What's new

Why China isn’t ready to invade Taiwan – yet

no india has nothing to do with china , others may come to fight for china .

Who? Trump? Don't kid yourself. Trump can't even keep the US government open much less fight WW3 with China. That's way out of his league. Anyway, he's done for come 2020 election.
 
. .
China will take one more decade of preparation to attack Taiwan. I like it.
 
.
  • The Taiwan question is caused by the Chinese civil war,
  • now some people think they are not Chinese, some people still insist that they are Chinese,
  • So we are biding our time to recover Taiwan with the least cost

China claims Taiwan as province. Sooner or later they take it. Russia took 60 years to take back Crimea.
 
.
President Xi Jinping wants to restore China to its former glory – and that means bringing Taiwan under the Communist Party’s control, one way or another.

That was the gist of Xi’s direction-setting New Year’s speech on Jan. 2, when he addressed a packed house at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing. Xi’s speech marked 40 years since China stopped regular artillery bombardment of Taiwan-controlled islands off the Chinese coast. While he spoke at length about peace, he also made it clear that he’s running out of patience for polite politics.

“We are willing to create a vast space for peaceful unification, but we will never leave any room for any sort of Taiwan independence or separatist activities,” Xi said from his seat at the front of the auditorium. He then directly addressed the scope of action China may use to enforce this: “We do not promise to renounce the use of force and reserve the option to use all necessary measures.”

Xi’s comments sparked a rebuke from Taiwan’s president, Tsai Ing-wen. “China must face the fact of the existence of Taiwan, and not deny the system of a democratic county that has been commonly built up by the Taiwanese people,” she said in a speech the next day.

Tsai’s pro-independence party, the Democratic Progressive Party, replaced the China-friendly Kuomintang party in 2016, making it less likely than ever that Taipei will accept a peaceful “reunification” with the Communist-governed mainland. If anything, the back-and-forth might cement the two sides in opposition to one another.

Xi’s comments are raising fears of a military conflict between the two sides, even if it’s not China’s preferred option. Taiwan announced a new round of military drills aimed at fending off invasion after Xi’s remarks, and President Tsai has asked international leaders to pledge their help in the event of a crisis.

Despite the escalating rhetoric, experts tell Global News an imminent military conflict is unlikely.

While Ian Easton, a research fellow at the Project 2049 Institute, says “this is a very dangerous flashpoint,” he points out that China would fail if it tried to invade Taiwan in 2019. However, China’s chances for victory will be much greater in five-to-10 years, once it’s finished building up its military.


“The farther forward you project, the more likely it becomes that there will be a military crisis in the Taiwan Strait,” said Easton, author of the book The Chinese Invasion Threat: Taiwan’s Defense and American Strategy in Asia. “They’re building up all the capabilities that they would need to launch a potential invasion of Taiwan at some point in the next decade.”

Here’s why China is so focused on controlling Taiwan, and why it probably can’t take over the island by force – at least for now.

The enemy next door
China has long viewed Taiwan as a rogue province run by nationalists who never accepted losing the Chinese Civil War in 1949, when Mao Zedong’s Communists rose to power. Taiwan views itself as a free and democratic country that stands apart from the controlling Communist Party. However, it can’t officially declare it’s full independence from China, lest it face some form of attack.

Many western nations treated Taiwan as the “true” China until 40 years ago, when the Communist government in Beijing started reaching out to the world. That same year, in 1979, the U.S. shifted diplomatic relations to Beijing while promising to continue selling weapons to Taiwan for its defence.

President Xi’s speech on Jan. 2 marked that anniversary.

Taiwan – which officially calls itself the Republic of China – occupies a large island separated from mainland China by the Taiwan Strait, a 160-kilometre-wide stretch of water off China’s east coast. The self-governed island of approximately 23.6 million people has strong economy with a gross domestic product of approximately US$572 billion. It’s a booming hub for technology, shipping and banking, and it occupies a key strategic position between China and the Pacific Ocean.

more at https://globalnews.ca/news/4837941/china-taiwan-invasion-attack/
Another twisted fact explanation. Xi never say he is impatient for reunification but just leaves no room for any independence movement from Taiwan. He is just warning the pro taiwanese party to think of the consequences. These pro independence party are the real autocratic. Taiwan mid term election with overwhelming taiwanese vote to keep Chinese Taipei name for upcoming 2020 Olympic shows most taiwanese do not support pro independence movement while it's the top government keep pushing independence movent against the majority.
 
.
There is a sure way for Taiwan to maintain independence from mainland China and avoid war forever: dig the dirt at its west coast and dump it at its east coast.
 
.
It will take forever for China to invade Taiwan....May be a tectonic shift will bring Taiwan to China!

Jokes Apart, when was the Last time China ever went to war? I think with Vietnam? The entire generation of Chinese soldiers have never seen blood.....raw blood coming out during war.

Let China first go to Africa(though they are there) and settle some conflicts there, get involved and see what war looks and feels like. Then only they should think of invading. Producing high tech equipments isn't enough.
 
.
Jokes Apart, when was the Last time China ever went to war? I think with Vietnam? The entire generation of Chinese soldiers have never seen blood.....raw blood coming out during war.

These days killing people in war is playing video game.



Then only they should think of invading.

They are not doing amphibious landing. They bomb infrastructure and force Taiwan to surrender. No Russia soldier was hurt taking back Crimea.
 
.
It will take forever for China to invade Taiwan....May be a tectonic shift will bring Taiwan to China!

Jokes Apart, when was the Last time China ever went to war? I think with Vietnam? The entire generation of Chinese soldiers have never seen blood.....raw blood coming out during war.

Let China first go to Africa(though they are there) and settle some conflicts there, get involved and see what war looks and feels like. Then only they should think of invading. Producing high tech equipments isn't enough.
War experience is over rated. It is just a big excuse by slayers trying to put down China military might. Iraqi full of war experience from their 1980-1988 iraqi-iran war can't even withstand coalition forces for a month in 1991 gulf war who has not fought major war for 18years. Tell me why Iraq lost the war badly since they are so experience?

Key to superior forces in modern conventional warfare are well trained and we'll equipped troops. It will truimph highly war experience soldier who everyday fought Taliban caveman and lack training in modern warfare. :enjoy:

China with 2nd largest military budget and far lower cost per soldier compare to US.
 
.
Depends how fast America declines. China will attack as soon as they can.

China can devastate Taiwan without sacrificing 1 man. All those power plants are sitting targets.

based on the news article that started this thread and this opinion (noting it's from a Canadian too), i recommend the Raiwanese government to try to make this peaceful unification proposal by China work.

we can not start a massive nuclear war over keeping Taiwan protected, or any other kind of major war between two militaries that by then might indeed be on equal footing, because the armies involved would be huge and powerful.

that means the Taiwanese government, military and intel circles, in my opinion should yield, before they bring themselves or (large) other nations into war over their continued future refusal to give up political power over the Taiwanese island.
it would be dangerously foolish to assume the military balance of power still allows NATO to *easily* keep Taiwan free in a political sense. even under communist control, you'd have enough personal freedoms as people just living on the Taiwanese island, for us not to risk millions upon millions of lives over that.
 
.
Any move on Taiwan will trigger Japan's collective self defense. The strategic change of China getting Taiwan gives it open excess into the Pacific, thus consequently, open excess to the whole lower half of Japan for the PLAN to roam.

So then combine ghat with two more facts, that being the Taiwanese have yet to demonstrate the political desire in their elections for unification plus Taiwan being very friendly to Japan.

Japan would fight.

The Japanese islands south of Okinawa would make it very difficult for the PLAN. The JSDF is already deploying anti-air and anti-ship missiles there. Soryu subs would also make any naval encirclementment of Taiwan a real challenge for the PLAN. Some JGSDF brigades and divisions are being reorganized as fast respones units, which include the new Amphibious Rapid Deployment Brigade. The Izumo class destroyers will provide nearby air superiority missions with F-35Bs. Japanese bases have been developing rapid base reconstruction and aircraft dispersement pads to reduce the effect of BM bombardment.

The only way for unification to happen is will peaceful political action by the people in Taiwan, but there is no need for it, and they don't desire it. They want good relations with China so they don't offend so much, but they ceryainly don't want unification, not even the KMT. Had the KMT politicians been saying that they want unification, the Chinese posters would surely post it up. But there's nothing. KMT wants good relations with China. There is another political party that is very much for unification in a pro-CCP China way, but they are very tiny.
 
.
yet the iranian coast guard makes a mockery out of your Naval forces
If you think that capturing a few sailors and humiliating them make 'mighty' the Iranian navy, I hope the Pakistan and Iranian navies are filled with ignoramuses like you. You say these nonsensical things not because you have any actual military experience in general, let alone naval in particular, but because you need to satisfy a childish whim to make US look bad in spite of reality. In other word, you are delusional.
 
.
Any move on Taiwan will trigger Japan's collective self defense. The strategic change of China getting Taiwan gives it open excess into the Pacific, thus consequently, open excess to the whole lower half of Japan for the PLAN to roam.

So then combine ghat with two more facts, that being the Taiwanese have yet to demonstrate the political desire in their elections for unification plus Taiwan being very friendly to Japan.

Japan would fight.

The Japanese islands south of Okinawa would make it very difficult for the PLAN. The JSDF is already deploying anti-air and anti-ship missiles there. Soryu subs would also make any naval encirclementment of Taiwan a real challenge for the PLAN. Some JGSDF brigades and divisions are being reorganized as fast respones units, which include the new Amphibious Rapid Deployment Brigade. The Izumo class destroyers will provide nearby air superiority missions with F-35Bs. Japanese bases have been developing rapid base reconstruction and aircraft dispersement pads to reduce the effect of BM bombardment.

The only way for unification to happen is will peaceful political action by the people in Taiwan, but there is no need for it, and they don't desire it. They want good relations with China so they don't offend so much, but they ceryainly don't want unification, not even the KMT. Had the KMT politicians been saying that they want unification, the Chinese posters would surely post it up. But there's nothing. KMT wants good relations with China. There is another political party that is very much for unification in a pro-CCP China way, but they are very tiny.

Another self delusion comment. Get your kuril island back from Russia first and I will believe the comment you just make.

I can also say Russia will be ready to attack if you Japanese lay your hands on China. Russia is wary of evil Japanese attempt to take more land from Russian. They are waiting for a chance to deal u a blow. :enjoy:
 
.
Interesting discussion. The People's Republic of China has since 1949 been unable to mount an amphibious assault on the Republic of China due to a lack of blue water navy and amphibious capabilities. This has been changing over the past 10 years. I would estimate by 2021 Taiwan could be under practical threat of armed invasion by PRC. Of course, the USA would respond if such an event looked likely. PRC has publicly stated they would sink all of the aircraft carriers sent into the region and they have capability to back up those threats. However, it seems to me a risky venture to wage armed aggression over an island that poises not threat to anyone national security. The smart play is to take away any vestige of nation from Taiwan. In the end, they will have to fall in line because everyone else deserted their quest to be a free and independent nation. Having visited the Beautiful Island, I feel bad and sad that PRC just can't live paradise alone. I saw a place that was full of personal freedom and creativity...vibrant and wealthy its populace. The PRC could learn much from the Taiwan. Conversely, the PRC offers nothing but a loss of identity and freedom for the ROC.
 
.
Poor China, needs help from Russia.
Is funny how these 1.5m short men try laughing at 1.7m superior men? Japanese need to take a mirror and look at yourselves. Mighty Japan can stand alone and dont need allies and can win China or South Korea?

May I know what drugs has you taken before writing those words and post it out? You Japanese is just a 跟班 for the American. I truly admire your delusion spirit which gives you the courage to spew those rubbish? Oh, I forgot your US master still have thousands of men living on Okinawan and you has a busy time serving them. :enjoy:

We China dont have such problem.. No US cowboy on China or Taiwan soil dirty those place. See the difference between u and me? :lol:

Interesting discussion. The People's Republic of China has since 1949 been unable to mount an amphibious assault on the Republic of China due to a lack of blue water navy and amphibious capabilities. This has been changing over the past 10 years. I would estimate by 2021 Taiwan could be under practical threat of armed invasion by PRC. Of course, the USA would respond if such an event looked likely. PRC has publicly stated they would sink all of the aircraft carriers sent into the region and they have capability to back up those threats. However, it seems to me a risky venture to wage armed aggression over an island that poises not threat to anyone national security. The smart play is to take away any vestige of nation from Taiwan. In the end, they will have to fall in line because everyone else deserted their quest to be a free and independent nation. Having visited the Beautiful Island, I feel bad and sad that PRC just can't live paradise alone. I saw a place that was full of personal freedom and creativity...vibrant and wealthy its populace. The PRC could learn much from the Taiwan. Conversely, the PRC offers nothing but a loss of identity and freedom for the ROC.
Really? hundred thousand of taiwanese migrate and work in mainland China. Shenzhen is a magnet for entrepreneur and innovative technologist taiwanese for them to showcase their talent. Taiwan trying to close its door is a boring place for them. :enjoy:

http://focustaiwan.tw/news/aeco/201803190018.aspx

China was cited as the most popular place to work because of the lack of language barriers, its geographic proximity to Taiwan, the cultural similarities across the Taiwan Strait, and respondents having a positive outlook on China's market, the job bank said.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom