Urdu belongs to India, not Pakistan : Javed Akhtar

[Foinikas]

Nope - water, air, food, etc can be generalized based on religion.

Any religious person who lives in India is included if you state they are Indian.

My good man,isn't the river called Indus river?! THAT'S WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT.

Why do you think I'm talking about religion?

 

[Trango Towers]

So what even if it is from Pakistan Egypt or outer space? It is a nice language with some beautiful poetry, lot of people use it, like it.

Why do even such good things become controversial

Very well said. Common sense but often eludes those we think have a brain like this javed shahib

 

[villageidiot]

If flows in IOK first before entering pakistan.

FTFY

 

[Trango Towers]

It still flows in India first before entering pakistan.

And before that it's from China.. what's your point here?

 

[SABRE]

Name "India" belongs to Pakistan not Hindustan/Bharat. Let's exchange.

 

[hunter_hunted]

River is important for all living things including mankind.

You should respect it.

Thats why you dump sewerage and dead bodies in Ganga

 

[uhuru]

Indian muslims and their urge to prove holier than the pope.

Neither India or Pakistan can claim monopoly over a language. But trust the Indians to stoop down to this level to create a news out of it.

In a way maybe it is true. Look at Pakistan, if i watch the news - it is jumbled up english; then the other side hinglish galore with Pakistan's inferior complex is try to copy.

Here we have idarah za kiswahili that keeps luagaa safi - clean language - every year new words are added. Swahili is the national language and promoted as the only language of official business unless you are dealing with external parties. Do you have the same in Pakistan?

 

[Al_Muhannad]

And before that it's from China.. what's your point here?

May both Pakistan and bharat belongs to China.

Starting from 2022, there is way too much fucking indianess here.

 

[AgnosticIndian]

I'm having serious deja vu at this. As if this same thread, with the same responses, from the same posters has been seen before. It probably really has been, considering how repetitive this whole thing is.

Yeah, Urdu is the language of Indian Muslims, and for any person, left or right, secular or religious, Hindu or Muslim, Urdu has the same connotations as whatever connotations "Indian Muslim" has, even if they say that it's not a language of a religion. Nobody hates Urdu because it is a "Pakistani" language, that would be as if Hindu nationalists disliked Islam because it's the "Pakistani religion". It's the other way around. I doubt anyone seriously believes. Not even the Pakistanis themselves, and not even Hindu nationalists.

 

[Skimming]

Technically, he’s not wrong. Reading the comments by Indians on this thread and on others, I’m going to write a piece on their national psyche. I think it’s time we have an important discussion/put a spotlight on it.

What a waste of time!!! What you get from it?

 

[AA_]

What a waste of time!!! What you get from it?

Personal satisfaction, and I like research and analysis.

 

[Trango Towers]

May both Pakistan and bharat belongs to China.

Starting from 2022, there is way too much fucking indianess here.

Lool...u want to be Indian?

 

[Al_Muhannad]

Lool...u want to be Indian?

That’s not what it meant.

I prefer being labelled savage-from-1400-years-ago over indian. Never make a compromise that low.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

Lahori esi bandar de tattay toh toh ki pi re si kuch hafte pelay.

 

[AA_]

Lahori esi bandar de tattay toh toh ki pi re si kuch hafte pelay.

No, certain individuals from Lahore acted this way.