India burning

[jamahir]

She chose to write what she had experienced first-hand, and what she genuinely believed in. Others like Avijit weren't even critical of any particular religion, all they wanted was to pen down their thoughts. And in turn was culled by the types protesting CAA and NRC in India- uneducated and violent.

As compared to the very intellectual Sangh. How nice.

People like Mandela and Carlos ( the jackal ) were so admiring of the Sangh.

 

[namefield_empty]

As compared to the very intellectual Sangh. How nice.

A Sanghi government shelters Ms Nasrin after her fellow Bengalis(threatened by the mullahs) refused her residency there. Do keep in mind that she still considers Bengal her spiritual home and is equally critical of all religions.

 

[Naofumi]

Only 5,097 Chakmas, Hajongs in Arunachal have voting rights’

Just an example..

Can you show the same for Bengalis who came in 1971? Because I think they make up the biggest group by far leftout in NRC

 

[fitpOsitive]

Dawn is a quality media news outlet, no doubt.

And people call them traitor.

 

[El Sidd]

An artificial entity like India could only survive 70 odd years enjoying the remnants of colonial administrative infrastructure.

It is burning from within like an isolated fascist state.

 

[namefield_empty]

Can you show the same for Bengalis who came in 1971? Because I think they

As i have already mentioned in a previous post that those Hindu Bengalis who found out of NRC was because their refugee id cards were deemed inadmissible by the corrupt NRC coordinator (against whom we have initiated legal proceedings).

 

[jamahir]

Do keep in mind that she still considers Bengal her spiritual home

I have no objection to that.

and is equally critical of all religions.

Show me where she criticized Hindutva thought. Show me where she was condemned the same way that the Sangh condemns, say Arundhati Roy.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

The post you had responded to specifically was about population. If you felt the population does not mean jack shit you should have said so in reply to that post.

No, I was negating the narrative about the size of indian population as its irrelevant. that when a super power as huge as Soviet union can collapse, with huge resources and military might, what chance India got when it is lighting fire within.

 

[Naofumi]

A Sanghi government shelters Ms Nasrin after her fellow Bengalis(threatened by the mullahs) refused her residency there.

Because, she kept her mouth about Sangh shut up till now, like when she even questioned the CAA, then she called it "generous" and that made the headline, after that she goes on to bash Pakistan and BD, and then she makes her point - include freethinker muslims too. She is clever to not to clash with Sangh
https://www.business-standard.com/a...muslim-community-atheists-120011800124_1.html

As i have already mentioned in a previous post that those Hindu Bengalis who found out of NRC was because their refugee id cards were deemed inadmissible by the corrupt NRC coordinator (against whom we have initiated legal proceedings).

Not a very convincing argument

 

[jamahir]

Because, she kept her mouth about Sangh shut up till now, like when she even questioned the CAA, then she called it "generous" and that made the headline, after that she goes on to bash Pakistan and BD, and then she makes her point - include freethinker muslims too. She is clever to not to clash with Sangh

Indeed.

https://www.business-standard.com/a...muslim-community-atheists-120011800124_1.html

Citing Muslim "atheists bloggers" who were killed by suspected Islamist militants in Bangladesh a few years ago, she said: "Many of these bloggers left for Europe and America to save their lives. Why cannot they come to India? Today, India requires more free thinker, secularist, feminist from the Muslim community."

@Axomiya_lora

 

[namefield_empty]

Not a very convincing argument

Let us suppose that you are a Pakistani Hindu, born and brought up there, studied and graduated from some nondescript University there and was pursuing your profession when you hurt the fragile sensibility of the Islamists.

You run for your dear life to India and our government provides you a refugee identity document till you get a long term visa.

Pray tell me now that if your birth certificate, SSC pass certificate or your name in the Pakistani voter list would be accepted in India. Only admissible document in your possession would be your refugee identity card through which you gained entry to India. It should not be too difficult to comprehend for a person with normal intellect.

 

[Naofumi]

Let us suppose that you are a Pakistani Hindu, born and brought up there, studied and graduated from some nondescript University there and was pursuing your profession when you hurt the fragile sensibility of the Islamists.

You run for your dear life to India and our government provides you a refugee identity document till you get a long term visa.

Pray tell me now that if your birth certificate, SSC pass certificate or your name in the Pakistani voter list would be accepted in India. Only admissible document in your possession would be your refugee identity card through which you gained entry to India. It should not be too difficult to comprehend for a person with normal intellect.

I was talking about coordinator being corrupt. And now I think about it, you still did not refuted that quora answer

 

[namefield_empty]

Because, she kept her mouth about Sangh shut up till now, like when she even questioned the CAA, then she called it "generous" and that made the headline, after that she goes on to bash Pakistan and BD,

Nope, it is because she knows about the struggles of the religious and ethnic minorities in Bangladesh and Pakistan first hand, and what happens to the liberal freethinkers and atheists over there.

I was talking about coordinator being corrupt.

Don't be so naive, above mentioned posts are the EXAMPLES of the coordinator being corrupt when he plainly refused to accept refugee id cards or do sample reverification. These kinks would be ironed out in due time.

you still did not refuted that quora answer

I have refuted it many a times. NRC in Assam mainly relied on legacy data, that means even if you don't have any documents proving yourself to be an Indian citizen you still can be included if someone/anyone in your ancestry can prove themselves to be an Indian. There were approximately two dozens of legally acceptable documents in the accepted list. Anyone in India can forge identification documents like PAN and AADHAR, but legacy data is where they would be caught red handed. Anyway, that was only for Assam, pan India NRC is still undecided, so i don't know why are you unnecessary cribbing.

 

[Naofumi]

Nope, it is because she knows about the struggles of the religious and ethnic minorities in Bangladesh and Pakistan first hand, and what happens to the liberal freethinkers and atheists over there.

But she was asked to speak about CAA, even then she bashed BD and Pakistan. And if you believe that show any direct criticism of Sangh by her

 

[jamahir]

Nope, it is because she knows about the struggles of the religious and ethnic minorities in Bangladesh and Pakistan first hand, and what happens to the liberal freethinkers and atheists over there.

And what happens to liberal freethinkers over here ??

Let us remember Govind Pansare, Narendra Dabholkar, M.M.Kalburgi and Gauri Lankesh who were all assassinated by Sangh people.

And those who were not assassinated were harassed by other means, like the late Rohith Vemula ( forced to commit suicide ) or Kanhaiya Kumar ( charged with "Sedition" and harassed by legal means ).