PTI ‘decides’ to disband Ruet-i-Hilal committees at all levels

[GumNaam]

Yes and ALLAH and his RASOOL SAW knew about other form of sightings so please stop trying to teach Islam to those who gave you Islam. Sighting from naked eye is must to decide about the starting of the month.

Uhm...you do realize that telescopes, radars, computers and these other forms of sightings we have today didn't exist over 1400 years ago, right?

 

[Skyliner]

No it can't be Islam is some ones personal Islam is what ALLAH and his RASOOL SAW have decided. And wrong move. Moon sighting is must. Eid or Ramdan can't be decided on birth of moon.


Than Eid would be done next day. Either 29 or 30. Moon Sighting has to be done.


What is unislamic is that you have to sight the moon. Every body knows moon is there it doesn't get destroyed and new moon doesn't come to existence. It's same moon. Yes every body knows about birth of moon and How many hours are needed before moon can be seen through naked eye. Still Moon has to be sighted from the eye.

Hazrat app na to straightaway inkar kr k fatwa laga dia ha k it's unIslamic, don't you think it should be ulama who would be issuing fatwa whether it's according to the injunctions of Islam or not!
It's a simple issue of having witnesses of moon sight whether over a radar or naked eye, can be resolved involving ulama.

 

[GumNaam]

Hazrat app na to straightaway inkar kr k fatwa laga dia ha k it's unIslamic, don't you think it should be ulama who would be issuing fatwa whether it's according to the injunctions of Islam or not!
It's a simple issue of having witnesses of moon sight whether over a radar or naked eye, can be resolved involving ulama.

Don't need ulemas' opinion for something so simple, straight and forward. this kind of mind control at the hands of clergy needs to end for ever.

 

[Skyliner]

Don't need ulemas' opinion for something so simple, straight and forward. this kind of mind control at the hands of clergy needs to end for ever.

Brother there's a need
Would you lay an extra story on your existing house without having an expert opinion!

 

[Maxpane]

thats a good newd

 

[Wa Muhammada]

Brother there's a need
Would you lay an extra story on your existing house without having an expert opinion!

Those who have their eyes open are witnessing the brick by brick dissemblement of Islam in Pakistan. IK’s PTI govt is resembling the era of Ataturk where the state controlled religion and secularism susperseded Islam and the ulema were imprisoned.

Our future generation will curse us for voting in such a govt. I agree that structural reforms and ‘selective’ ehtesaab is happening but deen e Islam is in danger from these secularists and already we can see religion is state controlled. Woe on us, for our amaal have brought us to this junction

 

[zain41]

Those who have their eyes open are witnessing the brick by brick dissemblement of Islam in Pakistan. IK’s PTI govt is resembling the era of Ataturk where the state controlled religion and secularism susperseded Islam and the ulema were imprisoned.

Our future generation will curse us for voting in such a govt. I agree that structural reforms and ‘selective’ ehtesaab is happening but deen e Islam is in danger from these secularists and already we can see religion is state controlled. Woe on us, for our amaal have brought us to this junction

What other steps has pti taken that are “against Islam” lol

 

[GumNaam]

Brother there's a need
Would you lay an extra story on your existing house without having an expert opinion!

I would consult the experts IN THAT PARTICULAR FIELD, in this case, a structural architect, not a general construction worker. Which is why, in case of the moon sighting, I would consult the experts in astronomy and astrophysics, not some clergy.

 

[Pandora]

Eye witnesses were in early days because there was no other form of confirmation for moon sighting. I think it is just pathetic that people think that a radar and telescope is inferior to a human eye ball. Even our current method of confirmation is done through portable telescopes so why not throw them away as well and let it be done through eyes of bunch of mullahs.

Those who have their eyes open are witnessing the brick by brick dissemblement of Islam in Pakistan. IK’s PTI govt is resembling the era of Ataturk where the state controlled religion and secularism susperseded Islam and the ulema were imprisoned.

Our future generation will curse us for voting in such a govt. I agree that structural reforms and ‘selective’ ehtesaab is happening but deen e Islam is in danger from these secularists and already we can see religion is state controlled. Woe on us, for our amaal have brought us to this junction

You dont need eyes to be blind to the reality. In Saudia moon sighting is done through such method yet they have not been classified as seculars. Even in Malaysia Indonesia and turkey such methods are being used for moon sighting so are they all seculars and kafirs as well?

Ataturk imprissoned Ulema because they ruined the fabric of turkey from within the state. Any sane person will see what people like Molanna diesel, Molanna tahir ul padri and Khadim rizvi among thousands of others doing to our country in name of islam. Nothing is more dangerous for muslims than a mullah who feeds on souls of our people.

 

[Super Falcon]

Good before govt were like lakeer ka faqeer many things and system has to be changed for better

 

[GumNaam]

Qalandari e Lahori Allama Iqbal Rehmatullah Alayhi spoke abt this beautifully:

Uhm, THIS is what Qalandari e Lahori Allama Iqbal Rehmatullah Alayhi had to say about this...

And by the way, Allama Iqbal Rehmatullah Alayhi was a sialkoti, not lahori.

 

[gutto786]

Its a good decision.
Actually met department will be able to predict
Moon age
Clouds chances
Visibility
So keeping all this (and many other weather factors that met department can predict) its 100% gauranteed that met dept prediction will far more accurate than a committee looking for moon with a telescope
Its a much more islamically right decision to hand it over to met dept

 

[Sabretooth]

Finally, common sense has prevailed against the blind following. ٱلْـحَـمْـدُ للهِ

 

[saiyan0321]

Finally. Utter waste of space and funds.. Eye witness and oaths were from back then when in the Arabian desert there were no telescopes or any form of tech in the world.. The modern world has evolved and we now have massive machines and technology and telescopes that can tell us the start of the Islamic month.

Those that are against this should also be against the atomic bombs or missiles or tanks since they were also not categorically stated in Islam or the atomic bomb which is specifically made to target civilian industry sector where civilians would die. Should we call Bhutto, Zia, benazir and nawaza secular for the bomb.. Wahan pay tu nahi Islamic injunctions ati...

It was this very mindset which has seen Muslims enter the darkages.. There was once fatwa against loudspeakers and now its unislamic to take loudspeakers away from mosques... The printing press was considered illegal and now it is the mainstay for quranic printing... Today eyeballs are apparently more reliable then telescopes... Hadd hogaye hai. We must improve ourselves in our scientific research if we are to become a proper world power just like our ancestors...

Also open your minds.. This was rightly called and was the useless expenditure of the state to satisfy a few mullahs who seriously for drunk on power on the one day of the year where he was given limelight.

 

[Norwegian]

Those who have their eyes open are witnessing the brick by brick dissemblement of Islam in Pakistan. IK’s PTI govt is resembling the era of Ataturk where the state controlled religion and secularism susperseded Islam and the ulema were imprisoned.

Our future generation will curse us for voting in such a govt. I agree that structural reforms and ‘selective’ ehtesaab is happening but deen e Islam is in danger from these secularists and already we can see religion is state controlled. Woe on us, for our amaal have brought us to this junction

Lol