Regarding stupidity of F-16 purchase with prior knowledge and experience of sanctions, my subject was PAF not you.
Our financial problems, they are not going to go away anywhere as long as we keep finding billions in politicians houses and we keep letting them walk free instead of roasting them alive with their whole families.
In my opinion (and I may be totally wrong on that) Affordability issue is not even a factor, or relevant, if it is, It MUST NOT be. We were not even able to finance our nuclear program but our leadership saw the need (for survival) and they managed it one way or the other, we were not able to finance the missile research and all, but again people at the top saw the need and we managed that, Pakistan is not a poor country, there are billions of dollars stacked away in our politicians houses, it is not difficult to recover 30/40 billion in hard cash with the help of one sharp spear (to shove up the arse) and one sharp machete (to chop off the heads) of each and every single member of these corrupt politicians. Financing 100 J10's is not difficult, I would happily kill 100/1000 politicians to save the millions and the country. No price is ever too high to spend on saving the honour of the country.
Regarding the solution, how many J10's we could have bought in the same amount that we paid for block 52's? and how many more we could have acquired on long-term loan is anybody's guess.
Regarding what J10 brings to the table? same capability as F-16 less the sanctions at a lower price at lower maintenance cost, at lower operating cost, with possibility of local manufacturing/assembling, gaining technical knowhow, using that knowhow in Thunder production, reducing average cost of Thunders due to higher utilization of manufacturing facilities, commonality of armament with thunder, selection/variety of armament, higher numbers (2~3 squadrons instead of 1), better range than thunder, better load then thunder, AESA, IRST, political freedom from USA, better leverage in negotiations, etc., etc....
In no way I am putting down Falcons, they are amazing machines with great capability, but if that "great" capability is not guaranteed (due to sanctions or shortage of spares and armaments) during a conflict then that peacetime capability is useless for us, and all the investment and training is also wasted, and it would be a lot better to get J10 with 80/90 percent guaranteed capability. In a layman terms I would prefer a sling shot for my defence than a gun that I can't fire in time of need.
If you think that the decision to buy the 16s was stupid take it up with the PAF officials.As to the logic of repeat buy I merely pointed out the reasoning behind the repeat buy. Perhaps you are oblivious of the financial difficulties which Our country faces. The sort of decsions you want are on the books but there is no money to back it with. So rather than sitting on your lofty seat and pontificating come out with how you will organize the finances to buy the planes which are needed.
One of the reason why we buy the 16s is the ease in embedding a plane within the established infrastructure. If you think this is treasonous take it up with the Rulers and money managers of our country.
Wiser people than you have prepared and read the scenario much better than you and are aware of our needs. If you think you can do better then come out with solid facts as to how.
Alot of countries buy from the US and for very good reasons. You get the best bang for the buck. We have internet warriors harping on ad nauseum abourt kill switches and how they will cripple the fleet of 16s which PAF has in a war against india. I have alluded at length what the sanctions are going to be and why I feel the kill switches will not be utilized by US in a war against India where the US armoury goes up against the French and the Russians. Do you guys honestly think the US will let go of its biggest advertisement campaign on earth to shoot itself in its own foot.
Has anyone ever considered that the PAF is not aware of these alleged kill switches and might not have taken steps to remedy the cause if any??? I already know you have not alluded to them but the stupidity that you point out of buying repeatedly from them makes me allude to it.
Also while you are at irt ask yourself whom will you buy the next 4.5 generation platform from and how you will pay for it? In our wave of condemnation perhaps the Gurus and their followers would like to point out which 4.5 generation platform is available and at a cost we can afford. Why do the followers of the Sage condemning PAF of treason and criminal negligence not consider the options that we have to hand NOW and then reanalyze the situation and see why PAF sits quietly and waits. What do we wait for ?
There is a lot in her e for you to think about and ponder on. Please contemplate and then formulate a reasonable response and then we can debate further.
regards
A
As to the last point it did not do so regarding the decision to finance the 16s sale subsidised with FMF. This is where the problems came in.
The EDA falcos ar e a bonus and a carrot which is dangled in front of us. They are needed but perhaps not as badly as before sothe green rabbit is not biting itas quickly as before. We will go for it but only at the right price( the price being monetary as well as other behind the scene demands). This is where the game is in my humble opinion
A