Fire'. Riiiiight. Richard Armitage, when he was questioned about the alleged incident, was utterly baffled and stated that while he did have numerous conversations with Pakistani officials right after 9/11, and did repeat President Bush's, "those that aren't with us, are against us." line, that his call to Pakistani officials were cordial, cooperative, and no threat at all, was ever made. President Bush, was likewise baffled, stating that he first heard of such a story, only when he read it in the newspapers, many years after 9/11. Colin Powell said that such a threat would not have been made in any event, as his calls, and others, reported that Musharraff's government immediately agreed to all seven items requested by the US government, of Pakistan, without conditions.

And btw, when Gen. Musharraff's book was published, it was most harshly trashed by the reviewers in Pakistan for it's multitude of self-serving lies, excuses, and inconsistencies.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Armitage_(politician)#Pakistan_and_the_fight_against_terrorism

https://www.pressreader.com/

The US took note of it after China made her bold statement, it was impossible for the US to take note of China's bold statement before China gave it.

Well there are many who say that Pakistan had no choice due to the threat of war and others who say that Musharraf was a sell-out and insincere to his people...I am still undecided...

 

[TankMan]

Relevant:
https://www.democracynow.org/2016/4/25/sy_hershs_book_on_bin_laden
https://www.democracynow.org/2016/4/25/part_2_seymour_hershs_new_book

Seymour Hersh is a credible and professional journalist - his claims are worth considering. The US Govt. quickly jumped to discredit him, so he must be saying something right.

 

[tarrar]

He was killed long time in Afghanistan. All this bullshit by US & Zardari party was only to harm Pakistans image.

 

[wiseone2]

i wish the americans had shown the body to put conspiracy seekers to rest

 

[WaLeEdK2]

Pics the US released smh... To bad they threw the body into the ocean so a big fish could eat it lol.

I gotta hand it to the US though. This one tops the evidence on WMDs. I guarantee the Russians and Chinese knew how much BS there was to this fairytale lmao.

 

[sohailbutt1987]

the same US who fooled the world saying "an airplane" smashed into pentagon where as it was hit by a cruise missile!

by the way mullah omar's death was hidden by his close followers for 2 damn years before the world came to know about it, by american standards he would have been killed in carpet bombings of tora bora!

also a fact which the world cannot deny is of Saddam Hussain's execution, he was specially hanged on the day of eid!

also a fact that Gaddafi's body was kept on display for 7 days for the world to see to believe that he had actually been killed!

so my point; why in the world would america dispose off bin laden in sea the same night of his death? by amercian standards he should have been stuffed and displayed at musuems all arounds the world to believe that he is actually dead! why?! why?! why?!

Bin Laden died many years ago, he had problems with his kidneys and he used to visit Pakistan for regular check ups BEFORE 9/11, this so called operation to kill him was just to wipe out his name and secure a second round in white house by obama!

 

[Path-Finder]

osama died and a new nemesis was presented to the word called baghdadi. al qaeda was succeeded by isis as well!

 

[Vortex]

There is an irrefutable evidence US killed OBL at Abottabad :

 

[BHarwana]

Must watch Bhutto interview video.

MI6 killed Osama bin laden, long time ago.

 

[LeGenD]

Relevant:
https://www.democracynow.org/2016/4/25/sy_hershs_book_on_bin_laden
https://www.democracynow.org/2016/4/25/part_2_seymour_hershs_new_book

Seymour Hersh is a credible and professional journalist - his claims are worth considering. The US Govt. quickly jumped to discredit him, so he must be saying something right.

His account is false and debunked. A journalist is not infallible irrespective of his reputation.

Some people are still under the illusion that Pakistani defenses are impregnable. Declassified sources confirm that Leon Panetta was not on good terms with Shuja Pasha and cooperation in this raid was out of question.

Pakistan's own investigation lend's credibility to American accounts of the raid. About time we (all) acknowledge the realities.

 

[shahbaz baig]

it`s 2050. and the question is same that who killed Osama bin laden ? and why were his body not preserved for eternal display. like saddam and Gaddafi?

May be Pakistan was also involved with US or may be not. this was really a hidden Operation in the history of world.

 

[Verve]

Maybe the question should be 'WHAT killed him: a bullet or a disease?'.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

Must watch Bhutto interview video.

MI6 killed Osama bin laden, long time ago.

which shows Osama was not dead at the time. MI6 is a lame organization with no real accomplishments. If she had said CIA now that would have been credible. But then misleading the CIA is what she thought she would do with this statement.

 

[barbarosa]

He is a live yet.

 

[BHarwana]

which shows Osama was not dead at the time. MI6 is a lame organization with no real accomplishments. If she had said CIA now that would have been credible. But then misleading the CIA is what she thought she would do with this statement.

the one which shows Osama was dead long time ago.