sadly everyone here is MANIPULATED by stupid leaders that do anything for vote bank! & like i said we don't need the US or the indians TO BREAK US! WE ARE MORE THAN CAPABLE OF BREAKING OURSELVES INTO ETHNIC,RELIGIOUS & CITY sects!
very very disheartning!
bhai forget it all these guys want is division! put 2 pakistanis in a room and they will disagree with everything. this QAUM is dead & baighyrat!
even Bengalis are better than us atleast they are united as a nation WE are not!
Dear ice man,
Partly you are, right my friend!
But like me, most of pakistanis aren't in the favour of the, old divisions, or the new ones ,which is in progress , right now!
That's why, I allwaYs pushed the, above mentioned idea, from which, we can get n real,, democracy, not this mafia style(demo-crazy)!which is bieng pushed, or injected on us by, making us , economicly week?
I allways admire, our militry dictatorship, which allways made, pakistan become selfsufficiant, all of 3 genrls, who hAd govrned us, were more, democratic, more fair, & were nt, crupt at all, its our badluck , that they were decent, peoples bt with out knowledge, of politics, Zulfiqar ali bhutto was bieng gromed, by F.marshall ayaub khan, NAWAZ shrif was made, gen .ziAul-haq, Imran khan get elected in the times of musharaf, mustafa kamal, & chdry perveiz -ILahi , also got their real colours durring, gen. Musharaf, s era.
Great progress , was made! Under the militry leadership, bt only thing, these good soilders, not able to do, iS unification of the , pakistani nation!
Musharaf,S retirement happened ,due to a open disscuSsion of core-commanders, meeting, in which, they werE all, werE agreed to , give a chance, to the demo-crazy , instead of that, real democracy?
I think, now need a dictator, with a blazing gun, in his hand, with a will of iron, to make this nation, united with danda, finish All, this rubissh , soba culture, & give us unification!
That's the most , realistic solution, We can have, now?
Thanks
These are the true historical & current facts of the Sindhi-Urdu speakers' divide:
Sindh willingly accepted the Mohajirs that came to Pakistan 1947. The Mohajirs, who were the most educated group, starting dominating Karachi & Hyderabad, & the Sindhis were getting driven out. Even with limited resources & opportunities, the Urdu speakers managed to transform Karachi & Hyderabad; whereas interior Sindh, that got most of the province's revenue, was marred with rampant corruption of feudalism (which is still pervasive today) from the Sindhi leadership.
The Mohajirs were guilty of showing arrogance, & making prominent their (initial) superiority in education, culture in Sindh; & taking sole credit for the creation of Pakistan, as well as not acclimatizing to the region well enough (as compared to other ethnic groups such as Balochs, Pakhtuns etc in Sindh that call them Sindhis). They did not acknowledge the fact that the Sindhis were the ones that accepted them with open arms, & gave them a place there.
After the MQM was formed in 1984 however, the party gradually started arming the Urdu speakers, & started getting them to abandon their education, getting them into political activism. After the brutal military operations by the Benazir Bhutto regime against the Urdu speakers in Karachi (& its repercussions also felt in Hyderabad), political activism & guns culture became pervasive in the Urdu speaking community, & eventually, these are the things that have resulted in the deterioration of the Urdu speaking community.
MQM is a legitimate party with an illegitimate leader, & poor mafia like tactics. MQM supporters will point to the fact that they have little choice but to keep the arms, citing the incidents of 1992 in Hyderabad & Karachi. I would cite the fact that Sindhis have accepted all ethnic groups with open arms inside Sindh, & it is due to the MQM mafia tactics that we see such bitterness amongst the Sindhis. However, I think the MQM have done well in Karachi from a development point of view, & anyone that criticizes Urdu speakers for 'stealing the resources of the country' should start looking into the rampant corruption in interior Sindh, from Sindhi leaders.
Educated Urdu speakers today find it difficult to support the MQM, but the main crux of support that the MQM receives, from middle class & lower middle class Urdu speakers (who are not necessarily very educated, & not as moderate as educated Urdu speakers; the average Sindhi is more moderate than the average Urdu speaker); still see MQM as their saviors (even though the MQM has been responsible for the degradation of the Urdu speaking community, by getting them engaged in political activism & gun warfare, rather than focusing them on their education), & they still have bitter feelings of what happened in 1992 in Hyderabad & Karachi.
I consider both Sindhi parties & the MQM to be moderate, secular forces that need to unite. Sindhi parties need to get rid of feudalism, MQM needs to disassociate itself with Altaf Hussein, bring Altaf Hussein back to Pakistan, and make him accountable in the courts. And Karachi needs to get rid of arms in the city.
Nice post, mate
Bringing altaf hussain back, will only bringing in problems, bringing billons of libraly looted, money by PPP, (asif zardari) is more important? Or not, librly Speaking!
