Don't go so dramatic for me and then say you seek the total elimination of the taliban in the SWAT valley only?
Uh...Korrum, Khyber, N.A., the Islamic Emirate of Waziristan, and eastern Baluchistan await this operation or feel free to go after those locations simultaneous to Buner and SWAT.
There are taliban EVERYWHERE and if chopping heads is too revulsive for SWAT and Buner, so too for the rest of your country and Afghanistan to boot. You cannot see Omar and his merry men as "good taliban". They will submit Afghanistan, AGAIN, to the same misery that you've seen so clearly now in SWAT and BUNER.
If America and ISAF are successful to any degree this summer, there will be rats scattering all across southern Afghanistan from Farah through Nimroz and Helmand to Kandahar. Not all but some will certainly head south to seek sanctuary if matters prove too hot for them. I don't know how the Iranians feel about the taliban but I've understood it's not well so I doubt that the lads in Farah and Nimroz will go in that direction. There's little doubt about those in Helmand and Kandahar though. Marine Commandant Conway and Gen. Kayani have already had discussions to that effect.
I'm hoping Pakistan understands that if it's your war, it's also the war of others in Afghanistan. The enemy is common and there is no "good" and "bad" taliban. Nor can Haqqani and Hekmatyar be viewed any differently than Omar.
They are all enemies of mankind. It can't be any more plain and must be treated as such. This will be long and hard but we hope that you'll help defeat this scourge.
I do anyway. God bless you and good luck reclaiming SWAT and Buner. May they be the first in this march to transform Pakistan into the future.
Think of all that must be for this to work. We KNOW what's required and in more or less what priority/order. It'll be such a good thing to bring these conditions about.