Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan acknowledged as traitor or not?

[Srinivas]

He was Pro-India and you have all the reasons to cheer him.

For us he is not a hero not even the Afghanistanis consider him a hero.

Frankly speaking ANP the political party here in my province run by his grandsons is carrying his name as a liability

He is not pro India but he has close relationship with Mahatma Ghandhi and believes in Tolerance and co existence.

He is also socialist and believes in equality, He is popular on either side of Durand line.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

He is not pro India but he has close relationship with Mahatma Ghandhi and believes in Tolerance and co existence.

He is also socialist and believes in equality, He is popular on either side of Durand line.

Actually Bacha khan is very popular and respected in Afghanistan. @Spring Onion is lying for some unknown reason...he is also very popular in peshawer valley

 

[Srinivas]

Actually Bacha khan is very popular and respected in Afghanistan. @Spring Onion is lying for some unknown reason...he is also very popular in peshawer valley

His entire life is a modest one and he tirelessly worked for the literacy and empowerment of his own people. He only feared about his own people's rights with the formation of Pakistan.

He also knows the immature nature of the migrated ones at that time.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

His entire life is a modest one and he tirelessly worked for the literacy and empowerment of his own people. He only feared about his own people's rights with the formation of Pakistan.

He also knows the immature nature of the migrated ones at that time.

Considering the extensive talibanization of nowadays pakhtuns, his non-violence efforts become more important.
There is only one thing taught to pakhtuns in pakistani schools that, he was frontier gandhi, ally of hindus, who wanted to break pakistan...

 

[nana41]

If "Bacha Khan" learnd the non voilence philosophy of AHINSA from Ghandhi and became a diehard follower ,was it so that Allama Iqbal(ra) and Jinnah(ra) were inciting and teaching him on voilence, were these two leaders advising him not to be a "khudai Khidmatgar"?. I have seen photographs him sitting near the feet of his spiritual/political leader Ghandhi,never with Allama Iqbal(ra)asking for any quraanic advise.IMHO he was not a wise man just a stuborne pakhtoon,who was out to get some cheap shuhrat ,further more more he stood whole heartedly against the creation ofPAKISTAN. His followers have turnd out to be as politically immature if not foolish.This NAP sided with russians and their agentsin Afghanistan after its invasion,and now they are repeating the same policy and helping american invaiders.instead of helping their brothern these NAP fools are condenming the mujaideen...the SHAEEN of HAKIMUL UMMAT IQBAL(ra).

 

[imran_ind]

He didn't opted for pakistan makes him a traitor ? how funny why only him majority of the muslims in India choose to stay back India and no regrets we are proud to be a part of this country. so as per that logic all the 190 million muslims in India are traitors as per Pakistanis .

Khan abdul ghaffar khan is called 'Frontier Gandhi'. He is called so because Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan belonged to the NorthWest Frontier Province of British India and shared an ideology similar to Mahatma Gandhi.

To hell with your rants

 

[Srinivas]

Considering the extensive talibanization of nowadays pakhtuns, his non-violence efforts become more important.
There is only one thing taught to pakhtuns in pakistani schools that, he was frontier gandhi, ally of hindus, who wanted to break pakistan...

False propaganda.

Fact is he is pro Congress and the people at that time in NWFP are also pro congress and voted in favor of Congress, which is a amalgamation of Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs .....

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Muslim league workers were killing hindus every where even in NWFP. Due to efforts of khudai khidmatgars very little bloodshed occured in NWFP compared to punjab, and that mostly in muslim league dominated region of hazara..khudai khidmatgars were again called hindu agents and anti-muslim by muslim league for saving lives of hindus.

 

[Spring Onion]

Actually Bacha khan is very popular and respected in Afghanistan. @Spring Onion is lying for some unknown reason...he is also very popular in peshawer valley

yeh so famous that we consider him as a traitor.

Luffy he is NOT a hero for Afghans neither for Pukhtuns here.

His name is being used as a compulsion by ANP even.

Considering the extensive talibanization of nowadays pakhtuns, his non-violence efforts become more important.
There is only one thing taught to pakhtuns in pakistani schools that, he was frontier gandhi, ally of hindus, who wanted to break pakistan...

You ingornat educationally even because in Pakistani schools we do not teach about Ghafar Khan at all . He was congressi and he was pro-India , he was against Pakistan that is known to all of us.


the scum was anti-Pakistan that is no secret

He didn't opted for pakistan makes him a traitor ? how funny why only him majority of the muslims in India choose to stay back India and no regrets we are proud to be a part of this country. so as per that logic all the 190 million muslims in India are traitors as per Pakistanis .

Khan abdul ghaffar khan is called 'Frontier Gandhi'. He is called so because Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan belonged to the NorthWest Frontier Province of British India and shared an ideology similar to Mahatma Gandhi.

To hell with your rants

burn his deadbody according to hindu rituals we dont have an issue. indeed those who opted for India and NOT opting for Pakistan are traitors.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

yeh so famous that we consider him as a traitor.

Luffy he is NOT a hero for Afghans neither for Pukhtuns here.

His name is being used as a compulsion by ANP even.



You ingornat educationally even because in Pakistani schools we do not teach about Ghafar Khan at all . He was congressi and he was pro-India , he was against Pakistan that is known to all of us.


the scum was anti-Pakistan that is no secret



burn his deadbody according to hindu rituals we dont have an issue. indeed those who opted for India and NOT opting for Pakistan are traitors.

You must have been very poor student in Pakistan studies subject, Go check topic role of NWFP in Pakistan movement, he is mentioned there.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Seems he was a hero for the indians on PDF......

 

[Spring Onion]

You must have been very poor student in Pakistan studies subject, Go check topic role of NWFP in Pakistan movement, he is mentioned there.

yeh Indians call him frontier gandhi and you are thinking its ISI conpiracy to use that word in one line reference to bacha khan in school book.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Seems he was a hero for the indians on PDF......

lalay What are ur views about bacha khan?

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

lalay What are ur views about bacha khan?

Il be honest.. i dont know much abt him... but if he was against the creation of Pakistan... than i have no respect for him... if he wanted autonomy... well thts another member... i think all provinces should be given autonomy.

 

[Spring Onion]

Il be honest.. i dont know much abt him... but if he was against the creation of Pakistan... than i have no respect for him... if he wanted autonomy... well thts another member... i think all provinces should be given autonomy.

in the name of autonomy he wanted power only for his own family.

He was against creation of Pakistan.