Avicenna
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 18, 2016
- Messages
- 5,795
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
Wing Commander Nauman Ali Khan downed the IAF Su-30MKI (first kill) and Squadron Leader Hasan Siddiqui downed the IAF MiG-21 (second kill). IAF Mil Mi-17 downed at the same time was a fratricide.
I have confirmed this from my source in PAF.
PAF has not officially claimed the downing of a Su-30MKI yet. It has only officially claimed that two IAF fighters were shot down (through DG ISPR), one of which turned out to be a MiG-21. So the PAF has not taken any aircraft names. I do believe that the PAF will claim the Su-30MKI downing in the near future. Even the PAF pilots' names who downed the two Indian jets have not been released officially, although they have been leaked and everyone now knows who those pilots are.
There is no evidence of the Su-30MKI debris with Pakistan because the wreckage fell in Indian-Occupied Kashmir, which has been covered up by the Indian Air Force because it was too embarrassing to admit. The only reason the IAF admitted the downing of its MiG-21 and Wg. Cdr. Abhinandan was because Pakistan had the wreckage and the pilot. The fate of the Su-30 pilots is unknown but both most likely ejected according to PAF sources as well as civilian witnesses who saw two parachutes deploy, most likely landing on the Indian side. However, it is not known, which side they landed. If one is with Pakistan, then India is in a Catch-22 situation. If it asks for the pilot, then it has to admit that a Su-30MKI was shot down. If it doesn't, then the pilot remains in Pakistani custody to be revealed at the appropriate time.
The reason the PAF may not officially own up to the Su-30MKI downing (at least in the foreseeable future) is probably two-fold:
1. The Su-30MKI was probably shot down by an F-16 (saving grace for India) using an AIM-120 AMRAAM and PAF doesn't want to annoy the Americans. I believe the IAF salvaged the AIM-120 pieces from the wreckage of the downed Su-30MKI.
2. It doesn't want to annoy the Russians because the Russians will be embarrassed if a Russian-made fighter with Russian missiles was shot down by either a JF-17 or F-16. Pakistan needs Russian support in many areas, least of all for the JF-17's RD-93 engines.
I don't believe that the IAF can cover up a Su-30MKI loss for too long. Sooner or later the story will come out.
The most sensible and likely post on this thread.