Govt Crackdown on the Islamabad protesters | Updates & Discussions

[VCheng]

Ok, now there's a difference between a legal demand and a perfectly legal demand?

Told you we were not discussing the way he adopted - peaceful or violent, that's not the point. Point is about the legality or illegality of the demand.

Please consider this analogy: It is legal to pee inside one's house, preferably in a toilet. Peeing in the middle of the street in full public view is illegal. I hope you can see how the act of expressing the designated act makes all the difference?

 

[Emmie]

Please consider this analogy: It is legal to pee inside one's house, preferably in a toilet. Peeing in the middle of the street in full public view is illegal. I hope you can see how the act of expressing the designated act makes all the difference?

Oh man, it's not about peeing in toilet or right in the middle of street, it's about having the right to pee, it's about whether one can take a pee or not. How one takes a pee is not the point in focus here. Please maintain a difference between raising a demand and adopting ways to ensure demand is accepted.

 

[VCheng]

Oh man, it's not about peeing in toilet or right in the middle of street, it's about having the right to pee. How one takes a pee is not the point in focus here. Please maintain a difference between raising a demand and adopting ways to ensure demand is accepted.

The right to pee is not universal, with regards to location, is it? Having a right does not imply a blanket right to use it anywhere without distinction. This is the old shouting "Fire!" in a crowded theater vs. a right of freedom of expression, in a way.

 

[Leader]

PM Nawaz returned to the Parliament moments after the PTI legislators left the building.



Opposition 'jirga' sees ray of hope after PTI meeting - Pakistan - DAWN.COM

 

[Emmie]

The right to pee is not universal, with regards to location, is it? Having a right does not imply a blanket right to use it anywhere without distinction. This is the old shouting "Fire!" in a crowded theater vs. a right of freedom of expression, in a way.

But one still enjoys the right to pee regardless of location, isn't it?

 

[Leader]

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=840059752703113

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=840073692701719

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=840107306031691

Imran Khan (official) | Facebook

 

[VCheng]

But one still enjoys the right to pee regardless of location, isn't it?

Regardless of location? As in anywhere, anytime? Can I shout "Fire!" anywhere I want if I have the right of freedom of expression?

 

[Emmie]

Regardless of location? As in anywhere, anytime? Can I shout "Fire!" anywhere I want if I have the right of freedom of expression?

So what you are saying is - you have a right to pee but if you pee in middle of street or in blanket you lose the right to pee.

 

[Sedqal]

Please stop it with the pee analogy, use something else.

 

[Dubious]

lol @ Inqalabi

[video]

Dude SC par kapray dho ker kisnay latkai way thay? and that was even before the march

 

[VCheng]

So what you are saying is - you have a right to pee but if you pee in middle of street or in blanket you lose the right to pee.

No, the expression of a right is subject to the law, that is all.

 

[Ahmad1996]

 

[Emmie]

No, the expression of a right is subject to the law, that is all.

Where did I argue that? Find me a post of mine where I have argued that the way IK had adopted to express his right was legal or illegal?

 

[VCheng]

Where did I argue that? Find me a post of mine where I have argued that the way IK had adopted to express his right was legal or illegal?

No, not you, it was me who is arguing that IK has a right to his opinion, but its expression in the way that he did was not legal.

 

[Devil Soul]

اسلام آباد:شیخ رشیدنےکنٹینربدل لیا