PAK Navy successfully intercepts Indian Submarine, foils intrusion

[MastanKhan]

Don't think too much.

View attachment 544924



That would be a real stupid war tactics / strategy to use, Indians are stupid, but not that much.

Hi,

The first part of your post is not very intelligent---.

The second part is beyond your pay grade---so don't bother---you won't understand what I am saying---.

I have seen stupidity amongst my country men---your's is purely ignorance---.

 

[IceCold]

The game of cat & mouse has been played in sea's between subs and sub hunters since the development of the submarine.
During the cold war, the US & USSR were actively playing this game.

Submarines are prowlers of the deep, and are designed to remain undetected in order to complete their mission.

We during peace time, continuously conduct ASW exercises with our own subs in every possible scenario. These exercises benefit both the platforms.

Since 1964, PN has been operating submarines and now after 50+ years, we have a well trained submarine force which has proven it's worth in 1971, by sinking an enemy vessel. These doctrines are developed over a long period of time and produces qualified crews who are well conversant with submarine operations.

PN has also been up against its adversary since the start and used the Ghazi in 1965 in an aggressive posture.

Now coming to your specific concern,

Submarines are used in peace time to gather intel, track & monitor shipping lanes/routes, monitor adversaries naval movements, stay hidden in strategic choke points and many more, but they do all this while remain invisible.

As soon as it is detected, it loses all it's initiative and has to go back.

In this case, the sub was detected and localized (which is done while it is submerged and not on PD).
Then the procedure is adopted to let the sub know, that is has been localized & identified and is forced to come to PD or surface.

The video which was released was made by the IR camera, after the sub came to PD.

If they were defecting, then they would have made it obvious just by giving a call on the UHF guard frequency, and we would have guided it to our nearest port. So it's not the case.

We over the years, have tracked and have a pretty clear understanding of how our enemy operates, the area where they operate and the depths they operate.

This is not the first time, we have localized our enemy sub, it has been done so many times in the past. I myself have tracked one of their subs during one of our exercises many years ago.

This is the first time the IN is operating french submarines, and were probably testing it's capability and limits.

PN will and is looking into this matter deeply and from all angles, as it is a matter of survival.
Rest assured, we have our eyes & ears open.

I know sir that you have mentioned before that Sub cannot be taken out in International waters but this is the 2nd time Indians have tried to sneak in. What if when the sub is detected and we ask it to surface, our marines or commandos storm it and capture it taking all Indian sailors abroad as POW? Of course we can always return them back but this is going to be one hell of a trophy and embarrassment for Indians.

 

[IblinI]

A question from me since I have not followed up this news, is it confirm yet which submarine was detected in the event?

 

[Thorough Pro]

I can only laugh at your comments judging me without knowing anything about me.
GOD bless you.

Hi,

The first part of your post is not very intelligent---.

The second part is beyond your pay grade---so don't bother---you won't understand what I am saying---.

I have seen stupidity amongst my country men---your's is purely ignorance---.

 

[Rashid Mahmood]

I know sir that you have mentioned before that Sub cannot be taken out in International waters but this is the 2nd time Indians have tried to sneak in. What if when the sub is detected and we ask it to surface, our marines or commandos storm it and capture it taking all Indian sailors abroad as POW? Of course we can always return them back but this is going to be one hell of a trophy and embarrassment for Indians.

Yes it can be done.
Boarding an enemy vessel in international waters without provocation is not a good idea.
It depends on how far the govt is willing to take it.

View attachment 544765 View attachment 544765

View attachment 544767

PN Does not fly the Atlantic's anymore.
Dumb media .

Atlantic? I heard Atlantic decommissioned long time ago. Are they still in serve? @Rashid Mahmood

Yes.

 

[Arsalan]

But why? What could be the reason?

Cannot say.

Anyway, it was back on news after 2-3 hours of disappearance.

Have we sent out a boarding party?

It was warned and sent back.

Thats pak territorial waters..
They shud have sunk it

Its not. Its our EEZ. Not territorial waters.

 

[Dazzler]

 

[aziqbal]

I have not been following the submarine story closely

which PN asset took those photos of the Indian sub? P3C?

 

[Awan68]

A car sales man who has read one to many books but has zero, nil nada experience in any theatre of war, not even that of lieutenant has a habit of calling entire wings of our military traitors from his arm chair on an online forum. Lol i some times feel pity for this Baji Rao Maastani, he is clearly frustrated, dellusional and without doubt fantasizes about scenarios where is is leading assaults on an enemy and the entire world is in awe of his genius, i see right through u old man.

 

[CodeforFood]

A question from me since I have not followed up this news, is it confirm yet which submarine was detected in the event?

I believe it is scorpene class.

 

[Trango Towers]

Pakistan Navy thwarts attempt by Indian submarine to enter Pakistani waters
March 05, 2019

The Pakistan Navy detected an Indian submarine trying to enter Pakistani waters. — File photo/Reuters

The Pakistan Navy on Tuesday detected an Indian submarine trying to enter Pakistani waters and successfully thwarted the attempt, DawnNewsTV reported quoting the Navy's spokesperson.

"The Pakistan Navy used its specialised skills to ward off the submarine, successfully keeping it from entering Pakistani waters," a statement from the spokesperson said.

This is the second time the Pakistan Navy has detected the Indian submarine trying to enter Pakistani waters since 2016.

According to the statement, the fact that an Indian submarine laden with modern technology was detected by the Pakistan Navy is a loss for the Indian navy.

Source: https://www.dawn.com/news/1467778/p...by-indian-submarine-to-enter-pakistani-waters


Actual video of detection

Wish they would show cockpit footage of the two indian planes downed

 

[AMG_12]

I have not been following the submarine story closely

which PN asset took those photos of the Indian sub? P3C?

Yes, it was a P3C that detected the Indian Submarine.

 

[monitor]

The game of cat & mouse has been played in sea's between subs and sub hunters since the development of the submarine.
During the cold war, the US & USSR were actively playing this game.

Submarines are prowlers of the deep, and are designed to remain undetected in order to complete their mission.

We during peace time, continuously conduct ASW exercises with our own subs in every possible scenario. These exercises benefit both the platforms.

Since 1964, PN has been operating submarines and now after 50+ years, we have a well trained submarine force which has proven it's worth in 1971, by sinking an enemy vessel. These doctrines are developed over a long period of time and produces qualified crews who are well conversant with submarine operations.

PN has also been up against its adversary since the start and used the Ghazi in 1965 in an aggressive posture.

Now coming to your specific concern,

Submarines are used in peace time to gather intel, track & monitor shipping lanes/routes, monitor adversaries naval movements, stay hidden in strategic choke points and many more, but they do all this while remain invisible.

As soon as it is detected, it loses all it's initiative and has to go back.

In this case, the sub was detected and localized (which is done while it is submerged and not on PD).
Then the procedure is adopted to let the sub know, that is has been localized & identified and is forced to come to PD or surface.

The video which was released was made by the IR camera, after the sub came to PD.

If they were defecting, then they would have made it obvious just by giving a call on the UHF guard frequency, and we would have guided it to our nearest port. So it's not the case.

We over the years, have tracked and have a pretty clear understanding of how our enemy operates, the area where they operate and the depths they operate.

This is not the first time, we have localized our enemy sub, it has been done so many times in the past. I myself have tracked one of their subs during one of our exercises many years ago.

This is the first time the IN is operating french submarines, and were probably testing it's capability and limits.

PN will and is looking into this matter deeply and from all angles, as it is a matter of survival.
Rest assured, we have our eyes & ears open.

I question is coming to my mind as we know Indian submarine was coming to Pakistani sea area which is violation of Pakistan thus would given Pakistan right to attack the sub or destroy it. Why you didn't allow it to enter your water and only then inform the intruding submarine that he is detected so forced it to surrender or prepared for destruction ?

 

[Rashid Mahmood]

I question is coming to my mind as we know Indian submarine was coming to Pakistani sea area which is violation of Pakistan thus would given Pakistan right to attack the sub or destroy it. Why you didn't allow it to enter your water and only then inform the intruding submarine that he is detected so forced it to surrender or prepared for destruction ?

They would never enter the Territorial waters of Pakistan.
They know the consequences of doing so.

 

[dexter]

Wish they would show cockpit footage of the two indian planes downed

They will show it when the time is right but not yet.