Modi's Article 370 remark: Is it time to end special status for J&K?

[adwityagrata]

There has been Legal immigration from many parts of India, not illegal immigration from Bangladesh. How exactly is A&N's population growth tied to West Bengal's??

How did you expect them to land in A&N anyways? Without Indian Identity cards/passports, they would neither have been allowed on transport craft to A&N in the first place.

Do you think the millions of BD illegal migrants in India do not have papers ? LOL. This is India, not the USA. There is an entire SSI in place that provides fake & real papers to illegal BD's.

 

[Indischer]

Do you think the millions of BD illegal migrants in India do not have papers ? LOL. This is India, not the USA. There is an entire SSI in place that provides fake & real papers to illegal BD's.

Yeah, sure. And you alone also happen to know that such people alone have entered A&N islands. Your clinching evidence was equally epic, that comparison of population growth rates for W.Bengal and A&N Islands. Not bad for a strawman demolisher.

 

[adwityagrata]

Yeah, sure. And you alone also happen to know that such people alone have entered A&N islands. Your clinching evidence was equally epic, that comparison of population growth rates for W.Bengal and A&N Islands. Not bad for a strawman demolisher.

No more than your apologetic spin that it was legal migration that result in the population tripling

You are the one who mentioned W. Bengal as being closest to A&N based on historical evidence and port access. So naturally the population growth comparison is also relevant, since most ppl in A&N and Bengali (BD's). Clearly you do not stand by your own assertions. Not surprising though.

 

[halupridol]

Yeah, sure. And you alone also happen to know that such people alone have entered A&N islands. Your clinching evidence was equally epic, that comparison of population growth rates for W.Bengal and A&N Islands. Not bad for a strawman demolisher.

tell u wht...........dont know about A N islands,,,,,but as far as w.bengal is concerned illegal immigration is huge.......bt no match with assam
damn its massive in assam......its like a mini bangladesh
PS:- dont know wht u guys were talking about....just saw ur post n replied

 

[Indischer]

No more than your apologetic fantasy that it was legal migration

You are the one who mentioned W. Bengal as being closest to A&N based on historical evidence and port access. So naturally the population growth comparison is also relevant, since most ppl in A&N and Bengali (BD's). Clearly you do not stand by your own assertions. Not surprising though.

Only an idiot could have been confused by my post into believing that none other than people from W.Bengal have migrated to A & N Islands. I don't know if you've been to the A&N islands. I've been there and there are plenty of people from Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh and Jharkand/Bihar. Here is a ethnic break-up for your sake:Bengali (32.6%), Hindi (25.95%), Tamil including Sri Lankan Tamils (17.84%) and Telugu (18.93%). So much for being swamped with "Illegal Bangladeshi Immigrants."

Map of Andaman & Nicobar Islands - Asian Maps, Asia Maps Andaman & Nicobar Islands Map Information - World Atlas

 

[adwityagrata]

tell u wht...........dont know about A N islands,,,,,but as far as w.bengal is concerned illegal immigration is huge.......bt no match with assam
damn its massive in assam......its like a mini bangladesh
PS:- dont know wht u guys were talking about....just saw ur post n replied

You got the general gist of the matter.

 

[Indischer]

tell u wht...........dont know about A N islands,,,,,but as far as w.bengal is concerned illegal immigration is huge.......bt no match with assam
damn its massive in assam......its like a mini bangladesh
PS:- dont know wht u guys were talking about....just saw ur post n replied

I don't dispute that a lot of Bangladeshis cross over into India illegally. It's obviously a problem in our N.E.Areas. Our talk was regarding his assertion that the Andaman and Nicobar Islands have been swamped by illegal bangladeshi immigration(which I beg to differ on).

 

[halupridol]

You got the general gist of the matter.

ur posts gives impression tht u r a hardcore rt winger........it wont take u nywhere,not much cn b chnged wid tht line of thnking
..

I don't dispute that a lot of Bangladeshis cross over into India illegally. It's obviously a problem in our N.E.Areas. Our talk was regarding his assertion that the Andaman and Nicobar Islands have been swamped by illegal bangladeshi immigration(which I beg to differ on).

well i have nothng to contribute on tht matter.....
r u pro congress??......
yeah on principle they r gud.....sad tht doesnt show in there 60+ yrs practice though..

 

[adwityagrata]

Only an idiot could have been confused by my post into believing that none other than people from W.Bengal have migrated to A & N Islands. I don't know if you've been to the A&N islands. I've been there and there are plenty of people from Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh and Jharkand/Bihar. Here is a ethnic break-up for your sake:Bengali (32.6%), Hindi (25.95%), Tamil including Sri Lankan Tamils (17.84%) and Telugu (18.93%). So much for being swamped with "Illegal Bangladeshi Immigrants."

Map of Andaman & Nicobar Islands - Asian Maps, Asia Maps Andaman & Nicobar Islands Map Information - World Atlas

And only an idiot will post a link that reinforces by assertion that majority is Bengalis. LOL.

This is what the govt. census in A&N show about foreign composition of populations in A&N who was born abroad (which primarily translates to emigration from BD)

Year-------------% of people born abroad (BD)
1951-------------10.35
1961-------------16.57
1971-------------12.47
1981-------------8.46
1991-------------5.4

Ref: Andaman and Nicobar islands development Report.

ur posts gives impression tht u r a hardcore rt winger........it wont take u nywhere,not much cn b chnged wid tht line of thnking

I am a hard core rationalist. LOL. But people are free to form their own prejudices

 

[halupridol]

I am a hard core rationalist. LOL. But people are free to form their own prejudices

think u meant nationalist......well i was just saying wht ur posts seem to b like.....

 

[Indischer]

well i have nothng to contribute on tht matter.....
r u pro congress??......
yeah on principle they r gud.....sad tht doesnt show in there 60+ yrs practice though..

Nah. I have no fixed political leanings. The Congress and it's politics are the fuel that fires the popularity of BJP. Hence, nothing much to choose between the two.

 

[adwityagrata]

think u meant nationalist......well i was just saying wht ur posts seem to b like.....

No Rationalist, Some one who practices Rationalism - defined as someone who Relies on reason as the best guide for belief and action.

 

[Indischer]

And only an idiot will post a link that reinforces by assertion that majority is Bengalis. LOL.

This is what the govt. census in A&N show about foreign composition of populations in A&N who was born abroad (which primarily translates to emigration from BD)

Year-------------% of people born abroad (BD)
1951-------------10.35
1961-------------16.57
1971-------------12.47
1981-------------8.46
1991-------------5.4

Ref: Andaman and Nicobar islands development Report.



I am a hard core rationalist. LOL. But people are free to form their own prejudices

And you posting this stat does what exactly? ROFL. These migrations are legal and the Government has kept track of the migrants. Reinforces what I said earlier that illegal migration into A&N Islands is near-damn impossible. Learn to know the difference between Legal and Illegal migration before ranting out, Mr Hard Core Nationalist...oops, Rationalist!

 

[adwityagrata]

And you posting this stat does what exactly? ROFL. These migrations are legal and the Government has kept track of the migrants. Reinforces what I said earlier that illegal migration into A&N Islands is near-damn impossible. Learn to know the difference between Legal and Illegal migration before ranting out, Mr Hard Core Nationalist...oops, Rationalist!

Govt. do not allow legal migration from Bangladesh genius . All such migration is illegal. LOL.

 

[Indischer]

Govt. do not allow legal migration from Bangladesh genius . All such migration is illegal. LOL.

What an idiot! Re-read the report that you have posted as source. The stats are from Goverment sources and certainly not of illegal immigrants. Or are you so obnoxious to accept that you've created a stawman of your own that you have a hard time demolishing?