BD-Myanmar sea boundary arbitration case!

[Avisheik]

BNP is basically Anti India and its their political stand , ... Can you bring to light any major incident where India has coerced Bangladesh into toeing Indias line or caused problem militarily or otherwise to Bangladesh people ? There is more rumor and allegations than truth . All India want is transit route to reach NE of India which is severely deprived of inclusive growth that rest of India is seeing .

Basically India wants strong and friendly relationship with BD but there is people who are using it a political mileage to target each other . There is more misunderstanding than anything else.

Well certain elements of the BNP is anti-indian. However BNP, is more keen on relationship with china, which does not mean that they hate india.

There hasnt been much military actions against each other, but we bangladeshis are mostly worried about economy and water when it comes to india. ANd then there is the never ending debate about the transit fees

 

[Deepak123]

1) Burma is giving transit, Bangladesh is giving corridor

Both are giving same stuff. But oppositions in your country are making as if Bangladesh is providing everything free for cheap politics. Don't tell us you are providing free Transit or asked nothing for Palatana project, you got or will gett money in different way but you Bangladeshi only care about the label "Only Transit Free in Dollar Only" on the money.

2) Burma IS IN SOUTH EAST ASIA, The moment you step in burma you are in south east asia.

Both Burma and Bangladesh are in "Look East Policy" for India when it comes to economy and trade.

3) For japan and korea, you need to co-operate with malaysia or singapore to trade. I dont know how you get burma in the equation.

Recently India and Japan signed a deal with South East Asia country to for a trade corridor through Vietnam, Thailand and Myanmar for less time consuming high speed trade corridor with ports and Roads network.

4) How about stopping your local population from selling cows to bdeshis, and stop corruption within BSF first. With low supply i bet it wont be finacially rewarding for them to smuggle cows from india

Well smuggling is a problem but bigger problem is denial by Bangladesh( both BAL and BNP ) about illegal immigration into India who you don't know how much headache created for us. You guys are showing stubborn attitude so expect stubborn attitude from us in return. So, can you tell me what Bangladesh is doing to stop illegal immigration till now, so why you people are expecting lot from us. When we were constructing Barbed wire-fence, your BDR was creating nuisance in constructing it.

 

[Avisheik]

Both are giving same stuff. But oppositions in your country are making as if Bangladesh is providing everything free for cheap politics. Don't tell us you are providing free Transit or asked nothing for Palatana project, you got or will gett money in different way but you Bangladeshi only care about the label "Only Transit Free in Dollar Only" on the money.


Both Burma and Bangladesh are in "Look East Policy" for India when it comes to economy and trade.



Recently India and Japan signed a deal with South East Asia country to for a trade corridor through Vietnam, Thailand and Myanmar for less time consuming high speed trade corridor with ports and Roads network.



Well smuggling is a problem but bigger problem is denial by Bangladesh( both BAL and BNP ) about illegal immigration into India who you don't know how much headache created for us. You guys are showing stubborn attitude so expect stubborn attitude from us in return. So, can you tell me what Bangladesh is doing to stop illegal immigration till now, so why you people are expecting lot from us. When we were constructing Barbed wire-fence, your BDR was creating nuisance in constructing it.

Transit and corridor isnt the same stuff. Technically yes, you are getting free transit. We are using that 1 billion dollar loan from india, for which we can mostly use for to buy indian goods to build the transit infrastructure, then pay you back the billion dollars+interest. So we should be getting transit fee in dolar only.

SO??? That policy does not change the geography of South east asia.

Well that makes more sense. I thought you were saying burma alone allowed trade to japan

Most of the illegal migration, are done by cattle smugglers. However they are not there to stay in india. As for the permanent migration from BD to india, i dont think there is much immgration in that cause. Basically because its not financially feasible to take the risk of going to india and face the same economic consequences as well. BDR was causing a rucus cause they claimed The construction of the fence was intruding and taking up land of bangladesh.

 

[CONTINUATOR]

Well smuggling is a problem but bigger problem is denial by Bangladesh( both BAL and BNP ) about illegal immigration into India who you don't know how much headache created for us. You guys are showing stubborn attitude so expect stubborn attitude from us in return. So, can you tell me what Bangladesh is doing to stop illegal immigration till now, so why you people are expecting lot from us. When we were constructing Barbed wire-fence, your BDR was creating nuisance in constructing it.

I am from NE Indian Bengali Hindu. My parents migrated to India in 1971, basically it took them almost 4 years to get all the relatives to India. I am born in India. Migration is a fact but the way it was portrayed by our Assamese brothers are totally misleading and baseless. Most of the people labelled as illegal immigrant are the landless people who were displaced by Bhramaputra erosion. They are floating poor people have no permanent address. I seen some Bihari Muslims migrated from Bangladesh but never seen any Bengali Muslim migrated. We have a distinct immigrant community who keeps in touch with one another so I know the facts.

 

[extra terrestrial]

well, If there is a war between Bangladesh and Myanmar, I don't think China and India will have any interest here thus they won't interfere in this matter, all they would do is to hold some useless peace meetings!! If I'm not wrong, as of now we are quite ahead of Myanmar in terms of military progress, so if there is a war, the result would be the defeat of Myanmar and possibly an independent Arakan!!

 

[Zabaniyah]

I am from NE Indian Bengali Hindu. My parents migrated to India in 1971, basically it took them almost 4 years to get all the relatives to India. I am born in India. Migration is a fact but the way it was portrayed by our Assamese brothers are totally misleading and baseless. Most of the people labelled as illegal immigrant are the landless people who were displaced by Bhramaputra erosion. They are floating poor people have no permanent address. I seen some Bihari Muslims migrated from Bangladesh but never seen any Bengali Muslim migrated. We have a distinct immigrant community who keeps in touch with one another so I know the facts.

That explains all the whining we see here...

Thanks for informing buddy And to

 

[Maira La]

well, If there is a war between Bangladesh and Myanmar, I don't think China and India will have any interest here thus they won't interfere in this matter, all they would do is to hold some useless peace meetings!! If I'm not wrong, as of now we are quite ahead of Myanmar in terms of military progress, so if there is a war, the result would be the defeat of Myanmar and possibly an independent Arakan!!

+1 for independent Arakan! There was a time when Arakan was separate from the kingdoms of jungle men. We must help the Arakanese people fight back, covertly.

 

[NeutralCitizen]

Myanmar will win Bangladesh won't win thats the truth.

 

[DarkPrince]

Myanmar will win Bangladesh won't win thats the truth.

if a war happens u ll see

 

[Zabaniyah]

Myanmar will win Bangladesh won't win thats the truth.

Have you read what was discussed in this thread and the statements from the US itself? Bangladesh has no reason to go to war with Myanmar. And neither has Myanmar. If Myanmar attacks us, the US will get involved.

And we are sufficient in defending ourselves from a Burmese attack. Bangladesh Army follows a defensive doctrine and not centered around any particular country.

Read through the damn topic before posting useless comments.

 

[NeutralCitizen]

if a war happens u ll see how wins

You won't for sure your Military is defensive and weaker. Myanmar will take the Chittagong region.

---------- Post added at 12:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:44 PM ----------

Have you read what was discussed in this thread and the statements from the US itself? Bangladesh has no reason to go to war with Myanmar. And neither has Myanmar. And if Myanmar attacks us, the US will get involved.

Read through the damn topic before posting useless comments.

They will try and prevent a war but the fact is Myanmar is stronger then Bangladesh, the Bangladeshi military is just defensive and weak compared to Myanmar.

---------- Post added at 12:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:45 PM ----------

Chittagong region will belong to Myanmar if war comes.

 

[DarkPrince]

You won't for sure your Military is defensive and weaker. Myanmar will take the Chittagong region.

BD is master in guerrilla warfare
yes they will enter chittagong
just entering is not winning

 

[NeutralCitizen]

BD is master in guerrilla warfare
yes they will enter chittagong
just entering is not winning

No your not you, several countries ahead of you in being masters of guerrilla warfare, just poor Bangladeshi nationalists we can't see the reality. Better stay on the good side of Myanmar otherwise you will lose land.

 

[Zabaniyah]

They will try and prevent a war but the fact is Myanmar is stronger then Bangladesh, the Bangladeshi military is just defensive and weak compared to Myanmar.

Chittagong region will belong to Myanmar if war comes.

And I suppose you are speaking from experience? Chittagong Hill Tracts is not easy to invade.

They dare invade either Bangladesh or Thailand, that'd be the end of the Burmese Junta.

Get it now?

No your not you, several countries ahead of you in being masters of guerrilla warfare, just poor Bangladeshi nationalists we can't see the reality. Better stay on the good side of Myanmar otherwise you will lose land.

What does that mean?

 

[DarkPrince]

No your not you, several countries ahead of you in being masters of guerrilla warfare, just poor Bangladeshi nationalists we can't see the reality. Better stay on the good side of Myanmar otherwise you will lose land.

its u who cant see the reality