India 'incomplete' without Pakistan's Sindh: BJP patriarch LK Advani

[BlackMist]

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...s-lal-krishna-advani/articleshow/56565122.cms

Well you cant have Sindh but if you want antiques for museum, please feel free to pickup entire PPP's leadership particularly Zardari and his Son. They will definitely make your day

 

[Zibago]

Well you cant have Sindh but if you want antiques for museum, please feel free to pickup entire PPP's leadership particularly Zardari and his Son. They will definitely make your day

What about this mummy ?

 

[khanmubashir]

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...s-lal-krishna-advani/articleshow/56565122.cms

Same way many old English men wish to have crown jewel of empire India back fate of 100s of millions can't be decided for stupid wishes of few dying old men
Pakistan was created per demands of Muslim majority of these land's
making such stupid claims show age has taken over mind

 

[Khanate]

@Kaptaan

 

[IceCold]

Try and comprehend the difference between personal opinion and national policy.

Sir please? Opinions are always personal till the time they have the power to bring them to reality. BJP is in power in India and so these opinions dont just remain opinions anymore but they impact is seen in the official policy.

 

[NirmalKrish]

I'm just pointing out that u are defending him on something where he was wrong. Do u agree that Hindustani is a race? If u have anything to contribute then respond otherwise don't bother to quote me and talk irrelevant stuff.

I was not at all defending that old Coot (what he says I could not give a rat about...) I was stating the fact that this thread as usual has become an India bashing affair, at the drop the of dime... catch my drift!

 

[BHarwana]

I fail to understand your logic, infact u have nothing left to return.
Before 1947 in Pakistan many of the rich wealthy merchants were Hindus and Sikhs. U have the Soojan Singh Haveli in Rawalpindi, infact it is said that Soojan Singh owned half of Rawalpindi.I have read it somewhere Tommorrow if the Great Grandson of Soojan Singh approaches and demands his share of property,will u oblige

I am ready to oblige but you will only get Rawalpindi and lose entire Sub continent including pindi.

 

[Cookie Monster]

I was not at all defending that old Coot (what he says I could not give a rat about...) I was stating the fact that this thread as usual has become an India bashing affair, at the drop the of dime... catch my drift!

Do u expect a round of applause from Pakistanis when Advani says he wants Sindh?

If the tables were turned and there was a thread about Pakistani politician saying Pakistan wants IOK, do u think Indians would react any differently?

 

[Khanate]

You could argue that he was in a way, I suppose. But ethnically, he was Gujarati.

Correct.

Though it was Jinnah who demanded the separation of Sindh from Bombay presidency under his Fourteen Points and restored the Sindhi identity.

• Sindh should be separated from the Bombay Presidency. -- Jinnah

Souce: Fourteen Points of Jinnah

 

[suresh1773]

I am ready to oblige but you will only get Rawalpindi and lose entire Sub continent including pindi.

Are u OK. Rawal Pindi was just one example. What about Mohatta Palace in Karachi.

 

[NirmalKrish]

Do u expect a round of applause from Pakistanis when Advani says he wants Sindh?

If the tables were turned and there was a thread about Pakistani politician saying Pakistan want IOK, do u think Indians would react any differently?

For a start, it will not involve rubbish language, Profanity and ridiculous statements such as "we are a superior race" then the rest you can add up. There are idiots from both ends, but learn to differentiate between a debate and verbal diarrhea.

 

[BHarwana]

Are u OK. Rawal Pindi was just one example. What about Mohatta Palace in Karachi.

Leave the individuals lets do it by kings. Name any Hindu king that controlled entire subcontinent and lets give it to his decedents

 

[Cookie Monster]

For a start, it will not involve rubbish language, Profanity and ridiculous statements such as "we are a superior race" then the rest you can add up. There are idiots from both ends, but learn to differentiate between a debate and verbal diarrhea.

Lol u r either naive or playing dumb. This doesn't even have to be a theoretical scenario since there are many such threads where u can see "rubbish language" and "verbal diarrhea" from Indian members.

As for ur superior race thing, look at post #53 where JackSparrow is trying to prove that Pakistanis are somehow an inferior race. So there goes ur claim of how Indians act so classy.

And do respond to my post #60...that is unless u find it hard to post a rebuttal to that.

 

[suresh1773]

Leave the individuals lets do it by kings. Name any Hindu king that controlled entire subcontinent and lets give it to his decedents

Any one claim to be a descendent of a Particular king and demand property,kingdom will you oblige.Now the question arises how will you verify his claim.

 

[NirmalKrish]

And what exactly legitimatizes ur nuclear program?

As for Pakistan's hegemonic and expansionist agenda plz cite examples. I can certainly provide quite a few examples in India's case

Are you asking a retorical question that has been debated and bashed to death on a PDF. Fruitless excercise you obviously are aware our of reasons. Nice try flamebaiting but I Ain't falling for that.