India's unfair tirade against Bangladesh puzzles Indians too

[gslv mk3]

We muslim ruled you hindus for 1000 years. Last time you were saved by choosing another master British. Who will save you this ttime?

WTF are you smoking...

And what are you Bongoloids with a puny military going to do??

Are you going to send BNS Bongobondu to attack Mumbai harbour or something...

Last time I checked, a smaller Myanmar was giving you middle finger & you were unable to do anything about it.

This is the best you can do- cheering for your 'dada' who 'liberated' you from 'tyranny'. Watch from 0:39

When people will start to starve, they will only have one side to choose - survival at any cost.

And how exactly is Bangladesh going to make NE India starve...???

Are you going to sanction India ??

What would you do? Invade Bangladesh? Well, that's what everybody in the region would be waiting for to have a free hit over India!

No one in the region would give a good damn about your LDC. And no one would be foolish enough to start a war with a nuclear power for Bangladesh.

Invading Bangladesh means you have to deal with a 6 million-strong armed force

6 million ??? It's 1.5 lakh. Even Indian Army- world's second largest- only have 1.3 million active personnel.

Is it another brainfart like ''Number of cars in Bangladesh is more than number of vehicles in India''...?

And even that number is way too insignificant given the capabilities of your military- particularly given that IAF can easily establish air dominance over your airspace.

Ask your former compatriots about what we'll do after establishing air superiority...

And I don't even have to mention about your navy...

Your Northeast and Eastern India would already be pissed off at your central govt. as their economies decline considering how dependent they are on Bangladesh.

Yeah indeed, $10 billion of trade, tilted in our favour is called 'dependency'...

But what else to expect from a deluded Bangladeshi ?

Yeah, our soldiers will be fighting with bare hands and feet, genius!

I hope they don't use those sophisticated DEW weapons developed by ''Asia's largest R&D facility established by Walton''. Indian army would be decimated then.

 

[kris]

How is having relatives across border or economic relations (hoping you are not justifying smuggling) are any barriers to NRC ?Or justify illegal immigrants.
It's time to address this menace.

Justified question. But my notion is that individual relations matter on the ground and help many people for being smuggled comfortably.....
Smuggling even happens into china from NK

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

This is just one example of trouble India will face if Bangladesh became not so friendly.

While, China and Pakistan just preparing to finish off the regional menace. All these things will eventually lead to the inevitable balkanization of India.

What will you do if India decides to blockade Bangladesh from land and sea? The only other way out is through Myanmar, and they would probably support India's blockade.

China and Pakistan are unlikely to declare war on India for Bangladesh. Donald Trump loves Modi (and he needs defense orders from them) so he will probably side with India. The EU will sit back at a distance and ask to mediate.

Indian politicians claim that there are millions or even tens of millions of illegal Bangladeshis in their country. Whether that is true or not won't mean anything, just like it never meant anything with the Rohingya. If they want to push them across the border they will do that.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

What will you do if India decides to blockade Bangladesh from land and sea? The only other way out is through Myanmar, and they would probably support India's blockade.

China and Pakistan are unlikely to declare war on India for Bangladesh. Donald Trump loves Modi (and he needs defense orders from them) so he will probably side with India. The EU will sit back at a distance and ask to mediate.

Indian politicians claim that there are millions or even tens of millions of illegal Bangladeshis in their country. Whether that is true or not won't mean anything, just like it never meant anything with the Rohingya. If they want to push them across the border they will do that.

Relax dude, These are election time rhetorics. There will be no deportation.

You should not confuse between allegedly 'Bangladeshi migrant' in India and Rohingyas. Rohingyas are a distinct ethnic group in myanmar totally different from other burmese in terms of look, language,culture,religion etc. While in case with India, everything is common. There are Bengali Hindus and Muslim in both countries, ethnicity, culture is the same. So detection without doubt is not easy. India as a major democratic and responsible power in the world can not act as recklessly as myanmar. They care about international reputation unlike burmese savage. Unlike Rohingyas, there is no history of insurgency within India's so called 'illegal Bangladeshi'. Even if India try to do any atrocity against those ''illegal Bangladeshi'', there will be huge uproar and opposition within India itself. Not all Indian party are supportive of this BJP led drama of detecting ''illegal Bangladeshi''. Indian opposition parties are against this dirty political stunt of BJP. Indian supreme court will intervene. Indian muslim numbering some 200 million will hit the street against persecution of muslim. Bangladesh will just shut the border. A major international crisis will follow. So, India can not act like myanmar.

What will you do if India decides to blockade Bangladesh from land and sea? The only other way out is through Myanmar, and they would probably support India's blockade.

Blockading some country is not as easy as you are assuming. It is an act of war and happen only in extreme cases. Currently Maldives is slapping India in faces, Do you see India blockading Maldives? Plus, the negative impact of blockade is not immediate upon the country against which blockade is imposed. Blockade can not do much against a country which is largely self sufficient in food and fuel. Bangladesh is largely self sufficient in food and has substantial gas to meet energy demand partially. With prudent austerity measures, the effect of blockade will not be felt for many months in Bangladesh. It is unlikely that any war will persist that long. A diplomatic solution will be achieved long before that.

2nd point is, do you think Bangladesh will allow escalate things with India to the point of war and blockade unless it acquire enough military deterrence or without mending it's tie with myanmar ? Hell no. Do you think we are that stupid?

China and Pakistan are unlikely to declare war on India for Bangladesh

Who is telling China and Pakistan to declare war on India on behalf of Bangladesh in a mythical war between India and Bangladesh? You did not even help Pakistan during it's war with India. So what chance any other county has? What @Species indicated is not about participating war on behalf of Bangladesh, but the desire of Chinese and Pakistani to see India's balkanization given the animosity among these 3 countries. That statement was actually a sarcasm intended to tease an Indian.

Indian politicians claim that there are millions or even tens of millions of illegal Bangladeshis in their country. Whether that is true or not won't mean anything, just like it never meant anything with the Rohingya. If they want to push them across the border they will do that.

Probability of this scenario I have already discussed in my first part of reply.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Indian muslim numbering some 200 million will hit the street against persecution of muslim. Bangladesh will just shut the border. A major international crisis will follow.

Did any of these things happen after the "butcher of Gujarat" became the Prime Minister of India?

The international community doesn't care, the Indian Muslims don't care.

America is leading the world into a new era where countries only care for their own interests.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Did any of these things happen after the butcher of Gujarat became the Prime Minister of India?

The international community doesn't care, the Indian Muslims don't care.

America is leading the world into a new era where countries only care for their own interests.

Indian muslim took to the streets during Rohingya crisis, and due to their opposition, Indian govt. forced to halt the deportation of 40000 Rohingyas to myanmar. Now you do the math whether Indian muslim will remain silent if BJP try to emulate myanmar.

If international community do not care, then why burmese general can not go to Europe and America? Why EU is mulling sanction against myanmar? Why ASEAN is urging myanmar to prosecute it's general? Even Donald Trump led America is critical of myanmar. You should not judge everyone else to your own country's standard.

 

[Chinese-Dragon]

Indian muslim took to the streets during Rohingya crisis, and due to their opposition, Indian govt. forced to halt the deportation of 40000 Rohingyas to myanmar. Now you do the math whether Indian muslim will remain silent if BJP try to emulate myanmar.

If international community do not care, then why burmese general can not go to Europe and America? Why EU is mulling sanction against myanmar? Why ASEAN is urging myanmar to prosecute it's general? Even Donald Trump led America is critical of myanmar. You should not udge everyone else to your own country's standard.

And who is actually doing something against Myanmar other than talking?

They have already pushed a million Bengali Muslims back to Bangladesh, has anyone actually done anything except talk?

Now who is going to do something if India and Myanmar blockade Bangladesh and stop the water? Indian politicians claim to have millions of illegal Bangladeshis (i.e. Bengali Muslims). With Donald Trump style politics spreading across the world, "Muslim refugees" are the new scapegoat.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

And who is actually doing something against Myanmar other than talking?

They have already pushed a million Bengali Muslims back to Bangladesh, has anyone actually done anything except talk?

Now who is going to do something if India and Myanmar blockade Bangladesh and stop the water? Indian politicians claim to have millions of illegal Bangladeshis (i.e. Bengali Muslims). If Bangladesh complains they can blockade and turn off the water.

Not only talk, myanmar is now under severe pressure to repatrate Rohingyas. Already their investment and tourism are suffering from negative consequences of international criticism. Sanction will follow from EU and US if they do not repatriate Rohingyas. Burmese are now preparing to receive the first batch of 8000 Rohingyas.

Myanmar can not blockade Bangladesh. And India will not do that as India and Bangladesh are friendly countries.
Before parroting blockade...blockade... you should wait to see at least India urging Bangladesh to take the socalled ''illegal Bangladeshi''. Up to date, they never raised the issue with Bangladesh. And you are imagining the scenario of India blockading Bangladesh!!

And India do not have tape switch to on/off water on the common rivers with Bangladesh. Out of 53 common rivers, only 2 have dam on Indian sides, one of this has water sharing treaty with Bangladesh. Bangladesh has 700 rivers with ample internal supply of fresh water. We are dependent on common rivers only partially. So Bangladesh will not collapse even if India can somehow hold back all the water coming to Bangladesh. At worst, some of our irrigated agriculture will be harmed.

 

[Species]

What will you do if India decides to blockade Bangladesh from land and sea? The only other way out is through Myanmar, and they would probably support India's blockade.

China and Pakistan are unlikely to declare war on India for Bangladesh. Donald Trump loves Modi (and he needs defense orders from them) so he will probably side with India. The EU will sit back at a distance and ask to mediate.

Indian politicians claim that there are millions or even tens of millions of illegal Bangladeshis in their country. Whether that is true or not won't mean anything, just like it never meant anything with the Rohingya. If they want to push them across the border they will do that.

We don't need China or Pakistan to rescue us, rather they will be motivated by their own intentions.

India cannot sustain a war against Bangladesh because of its own internal vulnerabilities already explained in earlier posts.

Their policy-makers know it the best which is why this 'illegal immigration' tantrum is only restricted to a mere rhetoric.

 

[gslv mk3]

India cannot sustain a war against Bangladesh because of its own internal vulnerabilities already explained above

So says a deluded Bangladeshi...

 

[Bilal9]

And who is actually doing something against Myanmar other than talking?

They have already pushed a million Bengali Muslims back to Bangladesh, has anyone actually done anything except talk?

Now who is going to do something if India and Myanmar blockade Bangladesh and stop the water? Indian politicians claim to have millions of illegal Bangladeshis (i.e. Bengali Muslims). With Donald Trump style politics spreading across the world, "Muslim refugees" are the new scapegoat.

Your calculus does not contain the insurgency factor in NE India and in Maoist areas. Bangladesh kept these people in check for the longest time by cutting off their arms supply and handing them over to India, and India appreciates this fact. Arming Indian insurgents and separatists is only ONE option. There are other options too.

If an Indian blockade is exercised, it will be a pretty foolhardy move, and Indian military planners know it.

The repercussions will be varied and many faceted and a 'loosely governed' India will find it hard to cope.

During 1971 - it was well documented how Bangladeshi guerrilla fighters kept the Pakistani Army confined to the barracks. Indians did rewrite a lot of history, but their involvement mostly amounted to moving in during winter for a fortnight and claiming victory over a largely decimated Pakistani force.

We know every inch of our land - and its mostly under water. Let the games begin.

 

[gslv mk3]

During 1971 - it was well documented how Bangladeshi guerrilla fighters kept the Pakistani Army confined to the barracks. Indians did rewrite a lot of history, but their involvement mostly amounted to moving in during winter for a fortnight and claiming victory over a largely decimated Pakistani force.

No one gives a damn about the fantasies of you LDC lot...

 

[Vijyes Yechury]

Indian muslim took to the streets during Rohingya crisis, and due to their opposition, Indian govt. forced to halt the deportation of 40000 Rohingyas to myanmar. Now you do the math whether Indian muslim will remain silent if BJP try to emulate myanmar.

If international community do not care, then why burmese general can not go to Europe and America? Why EU is mulling sanction against myanmar? Why ASEAN is urging myanmar to prosecute it's general? Even Donald Trump led America is critical of myanmar. You should not judge everyone else to your own country's standard.

This is stupidity to say that India responded to Indian Muslims shouting. India gets $100+ billion every year to keep quiet about Muslims. This will only be increased as more pressure is put on India. BJP may not have opposition support but if it goes fully against Muslims, it will get Hindus, Sikh, Buddhist, jain etc support. The opposition will be helpless and if they shout they will be attacked.

Also, understand that India is capable of destroying middle east and Bangladesh together by expelling muslims and causing food crisis. Blockade of Bangladesh is very easy as BD lacks food items like sugar, vegetables, water and fuel items. As I said, India is having a deal with Hasina to keep quiet in return for good behavior. The Bangladeshi illegals can be expelled any time needed when BD misbehaves. So, these are acting as blackmail tool for India to ensure BD does good behaviour.

About international sanction, this aplies only to small countries. India is in a position to dictate terms. The entire Arab oil flows at Indian mercy and India can cause major problems in that. Just releasing muslim population into pakistan by force and bombing Pakistan will create unbelievable refugee crisis in middle east that will make oil production collapse. In addition, Arabian sea is in Indian control. If international countries need Arab oil, they must accept Indian condition and promise to behave well .Sanctioning India is not the choice they have. Poor countries like Myanmar don't have such leverage. If India decides to teach BD a lesson, none will dare intervene.

We don't need China or Pakistan to rescue us, rather they will be motivated by their own intentions.

India cannot sustain a war against Bangladesh because of its own internal vulnerabilities already explained in earlier posts.

Their policy-makers know it the best which is why this 'illegal immigration' tantrum is only restricted to a mere rhetoric.

Read my above reply to know why action is not being taken on illegals.

Pakistan is as weak as Iraq was in 1990. Pakistan is worthless opponent. China India ties have improved drastically since Modi came. China is viewed as old civilisation without any imperial attitude. So, India under Modi sees China as a potential cultural ally. Even during NDA-1, China was viewed favourably for this reason. It will only improve ties further.

 

[UKBengali]

And who is actually doing something against Myanmar other than talking?

They have already pushed a million Bengali Muslims back to Bangladesh, has anyone actually done anything except talk?

Now who is going to do something if India and Myanmar blockade Bangladesh and stop the water? Indian politicians claim to have millions of illegal Bangladeshis (i.e. Bengali Muslims). With Donald Trump style politics spreading across the world, "Muslim refugees" are the new scapegoat.

https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-m...on-myanmar-over-rohingya-crisis-idUKKCN1MD266

Unless the Barmans hand over their war criminals and take back Rohingya then West will destroy their economy.

Please feel free to suck the life out of the Barman savages to your heart's content.

 

[Vijyes Yechury]

https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-m...on-myanmar-over-rohingya-crisis-idUKKCN1MD266

Unless the Barmans hand over their war criminals and take back Rohingya then West will destroy their economy.

Please feel free to suck the life out of the Barman savages to your heart's content.

Everyone does not rely on west for economy. West also relies on others for their economy. So, one sided affairs don't work