What If Attlee Hadn’t Partitioned India?

[Thorough Pro]

Yet another hindu propaganda, If it was not for Muslims, you guys would still be licking British feet. Thank the Muslims of the subcontinent for getting independence for you too, or keep spreading your misinformed propaganda lies.

what is a good nation?

You have a country full of agricultural wealth and low on energy,there is enough water and good weather to live.

what more do you want?

what silly statistics r u looking for?

we need to do better in a lot of things but dont fall for stats.

And defecating in the open in the village is anyday better than doing it in a toilet and running the risk of affecting drinking water.



Muslims did nothing dude,

It was the efforts of the Congress alone,Muslim league was created to create division and not allow a big nation to emerge.

This is a daylight fact.



Unfortunately the British left a united India and even otherwise the Sikh empire made sure,you didn't cross the Indus.

 

[bronxbull]

Yet another hindu propaganda, If it was not for Muslims, you guys would still be licking British feet. Thank the Muslims of the subcontinent for getting independence for you too, or keep spreading your misinformed propaganda lies.

Please stop dreaming sir jee. We finished all the Muslim kingdoms including tipu sultan before the Brits came.

That's why your whiskey sipping,pork munching quail sucked upto the Brits.

I don't lie,whereas you don't know the truth.

Jaake apni Mundi Saaf karein.

 

[Vinod2070]

Please stop dreaming sir jee. We finished all the Muslim kingdoms including tipu sultan before the Brits came.

That's why your whiskey sipping,pork munching quail sucked upto the Brits.

I don't lie,whereas you don't know the truth.

Jaake apni Mundi Saaf karein.

Mr. Jinnah was Churchill's mentee and Pakistan was the prize given to him and Muslim league for being faithful to the Brits.

And to forever remain a colonial outpost here.

Just like some of them accuse Israel to be a Western outpost in the ME.

 

[bronxbull]

Indeed.thats why India should just let the self destruction happen.just fund the secessionists.

 

[Menace2Society]

Pakistan are the new leaders of the tribes of Eurasia.

We have the biggest guns and the largest population, by 2030 we will be the largest Muslim population in the world.

We are the centre point for all future geo-strategic Islamic objectives in Eurasia, this is indisputable. There will be no invading army from Central Asia or Afghanistan which will sweep Pakistan and conquer India.

TTP are trying this and they are stuck in the mountains. We make the rules now, the balance of power shifted many many decades ago.

Towards the end of this century we will make the push westwards into all the "stans" to unite them under the flag of Pakistan, then we will push our way back into Delhi.

 

[Shardul.....the lion]

if partitioned had not happened, we would not been poorest nations on earth...

Pakistan are the new leaders of the tribes of Eurasia.

We have the biggest guns and the largest population, by 2030 we will be the largest Muslim population in the world.

We are the centre point for all future geo-strategic Islamic objectives in Eurasia, this is indisputable. There will be no invading army from Central Asia or Afghanistan which will sweep Pakistan and conquer India.

TTP are trying this and they are stuck in the mountains. We make the rules now, the balance of power shifted many many decades ago.

Towards the end of this century we will make the push westwards into all the "stans" to unite them under the flag of Pakistan, then we will push our way back into Delhi.

now wake up and smell the coffee

 

[Menace2Society]

if partitioned had not happened, we would not been poorest nations on earth...

Because 1 billion Indians would not be a burden If we never seperated Indians would be sucking the blood out of Balochistan's treasures to feed their own. Pakistan would be a wasteland.

We are at just the right population for sustainable future growth and prosperity.

Not jagged spikes up and down which India have shown. You are burdened with too many people which will be evident as the decades pass.

Essentially we are 2 very different civilizations brought together by force by the British. The present is a rewind to all of this.

 

[Shardul.....the lion]

Because 1 billion Indians would not be a burden If we never seperated Indians would be sucking the blood out of Balochistan's treasures to feed their own. Pakistan would be a wasteland.

We are at just the right population for sustainable future growth and prosperity.

Not jagged spikes up and down which India have shown. You are burdened with too many people which will be evident as the decades pass.

Essentially we are 2 very different civilizations brought together by force by the British. The present is a rewind to all of this.

difference is now Punjabis are sucking blood out and still both India. Pakistan and Bangladesh are poorest nations on earth....

answer that we have biggest guns and have millions below poverty just because of our famous rivalry

 

[Menace2Society]

difference is now Punjabis are sucking blood out and still both India. Pakistan and Bangladesh are poorest nations on earth....

Yeah because Baluchistan has been plundered.

The resources in Baluchistan are untouched. Because of Pakistan no foreign invader has stolen everything from there.

Now we are mining the area for the betterment of everyone.

Hindu majority in the sub continent would have meant forced conversion and murder on the Muslims in particular in the Indus Valley where there has been a traditional Muslim population.

A hindu controlled sub continent would be equivalent of an invasion on Indus Valley inhabitants. Modern day Pakistan would have been a wasteland, full of slums and death.

Didn't you say you would be sipping tea in Lahore in the morning in 1965? Traditionally Indus Valley areas have always been seen as a conquest for Indians because it is foreign land. We are very different people.

In the end it doesn't matter about money. Money comes and goes.

It is freedom, freedom from Indian hegemony, culture, history, life style, ethics, morality etc etc. This is priceless because all of this shapes who you are.

And as we are 2 very different people to shape us into Hindu majority India would be an act of colonization. Not even the British achieved this because if they did we wouldn't be sitting on the opposite sides of a border.

 

[bronxbull]

Pakistan are the new leaders of the tribes of Eurasia.

We have the biggest guns and the largest population, by 2030 we will be the largest Muslim population in the world.

We are the centre point for all future geo-strategic Islamic objectives in Eurasia, this is indisputable. There will be no invading army from Central Asia or Afghanistan which will sweep Pakistan and conquer India.

TTP are trying this and they are stuck in the mountains. We make the rules now, the balance of power shifted many many decades ago.

Towards the end of this century we will make the push westwards into all the "stans" to unite them under the flag of Pakistan, then we will push our way back into Delhi.

Good luck dude.

 

[bronxbull]

Yeah because Baluchistan has been plundered.

The resources in Baluchistan are untouched. Because of Pakistan no foreign invader has stolen everything from there.

Now we are mining the area for the betterment of everyone.

Hindu majority in the sub continent would have meant forced conversion and murder on the Muslims in particular in the Indus Valley where there has been a traditional Muslim population.

A hindu controlled sub continent would be equivalent of an invasion on Indus Valley inhabitants. Modern day Pakistan would have been a wasteland, full of slums and death.

Didn't you say you would be sipping tea in Lahore in the morning in 1965? Traditionally Indus Valley areas have always been seen as a conquest for Indians because it is foreign land. We are very different people.

In the end it doesn't matter about money. Money comes and goes.

It is freedom, freedom from Indian hegemony, culture, history, life style, ethics, morality etc etc. This is priceless because all of this shapes who you are.

And as we are 2 very different people to shape us into Hindu majority India would be an act of colonization. Not even the British achieved this because if they did we wouldn't be sitting on the opposite sides of a border.

We don't want any territory

 

[SwatCat]

Yet another hindu propaganda, If it was not for Muslims, you guys would still be licking British feet. Thank the Muslims of the subcontinent for getting independence for you too, or keep spreading your misinformed propaganda lies.

LOL muslim elite boot lickers of british and your lack of your history.

No muslim leader was jailed or received pain from british, it was congress.

Pakistan are the new leaders of the tribes of Eurasia.

We have the biggest guns and the largest population, by 2030 we will be the largest Muslim population in the world.

We are the centre point for all future geo-strategic Islamic objectives in Eurasia, this is indisputable. There will be no invading army from Central Asia or Afghanistan which will sweep Pakistan and conquer India.

TTP are trying this and they are stuck in the mountains. We make the rules now, the balance of power shifted many many decades ago.

Towards the end of this century we will make the push westwards into all the "stans" to unite them under the flag of Pakistan, then we will push our way back into Delhi.

This is not 7th century nor this is not the period of Babur or Ghaznavi.

Each one will have a period in history where they will excel, those central asian peoples chances are over, now is the time for India. Pakistanis are not central asians.

Nor any Islamic states want Pakistan to lead them, it is always a wet dream for you people and some jingoism involved here.

 

[INDIC]

Mr. Jinnah was Churchill's mentee and Pakistan was the prize given to him and Muslim league for being faithful to the Brits.

And to forever remain a colonial outpost here.

Just like some of them accuse Israel to be a Western outpost in the ME.

Ever since Pakistan became independent, Western countries always had presence in Pakistan all the time.

 

[Menace2Society]

This is not 7th century nor this is not the period of Babur or Ghaznavi.

Each one will have a period in history where they will excel, those central asian peoples chances are over, now is the time for India. Pakistanis are not central asians.

Nor any Islamic states want Pakistan to lead them, it is always a wet dream for you people and some jingoism involved here.

TTP are trying to conquer Pakistan to use our ideology for their gains.

None of the stans have a concrete ideology like Pakistan does, that is why they will always look to us before they do anything else.

Little do they know the tide will go westwards and we will unite them under true spiritual awareness and kill their destructive war mongering mindset.

History is always in a state of flux, Eurasia is a funny place.

Pakistan is formed on the Indus Valley, we have nothing to do with South India. Through historically we have always had close links to central Asian and Middle eastern countries because we are the bridge between east and west.

If you can't see past this then this exactly the reason why 70 million Muslims rejected Indian hegemony in 1947.

Pakistan as a landmass is a completely different civilization.

Do you think through history when they spoke of Al-Sind, or Hind, do you think they were referring to jungle dwelling South Indians?

No, they were referring to people of the Indus, since Mesopotamia Pakistanis has been known in the world. India or Indians never existed, you were just segregated jungle people that had nothing of value to say to the world.

 

[SwatCat]

Yeah ...... I know being anti India is Pakistans ideology, it is eveident in your post where you brought India deliberately even though I have not mentioned India in my post.

The stans have culture, Language and then on top of it they have identity and they just happens to be muslim majority countries. This point is difficult for pakistanis to understand since your ideology is reverse .

To tell you if you see the history of Indian civilization most of the mathematicians, gurus, rishis , art culture and traditions are originated in South.

Indus Valley is an enigma in itself. It is a just an excavation site which do not reveal any thing about the people of that region. There is no literature associated with those sites except some artefacts which are leading to some controversial deductions. Better not to mention it.

And name one Islamic country which is looking at Pakistan right now or will look at pakistan for its problems, the reverse is happening right now and continues to do for long period since things are not quite right in pakistan.

Regarding Jungle dwellers and all, it is nonsense.each region in India has its own language, art , culture, traditions and identity. These things are developed over a period of centuries and they are still valued in our lives and we are proud of them.

TTP are trying to conquer Pakistan to use our ideology for their gains.

None of the stans have a concrete ideology like Pakistan does, that is why they will always look to us before they do anything else.

Little do they know the tide will go westwards and we will unite them under true spiritual awareness and kill their destructive war mongering mindset.

History is always in a state of flux, Eurasia is a funny place.

Pakistan is formed on the Indus Valley, we have nothing to do with South India. Through historically we have always had close links to central Asian and Middle eastern countries because we are the bridge between east and west.

If you can't see past this then this exactly the reason why 70 million Muslims rejected Indian hegemony in 1947.

Pakistan as a landmass is a completely different civilization.

Do you think through history when they spoke of Al-Sind, or Hind, do you think they were referring to jungle dwelling South Indians?

No, they were referring to people of the Indus, since Mesopotamia Pakistanis has been known in the world. India or Indians never existed, you were just segregated jungle people that had nothing of value to say to the world.