Do Pakistani punjabis have love for Indian Punjabis and vice versa

[Squashh]

Don't teach me how Punjabis look or you must not be a Punjabi

Punjabis are a mix bunch dude, what are you on about?

 

[Aoun Hussnain]

Islam has not wiped any feelings.
Separation didn't happen because of Islam.
How'd u feel if I ask u that has Sikhism wiped off feelings of punjabi brotherhood from you?
Punjabi is our culture but Islam is our religion n obviously as Muslims Islam is more dear to us than being Punjabi

 

[ito]

What,s your problem if i like indian punjabis? I never said they look better or like us.UP too got mixed people,some are dark,some are fair etc etc.


And yes may be you haven not seen much punjabis yet ,specially from the pakistan side @Shamain

Punjabis are a mix bunch dude, what are you on about?

I am not a racist...I just expressed my opinion...yes...I met a lot of Punjabis from Pakistani side....this is easy if you have spent lot of your time in UK and US.

I agree Punjabis are a mixed lot...

 

[SecularNationalist]

Punjabis are a mix bunch dude, what are you on about?

And in terms of face features and color our punjabis are way more good looking than indian punjabis.I am surprised how can he compare me with someone from utter pardesh
These are people of UP

 

[GURU DUTT]

A Tamil Muslim ,hindu or christian no matter where he is has love for a fellow tamilian...I recently read a Facebook message of ar rahman paying tribute to apj Abdul kalam where he said something like apj Abdul kalam showed how a Tamil can influence all India(in other words he was saying that he was proud of apj being Tamil).

The same can be said of malayalis ...Wherever they go they remain united irrespective of their religion....Gujarati ,Marathi ,Telugus and bengalis do have their own communities in many countries.

Do punjabis of pak and India share that brotherhood?or are the memories of partititon still fresh in their minds?has Islam wiped off any feeling or identity with Punjabi and its culture?

punjabies i know most of them or their granparents have bad memories of pakistan so they dont have any love for punjabies from across the border but cant say anything about how punjabies from across the border feel about punjabies of india

 

[Squashh]

And in terms of face features and color our punjabis are way more good looking than indian punjabis.I am surprised how can he compare me with someone from utter pardesh
These are people of UP

Poverty is a bigger problem than beauty...

 

[Zibago]

being a half punjabi i dont hate indian punjabis and wand day zakham halay vi haray nay par asi o sarian talkh yadaan pula ditian

punjabies i know most of them or their granparents have bad memories of pakistan so they dont have any love for punjabies from across the border but cant say anything about how punjabies from across the border feel about punjabies of india

same how you feel about them

indian punjabis are not real punjabis cuz real punjabis eat paye,bongaan with tilaan alay kulchay for breakfast hena @Armstrong hahaha

I think you are right..but feeling of Bengali nationalism has been there on both sides...but I don't get the feeling that even bengalis from both sides love each other.

We have significant population of Urdu speaking Muslims here in telangana...most of their homes get Telugu newspapers..they watch Telugu movies and serials as much as they watch Hindi ones.

One of my Muslim friends had been to Dubai once in search of a job..He told me there is a place there where all the daily telugu labourers gather in the morning before going to work...whenever he passed them(listening to them speaking Telugu) during jumma namaz,he would get a feeling of comfort and relief.

Even though he was a Urdu speaking Muslim ,he didn't get that feeling when he saw a UP Muslim or a Bihari Muslim....I believe it is very difficult to tell what makes a society or a group to develop that feeling of oneness or closeness.

It can't be language or religion alone.

Punjab has always been divided on religous lines in pre partition lahore muslims were not even allowed to touch the taps used by brahmin pandits

I am Punjabi and I hate Sikhs. They are worse than the dotheads for me.

ouch

Don't teach me how Punjabis look or you must not be a Punjabi

There is no such thing as a punjabi look it totally depends on your biradri(caste or tribe) your social status and area

 

[ito]

There is no such thing as a punjabi look it totally depends on your biradri(caste or tribe) your social status and area

Yes...looks depends on your biradri and your social status, it is also same in India too...but there is a 'Punjabi look'..I don't mean every Punjabi will have that look.

A typical 'Punjabi' look

 

[Long Live India]

NO, A big NO. Indian Punjabis does not have any special affection for Pakistani Punjabis. Majority of population in Indian side of Punjab comprise of Sikhs and they don't like punjabis from other side of the border. They can live with them but feel nothing special about Punjabis from other side of the border.

 

[graphican]

I am from Punjab and I very easily relate with Indian Sardas. I begin "O ke haal ea Sardar jee" and the Sard would start in friendly tone. I greeted a Sardar jee who was driving a buss and after asking where I was from, Sardar jee refused to take ticket for the trip and drove me free.

Sardars do not consider themselves Indians and introduce themselves are "from Punjab" and this aspect burs several non-Punjabi Indians.

 

[Shamain]

And in terms of face features and color our punjabis are way more good looking than indian punjabis.I am surprised how can he compare me with someone from utter pardesh
These are people of UP

Up and bihar are the poorest indian states. And they also host very high number of muslim population. And well u wont be surprised muslim localities are the poorest in both states.
Plus indians themselves make fun of up and bihar and say pakistan let go of kashmir dispute and take up and bihar from us.

Btw ,t he way india is desperate for gb and ajk due to strategic relevance no wonder they might wanna do that too.

But again they are the poorest states and always hurts me to see humans' and most imprtantly muslims' suffering there.

Aur badsurat koi nahi hota, indians alongside being haters are also very racist ppl. Example ,look at ito's comments in this thread on ur looks. And then the obsession for fair complexion. Seriously this ito , he needs to shutup ,seriously needs to cut his racist crap.

There also exists a lot of color racism between north and south india, south indians are more dark in complexion and get mocked by north indians, south indians in return give them back their own forms of racisms or reactions.

Yes...looks depends on your biradri and your social status, it is also same in India too...but there is a 'Punjabi look'..I don't mean every Punjabi will have that look.

A typical 'Punjabi' look

Lolzzzzzzz. Indians world revolves too much around bollywood and showbiz.

@fakhre mirpur what is 'bogan with tilaay' ?

I am from Punjab and I very easily relate with Indian Sardas. I begin "O ke haal ea Sardar jee" and the Sard would start in friendly tone. I greeted a Sardar jee who was driving a buss and after asking where I was from, Sardar jee refused to take ticket for the trip and drove me free.

Sardars do not consider themselves Indians and introduce themselves are "from Punjab" and this aspect burs several non-Punjabi Indians.

This is a common thing amongst pakistanis to address sikhs as sardar jees because pakistanis are generally very wellbehaved and courteous race when they meet outsiders. U wud notice that during the pilgrimage days when skihs are visiting lahore.

But again i never forget the history, bloodshed, i know no one is our wellwisher at the end of the day. What sikhs ,what hindus, what indians, all are in the same bracket in their hate for us.

 

[SHAMK9]

I don't know but Sikhs are cool, heck I like hanging out with sikhs rather than Indian muslims/hindus

 

[Mike_Brando]

I think you are right..but feeling of Bengali nationalism has been there on both sides...but I don't get the feeling that even bengalis from both sides love each other.

We have significant population of Urdu speaking Muslims here in telangana...most of their homes get Telugu newspapers..they watch Telugu movies and serials as much as they watch Hindi ones.

One of my Muslim friends had been to Dubai once in search of a job..He told me there is a place there where all the daily telugu labourers gather in the morning before going to work...whenever he passed them(listening to them speaking Telugu) during jumma namaz,he would get a feeling of comfort and relief.

Even though he was a Urdu speaking Muslim ,he didn't get that feeling when he saw a UP Muslim or a Bihari Muslim....I believe it is very difficult to tell what makes a society or a group to develop that feeling of oneness or closeness.

It can't be language or religion alone.

Anna,i am a Bengali and believe me we(i mean the majority of the Bengalis) don't have any sort love or affinity for our Bangaldeshi counterparts even though half of my family was from erstwhile East Bengal(present day Bangaldesh).Although we speak the same language the reality is that we are poles apart when it comes to culture and tradition.I mean you'll be surprised to find that the Bengalis share a more cultural similarities with the Odiyas than with the Bangaldeshis.Plus,most of us have suffered the wrath of partition and hence will never forget the treatment that was meted out to our forefathers by their BD counterparts.

 

[SecularNationalist]

Yes...looks depends on your biradri and your social status, it is also same in India too...but there is a 'Punjabi look'..I don't mean every Punjabi will have that look.

A typical 'Punjabi' look

So i grow a mustache and i will be like him
By the way i am not a pure punjabi my father is all from jhelum punjab and my mother family immigrated from Afghanistan they belong to the durrani tribe.

 

[GHOST RIDER]

If they are Indians
Regardless of ethnicity

Then their is no love for them