What's new

Not in our country: Japanese fight relocation of US military facility

Europa

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Apr 15, 2014
Messages
911
Reaction score
-1
Country
Germany
Location
India
japan-military-us-opposition.si.jpg


Opponents of a new American military base in Japan won a key victory on Sunday. Candidates against to the idea now have a majority in the city assembly, and in the Okinawa Prefecture, meaning they can attempt to block the new facility’s construction.

The assembly in the city of Noga now contains 16 members out of a total of 27 who are against the relocation of a US base from Futenma. They are both located in the Okinawa Prefecture - Japan’s southernmost district, made up of some of the Ryukyu Islands. The facility is situated in a densely-populated urban area in southern Okinawa. However, the government wants to move it to Noga, a smaller city to the north that already hosts Camp Schwab, another US Marine base.

The results will please the Nago Mayor Susumu Inamine, who is resolutely against the construction of the new military base. There has been significant local opposition to the relocation of the facility and the re-election of Inamine in January by a wide margin was effectively a de facto referendum on the US facility.

“Why should only Okinawa hold the burden for security of all of Japan, when the presence of US Marines doesn’t play a big role in deterring China?” Inamine, said in May, whilst on a visit to Washington, DC. “I, as mayor, have operational control over two ports that are needed for use as construction landfill and I will exercise all powers in the municipality to block access.”

Voter turnout at the assembly vote on Sunday was 70 percent, showing there is strong local interest surrounding the base. The results will come as a blow to Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who is in favor of the relocation move, as he sees the US presence as a needed deterrent against China.

On April 24, Abe and US President Barack Obama “affirmed the resolve on both sides” to make “steady progress” on transferring the Marine base in Futenma.

The estimated cost of the relocation is about $8.6 billion, and Japan will cover $3.1 billion of that sum.

In December 2013, the governor of Okinawa, Hirokazu Nakaima agreed to the base’s relocation in return for large-scale funds from Tokyo, which he hoped would be used to revitalize the local economy. In August, Japan’s Ministry of Defense started a drilling survey off the coast of Nago to prepare for the building of the base, which was to be built on a landfill site.

Tokyo and Washington are negotiating multiple plans regarding the relocation, according to the Japan Daily Press. One is to allow Japanese authorities to enter US bases for environmental checks and other official purposes, which Tokyo believes will complement the existing Status of Forces Agreement. Another is to advance the return of land where Futenma is currently, which is now scheduled for 2022.

In addition, Japan is suggesting that US exercises involving the controversial MV-22 Osprey transport aircraft occur in several locations - not just in Okinawa.

The United States agreed in 2006 to move the base to the coast, but local opposition prevented the potential shift. Anti-base sentiment and concern about US military operations at Futenma has long been an emotionally charged issue in Okinawa.

Japan hosts some 50,000 American soldiers and officers, particularly in Okinawa. Their presence is a constant source of tension with local populations due to crimes committed by the servicemen, disruptions caused by military flights and land use by the US forces.

For instance, last October, a local woman was raped by the US military. The incident provoked anger among locals and forced the American military to enforce a curfew upon its service members. The incident led to protests by outraged locals, while due to the seriousness of the case, it was held in a Japanese court. 24-year-old Seaman Christopher Browning was sentenced to 10 years behind bars, while 23-year-old Petty Officer 3rdClass Skyler Dozierwalker received nine years’ imprisonment.

The Okinawa prefecture, which is the southernmost Japanese district, is strategically vital to the US military given its proximity to the rest of Asia. The islands accounts for less than 1 percent of Japan’s total territory, but hosts about half the 38,000 US military personnel stationed in Japan.

Not in our country: Japanese fight relocation of US military facility — RT News
 
.
Opponents of U.S. base win majority in Nago assembly - The Japan News

12:46 am, September 09, 2014

Jiji PressNAGO, Okinawa (Jiji Press) — Opponents of a planned U.S. Marine base maintained a majority in Sunday’s city assembly election in Nago in Okinawa Prefecture.

The outcome came after Susumu Inamine, who opposes the controversial plans to move the U.S. Marine Corps’ Futenma Air Station in Ginowan, also in the prefecture, to Nago, won another term as mayor of Nago in January’s election.

Speaking to reporters, Inamine said he will step up his call on the central government to abandon the base relocation plan.

Sunday’s results are helpful to Takeshi Onaga, mayor of the prefectural capital of Naha and an opponent of the base relocation plan, who plans to run in the gubernatorial election set for Nov. 16.

The outcome deals a blow to efforts to win a third term by incumbent Gov. Hirokazu Nakaima, who late last year approved land reclamation in Nago’s coastal Henoko district for the base relocation.

The central government has already started a drilling survey in waters off Henoko for the base relocation.Speech

U.S. base opponents gain majority in Nago city assembly - 毎日新聞
 
.
“Why should only Okinawa hold the burden for security of all of Japan, when the presence of US Marines doesn’t play a big role in deterring China?” Inamine, said in May, whilst on a visit to Washington, DC. “I, as mayor, have operational control over two ports that are needed for use as construction landfill and I will exercise all powers in the municipality to block access.”

The Okinawa prefecture, which is the southernmost Japanese district, is strategically vital to the US military given its proximity to the rest of Asia. The islands accounts for less than 1 percent of Japan’s total territory, but hosts about half the 38,000 US military personnel stationed in Japan.

Okinawa is just an atom compared to the Japanese US agreement. They can say whatever they want, but the US will get the strategic real estate it wants.

Or the Japanese can start to take control of their defense.

There is a long term strategic reason that Japan and the US have this defense agreement. The Japanese got free defense, American Weapons & training, while it focused on rebuilding itself.

The US got access to keep tabs on the Communist Giants.

Japan is a MAJOR staging ground for American operations in Asia. 50,000 US troops ready to confront back up the 28,500 in S.Korea. Any rations going to S.Korea pass through Japan.

Before the Chinese members begin their posts, the Okinawan just want the rest of Japan to host more US troops, 38,000 are stationed in Okinawa, which is 1% of Japan's territory.
 
.
@Nihonjin1051 Why has moving the base to Okinoerabujima never been broached as a possibility? It seems fairly sizable, and has far fewer people (15,000 according to Wikipedia).
 
.
Japan is a mere colony of the US. As China rises, the US military will get crushed by the PLA just like the PLA kicked out the US and its allies out of North Korea during the Korean war.

US military got humiliated once by China, it's doesn't have the guts for a 2nd fight.
 
.
@Nihonjin1051 Why has moving the base to Okinoerabujima never been broached as a possibility? It seems fairly sizable, and has far fewer people (15,000 according to Wikipedia).

Okinoerabujima is too small for the US Military Base as seen in Okinawa. It requires a larger land mass and Okinawa is thus preferable for its location. Okinawa is a Large Military installation because it is home to the US Army,US Navy, US Air Force, US Marines . It is then also home to Japanese Military Base that includes the JGSDF, JASDF, JMSDF. There are 50,000 some American military personnel here, not including the fact that it is also home to the Japanese Ground Self Defense Force's Western Army's 15th Brigade, as well as contingents of the 4th and 8th Division. The Military bases (Japanese and American) provide jobs to the people in Okinawa Prefecture, providing jobs to over 10,000 Japanese civilians in Okinawa, contributes to over $2 Billion to the local economy. The Japanese military bases in Okinawa also stimulate around $10 Billion per year to the local prefecture. Moving the bases (American or Japanese) away from Okinawa to other islands will cost too much money to build, time, as well as it will cost the loss of jobs to some 10,000 Japanese. It will also mean $12 Billion will be cut from the local economy of Okinawa Prefecture.

This is why it is in my opinion, that the military bases must stay where they are, and actually contribute greatly to the local people as well as the overall defense of the nation. These protesters can be damned for all I care, because they don't speak for the some 10,000 Japanese Okinawans (and their families whom they support) who work in the military bases.
 
. .
Japan is pretty much irrelevant in the world with a bankrupt economy, outdated military, shrinking population, staggering debt, economy collapsing 7.1% and worst of all being a colony of the US and Japanese women getting raped by US soldiers :lol:

China will crush the US military like it did in Korean War. US military is nothing but a paper tiger shooting at mullahs :lol:
Mullah fighting is what the US can do, it's scared to fight Russia or China.

It's certainly too scared to fight the PLA after the spanking they took in the Korean war.

I am very pleased with the demise of Japan, couldn't happen to a better bunch of people.
Hopefully they continue to rot :lol:

That's what they get for messing with China.
Karma :coffee:

And this goes to the US too with the dire economic state the US regime finds itself in.

Don't mess with China.....EVER :coffee:
obama-biden.jpg
 
.
Japan is pretty much irrelevant in the world with a bankrupt economy, outdated military, shrinking population, staggering debt, economy collapsing 7.1% and worst of all being a colony of the US and Japanese women getting raped by US soldiers :lol:

China will crush the US military like it did in Korean War. US military is nothing but a paper tiger shooting at mullahs :lol:
Mullah fighting is what the US can do, it's scared to fight Russia or China.

It's certainly too scared to fight the PLA after the spanking they took in the Korean war.

I am very pleased with the demise of Japan, couldn't happen to a better bunch of people.
Hopefully they continue to rot :lol:

That's what they get for messing with China.
Karma :coffee:

And this goes to the US too with the dire economic state the US regime finds itself in.

Don't mess with China.....EVER :coffee:

Its ok to be biased but it should not lead to absurdity.
 
.
Its ok to be biased but it should not lead to absurdity.
it's that Chinese hubris.
if you changed the name and flag you would think it was a U.S 12 yr old :D

we will crush you rah rah you can't stop the Chinese rah rah lol
 
.
US military hasn't don't jack against any decent opposition and the fights they did have they got thumped.
Pounding a bunch of mullahs don't earn you respect, taking on Russia and China will.
US military is all hype. It's all believing in fairytales of fake invincibility and untouchable weapons and brainwashing the fools to believe into the hype.
Serbia alone embarrassed the US military when they shot down their untouchable steal planes :lol:

And yes, Japan is irrelevant.

not really seeing how this has anything to with the topic
just seems like a bunch of anti-us/jp and pro China talk
 
. .
This is why it is in my opinion, that the military bases must stay where they are, and actually contribute greatly to the local people as well as the overall defense of the nation. These protesters can be damned for all I care, because they don't speak for the some 10,000 Japanese Okinawans (and their families whom they support) who work in the military bases.

exactly the opposite when I talk to someone from the North.

The relocation of US base can be substituted by tourism and other industries. I believe the demilitary of Okinawa is in the best interest of locals. Nobody want foreign troops in their neighborhood, whether Nagano, Fukushima, or any perfecture of Hokkaido.
 
.
exactly the opposite when I talk to someone from the North.

The relocation of US base can be substituted by tourism and other industries. I believe the demilitary of Okinawa is in the best interest of locals. Nobody want foreign troops in their neighborhood, whether Nagano, Fukushima, or any perfecture of Hokkaido.

Interesting to know that Nihonjin1051's opinion is the opposite to many Japanese including 90% of Okinawan. (Someone just dispute me about Okinawan should be called Ryukyu) Ok. I just call the current name Okinawan. Since all Okinawan are Japanese and 90% of which are opposing US bases, I want to know statistically how many percent Japanese want US bases near their home.


Last time Thailand host US was cultural prosperous. Everywhere US bases touch, it become Pataya night bar clubs. Is having many night bar clubs cultural prosperous or cultural disastrous? I for one am a customer. :dance3::hitwall::cuckoo:. Mix feeling here.


Ok. The Most important aspect of having US based on your soil, from Thailand experience, under my eye glasses view, is that
Once Thailand/US lost South Vietnam to North Vietnam, the US bases in Thailand are now magnetic to drag war inside Thai territory. US personal became soft cocoon under Thai soldiers' protection!.
 
.
Right...
military base in Okinawan will only attract missile...
It can hardly play anything import if there is a big war..
I think US has a plan of moving some force to the Guam, far away from China mailand..

Interesting to know that Nihonjin1051's opinion is the opposite to many Japanese including 90% of Okinawan. (Someone just dispute me about Okinawan should be called Ryukyu) Ok. I just call the current name Okinawan. Since all Okinawan are Japanese and 90% of which are opposing US bases, I want to know statistically how many percent Japanese want US bases near their home.


Last time Thailand host US was cultural prosperous. Everywhere US bases touch, it become Pataya night bar clubs. Is having many night bar clubs cultural prosperous or cultural disastrous? I for one am a customer. :dance3::hitwall::cuckoo:. Mix feeling here.


Ok. The Most important aspect of having US based on your soil, from Thailand experience, under my eye glasses view, is that
Once Thailand/US lost South Vietnam to North Vietnam, the US bases in Thailand are now magnetic to drag war inside Thai territory. US personal became soft cocoon under Thai soldiers' protection!.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom