Can We Really Consider Urdu as a National Language of Pakistan?

[Joe Shearer]

In style there are huge differences.

But it's the same Shalwar Kameez, right? It doesn't change into a dhoti and kurta?

 

[MultaniGuy]

Indian Salwar Kameez

Pakistani Shalwar Kameez

Usually Pakistani Shalwar Kameez is much baggier, while Indian ones are usually associated with Churidar pyjamas.

Even in India they don't spell it Shalwar they spell it "salwar."

 

[El Sidd]

You can still provide the unintentional light relief.



And that is the significance of Urdu? Occurring with prescient wisdom right out then in 1947?

You are truly a superior mind, far too superior for this forum.

"...Urdu me national language me bolonga to kargil hojaega or phir hum discuss karenge kay 1999 me kon kese Bach gaya..."

With leadership such as yours, India is safe and secure.



Neither is English.

It is beyond your comprehension.

 

[Joe Shearer]

It is beyond your comprehension.

Thank Heavens for that.

My hopes for my country's future, given the bunch of clowns governing it at the moment, lies solely in the fact it is you and the likes of you who form the hostile forces.

. Latest Indian Patiala shalwar kameez fashion 2015-2016 (6)

Indian models, modelling their typical churidar bottoms and running around mispronouncing these 'salwar', thereby reinforcing Pakistani pride in their distinct identity and their complete, monastic segregation from anything Indian.

Conclusion: I have done something truly evil in my previous janma, and am being punished by being engaged in conversation by superior beings.

 

[MultaniGuy]

Thank Heavens for that.

My hopes for my country's future, given the bunch of clowns governing it at the moment, lies solely in the fact it is you and the likes of you who form the hostile forces.

. Latest Indian Patiala shalwar kameez fashion 2015-2016 (6)

Indian models, modelling their typical churidar bottoms and running around mispronouncing these 'salwar', thereby reinforcing Pakistani pride in their distinct identity and their complete, monastic segregation from anything Indian.

Conclusion: I have done something truly evil in my previous janma, and am being punished by being engaged in conversation by superior beings.

Indian say "salwar" not Shalwar.

Give it up, we do not share the same culture.

In Pakistan revealing fashions are not acceptable as it is in India.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Indian say "salwar" not Shalwar.

Give it up, we do not share the same culture.

In Pakistan revealing fashions are not acceptable as it is in India.

Ah, that of course is definitive. There would not have been any Hindu emerging out of Sindhu had it not been for the same mispronunciation.

Which of the illustrations did you find revealing?

 

[SQ8]

Remove Urdu, and disunite Pakistan- end of story. End of unity , End of country.

 

[padamchen]

Indian Salwar Kameez

Pakistani Shalwar Kameez

Usually Pakistani Shalwar Kameez is much baggier, while Indian ones are usually associated with Churidar pyjamas.

Even in India they don't spell it Shalwar they spell it "salwar."

It's called Patiala man.

Some of you guys are astonishingly unaware of women fashion.

Like yesterday there was a nerd who claimed that a backless dress without a visible strap automatically meant no brassiere.

Spend less time here and more with women. Would help.

Cheers, Doc

 

[MultaniGuy]

Ah, that of course is definitive. There would not have been any Hindu emerging out of Sindhu had it not been for the same mispronunciation.

Which of the illustrations did you find revealing?

The second photo. lol

It's called Patiala man.

Some of you guys are astonishingly unaware of women fashion.

Like yesterday there was a nerd who claimed that a backless dress without a visible strap automatically meant no brassiere.

Spend less time here and more with women. Would help.

Cheers, Doc

I don't know if Patiala style Shalwar is the same as the regular Pakistani Shalwar Kameez suit.

I think there is a difference. The Patiala style has pleatings in it.

I like your sense of humor padamchen.

 

[xyxmt]

In fact, Indians themselves today should be speaking Urdu as opposed to Hindi.

They actually do speak Urdu not Hindi, what they call Hindi movies are Urdu movies, all their songs are Urdu songs mostly written by muslim poets

 

[MultaniGuy]

Usually Pakistani Shalwar Kameez is very baggy

Indian men's Kurta Pyjama:

 

[Darth Vader]

So, today I was reading the opinions of Pakistanis in another thread and I was surprised to know that only 8% of the Pakistani population speaks Urdu as their mother tongue. As we all know that Urdu is the national language of Pakistan. And there are many other languages that are spoken by higher percentage of people as their mother tongue. So why was Urdu even made the national language of Pakistan even when there were many alternatives left? Even the origin of Urdu is in India, the arch rival of Pakistan. For comparison, Hindi have a much larger percentage of people speaking it as mother tongue in India but still it is not the National language of the nation. Infact, in India, there is no national Language and have only official languages.



Note : It is my first thread in PDF. So pardon me if there were any grammatical mistakes or the way of writing was a bit awkward.

As the Saying Goes
There Country there Rules. They can chose whatever they like

 

[Joe Shearer]

They actually do speak Urdu not Hindi, what they call Hindi movies are Urdu movies, all their songs are Urdu songs mostly written by muslim poets

You are precisely right.

 

[MultaniGuy]

Usually Pakistanis wear Shalwars.

But Indians wear pyjamas, churidars, dhotis, and saris.

 

[padamchen]

You are precisely right.

Yup. We speak in Hindi but sing in Urdu. Fluent polyglots we are.

Cheers, Doc

The second photo. lol


I don't know if Patiala style Shalwar is the same as the regular Pakistani Shalwar Kameez suit.

I think there is a difference. The Patiala style has pleatings in it.

I like your sense of humor padamchen.

Yeah. Not so much pleats as descending drapes.

The inner architecture of women's clothes is a formidable science.

Not for the bumbling newbie with trembling fat fingers.

Cheers, Doc