Would you support sending all Afghani Refugees back to Afghanistan?? Vote..

[scionoftheindus]

They should be sent back to build their beloved caves. They will never be loyal to Pakistan so there is no question of giving them citizenship. Their hatred for Pakistan despite giving them shelter will always be there no matter what you do.

And their hatred is justifiable...you were the biggest contributors in bringing violence to their country..you people poked in their matters saying ummah,chummah etc etc..they were called your brothers..isn't one Muslim a brother to another Muslim?afghans didn't ask you to meddle in their matters..it is extremely unfair to send them back now...even international community doesn't support it.

 

[Psychic]

You oould be member of racist organisation in Pakistan who hates other ethnics and refugees. You have lot of company especially in Europe.

Ok

 

[ArsalanKhan21]

Should have been expelled ages ago.

They could have gone back to Afghanistan 25 years ago only if Pakistan would have not supported Talibans. Blame also lies with some Pakistani institutions and you know who.

 

[scionoftheindus]

Afghan refugees in our country are not on PICNIC or Entertainment itinerary
.
There country is burning in WAR and they've no other option except us.....they're not staying in my HOME....or in my street....they're living mercilessly in open sky under severe weather condition (called Afghan Basti) .....they can never apply for any JOB...they are not allowed to take admissioin in Gov Schools....they;ve no right to PROTEST for their basic rights.......we hate them screw them for what?? ...If some of their Bad Guys are involved in illegad trade .then what??....We do have much bigger prominent Hard Nut Crackers like MQM, Zardari....(its no point of debate...its total lawlessness issue)
.
.
Look Guys...Our foundation of Independence under Jinnah was laid on what Principles??

Under the Principle....Mohajirs from india are allowed to migrate in Pak Lands....but same cant be done to Afghans....?? highly selfish attitude

Very well said brother..we should think on humanitarian grounds

 

[Menace2Society]

They could have gone back to Afghanistan 20 years ago only if Pakistan would have not supported Talibans.

Yes big bad ISI mobilized thousands of Afghans to rebel against the state for their strategic depth.

This Indian myth which has been peddled around and many Pakistanis believe it such as yourself.

Let me tell you reality. Afghanistan has been a basket case since day 1. It can't be helped. Afghans need to sort themselves out.

Pakistan never went into FATA and left the border areas for the tribals on both sides to do as they wish out of goodwill, see how thats turned out.

If Pakistan wanted to be a cunt of a neighbour it would have secured the entire border and not given a single shit what happens in Afghanistan but they didn't. They took in millions of refugees even though they were starving themselves.

 

[Djinn]

They could have gone back to Afghanistan 20 years ago only if Pakistan would have not supported Talibans.

If Pakistan had not supported them, there wouldn't have been any Afghanistan.

 

[ArsalanKhan21]

Yes big bad ISI mobilized thousands of Afghans to rebel against the state for their strategic depth.

Exactly ! Sometimes actions have unforseen consequences.

If Pakistan had not supported them, there wouldn't have been any Afghanistan.

What do you mean ? Pakistan could have joined with Iran to create a national government in Afghanistan instead both supported rival groups.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

@Psychic


Read about PEGIDA in Europe who want to throw all Muslims out UK, Germany and all the West including USA, Australia etc. Which of you agree with this and if you don't than how can you do the same thing in Pakistan. How are you differant from PEGIDA?

At least read the link on Wiki about PEGIDA and then think about the moral equivalence and the two faced hypocracy. Don't give me excuses because trust me in Europe they are sick of Muslims and they give many reasons like terrorism, drugs, sex grooming gangs and taking their jobs. There was a Italian member here called Markus who espoused those very views and I had a tangle with him. How are you guy's differant. Your just brown Markus that is all. I am not going reply anymore in case I say something silly. I owe that to the admin. but please think about the article beliw and look at those pictures. They had million man marches. That is what P-E-G-I-D-A stands for.

Patriotic Europeans Against the Islamisation of the West

(German: Patriotische Europäer gegen die Islamisierung des Abendlandes), abbreviated PEGIDA and Pegida, is a German far right anti-Islam[1][2][3] political organisation founded in Dresden in October 2014. It organized weekly demonstrations from October to February against what it considers the Islamisation of the Western world, calling for more restrictive immigration rules, particularly for Muslims. It seeks to alter German immigration legislation so that it becomes similar to Australian immigration programs and Canadian immigration categories. Offshoots of Pegida were formed in various countries.

Pegida - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[Djinn]

What do you mean ? Pakistan could have joined with Iran to create a national government in Afghanistan instead both supported rival groups.

On the the contrary if Americans hadn't deserted Afghanistan after Soviets defeat, things would have been a lot different. Pakistan played it's role well, it's the Americans who didn't see things through and took off.

 

[ArsalanKhan21]

On the the contrary if Americans hadn't deserted Afghanistan after Soviets defeat, things would have been a lot different. Pakistan played it's role well, it's the Americans who didn't see things through and took off.

What do you mean by that ? They helped Taliban to come to power and suppress other ethnic groups. Made mockery with their barbaric rule.

 

[Menace2Society]

On the the contrary if Americans hadn't deserted Afghanistan after Soviets defeat, things would have been a lot different. Pakistan played it's role well, it's the Americans who didn't see things through and took off.

Its all Pakistanis fault.

Iran and India funding Northern Alliance who were headed up by Uzbek brutal mercenaries who were the same people who massacred the children in Peshawar has nothing do to with anything. All Pakistans fault.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

@Psychic

EDL in UK - They want all Muslims kicked out. Read this link and see what they say. How are you people any differant other than your brown????

EDL member arrested after 'Breivik' bomb threat against Muslims - EDL News

 

[ArsalanKhan21]

Iran and India funding Northern Alliance who were headed up by Uzbek brutal mercenaries who were the same people who massacred the children in Peshawar has nothing do to with anything. All Pakistans fault.

We could have collaborated with Iran to create a unity government. Hindsight is 20/20. Now why do you want to send same people back to Afghanistan when there is still lingering civil war ? Ghani seems to be friendly person and we take this opportunity to create peace in Afghanistan so that Afghans can go back to their homes.

 

[Djinn]

What do you mean by that ? They helped Taliban to come to power and suppress other ethnic groups. Made mockery with their barbaric rule.

Pakistan only did what was deemed necessary for the status quo of that time. You cant turn a blind eye to Americans treachery and blame it entirely on Pakistan. Americans helped create Taliban's, did Pakistan ever have the capability to deal with them unilaterally? The answer is NO!!!!!

 

[Menace2Society]

We could have collaborated with Iran to create a unity government. Hindsight is 20/20. Now why do you want to send same people back to Afghanistan when there is still lingering civil war ?

Iran didn't want to collaborate. Mullah regime didn't take kindly to Pakistan. They picked India's side and created civil war JUST BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T WANT PAKISTANI INFLUENCE. You see the difference there? Pakistan did what they did to make Afghanistan invincible against invading Soviets and some semblance of a unified voice even if it was Taliban, it was something.

Let me teach you another reality.

Afghan society only worship strength. Generosity is considered a weakness. The same is the case for many African tribes. This is why they worship the ground India and Iran walk on because they treat them like dirt. Pakistanis don't so we get the abuse, cross border revenge attacks for stuff that we are not even responsible for etc etc.