What's new

How many Indian members have RSS worldview

What is your view about RSS


  • Total voters
    59
.
Sir the hinduism is not religion but it's a way of life of are culture suppose if you want to revert back to culture you will be reverted back to your old sect of belief under hinduism which is sanatan dharma which are religion fall under hinduism like shaivaism or vasnavism etc its on you if you want to be a arya samaji (aethist) you can be all its want a "sudhi karan" according to upanisads under vedas
How culture of Indian Muslim is different than those of Indian Hindus? I thought culture is about language/dress/food/music etc You need to go and look definition of word revert before using it. For example you were born Hindu you become Muslim later on and then change your mind again and get back to Hindusim only then you should be called revert to Hinduism. If someone born as Muslim and then adopt Hinduism then he will be a convert not revert
 
.
would any body explain this view ? i will like to know if people are discussing something which is not just words put together. "world" "wide" "view".
 
.
How culture of Indian Muslim is different than those of Indian Hindus? I thought culture is about langauge/dress/food/music etc You need to go and look definition of word revert before using it. For example you were born Hindu you become Muslim later on and then change your mind again and get back to Hindusim only then you should be called revert to Hinduism. If someone born as Muslim and then adopt Hinduism the. He will be a convert not revert
You are taking it wrong way man we are saying same thing I give your example only to show the method of reconvesion.people who are borns muslims are muslims they have nothing to do with reconvesion.VHp have different camps for born Muslim's where if they want they can change to sanatan dharma like Julia robberts changed from born Christian Catholic to a vasnavism sect of hinduism -
 
.
Those who dont know noble RSS..should watch this

[video]

What are your views about Tarek Fatah? If you hold this woman's views in high regard, you should be just as open and welcoming of his views about Pakistan and the likes of Jinnah and Zia ul Haq.
 
.
What are your views about Tarek Fatah? If you hold this woman's views in high regard, you should be just as open and welcoming of his views about Pakistan and the likes of Jinnah and Zia ul Haq.
I don't know why you guys hate this woman and insult her personality. I mean if she said something wrong then bring correct views and counter-arguments instead of bashing her. I never said i agree with every single word she speak but her views about RSS/MODI are not any different than mine
 
.
How culture of Indian Muslim is different than those of Indian Hindus? I thought culture is about language/dress/food/music etc You need to go and look definition of word revert before using it. For example you were born Hindu you become Muslim later on and then change your mind again and get back to Hindusim only then you should be called revert to Hinduism. If someone born as Muslim and then adopt Hinduism then he will be a convert not revert

he uses the word revert to probably imply all Indians are Hindus or something. The same way I have seen Muslim fundamentalists uses the word 'revert'. Something to do with everyone is born into Islam and then is corrupted by their parents or something.

For an Atheist, I am in awe of the ability of religion to mobilise people.

There is a lot of money in it too. Hmm... If I can figure a way, :D

I don't know why you guys hate this woman and insult her personality. I mean if she said something wrong then bring correct views and counter-arguments instead of bashing her. I never said i agree with every single word she speak but her views about RSS/MODI are not any different than mine

actually, I like the fact that Arundhati Roy is there. It makes the 'All Male' club of intelligentsia shift uncomfortably in their seats.

I do have an ideological disagreement with her about free market. I am a proponent of capitalism and privatisation (except some fields).

I do think a lot of poverty has been enabled by the well meaning, well intentioned socialism of the Congress.

The Chinese and the West wised upto this, but Indian politicians seem enslaved to populism.

I have history on my side. It seems when it comes to economics, you can tell it isn't her forte.

What are your views about Tarek Fatah? If you hold this woman's views in high regard, you should be just as open and welcoming of his views about Pakistan and the likes of Jinnah and Zia ul Haq.

what do you think of Arundhati though?
 
Last edited:
.
I don't know why you guys hate this woman and insult her personality. I mean if she said something wrong then bring correct views and counter-arguments instead of bashing her. I never said i agree with every single word she speak but her views about RSS/MODI are not any different than mine

It's because she is extremely prejudiced in her stance against the RSS/Modi, just like how Tarek Fateh is about anything Pakistani. She reads an RSS text from the 40s and 50s to support her stance, a time when Nazism and Fascism were still in vogue. Why not read out from contemporary RSS texts?

And please do educate yourself about those incidents from multiple sources. Sticking to her version of things alone is about as fcuked up as sticking to Tarek Fateh's narrative alone about Pakistan.

what do you think of Arundhati though?

I think she's a good example of a left-winger caught up in the infallability of his/her own narrative of things. I pretty much do not like anyone who takes a rigid position within the political spectrum, be it right or left. And rigidity is what breeds intolerance. Arundhati Roy is someone who refuses to see things from any other perspective than what she is seeing now. In many ways, she's part of the problem and not the solution.
 
Last edited:
.
he uses the word revert to probably imply all Indians are Hindus or something. The same way I have seen Muslim fundamentalists uses the word 'revert'. Something to do with everyone is born into Islam and then is corrupted by their parents or something.

For an Atheist, I am in awe of the ability of religion to mobilise people.

There is a lot of money in it too. Hmm... If I can figure a way, :D
You are right. According to Islam every child born as Muslim and then his society/parent make him Christian/atheist/polytheist/agnostic etc that's why they often use word revert for those who join Islam from different religion . I think we get ability to decide religion/beliefs for ourselves only when we become adult and before that its our parent who brainwash us about different beliefs and make decisions for ourselves :)
 
.
Off late, quite a lot of new members have joined with very strong rightwing views (from India). It will be interesting to know what percentage of indians here hold such view.
Request only Indian members who are of dharmic faith(support base of RSS) to participate, to get a better picture/statistics.
What is their view anyways?
 
. .
It's because she is extremely prejudiced in her stance against the RSS/Modi, just like how Tarek Fateh is about anything Pakistani. She reads an RSS text from the 40s and 50s to support her stance, a time when Nazism and Fascism were still in vogue. Why not read out from contemporary RSS texts?

And please do educate yourself about those incidents from multiple sources. Sticking to her version of things alone is about as fcuked up as sticking to Tarek Fateh's narrative alone about Pakistan.
.
so what are your views about RSS/MODI? they are frishtey and never involved in wrong doings..Even killer could have many other good traits but you don't become prejudiced if you talk about his act of killing
 
.
so what are your views about RSS/MODI? they are frishtey and never involved in wrong doings..Even killer could have many other good traits but you don't become prejudiced if you talk about his act of killing

well, he had his own pages long arguments with those folks here. @Indischer is not a religious extremist :-)
 
. . .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom