How Kashmir was stolen from Pakistan by Mountbatten

[NeutralCitizen]

Not an acceptable excuse.

Now for your little education: Pakistan had surplus energy only 4 years ago and future plan of energy was laid out in 2002 power policy of Pakistan.
Apparently, Pakistan's present problems are because of Zardari & Rehmna Malik.

There is no excuse pakistani kashmir is worse off thats why I've suggest it to be gifted to china, they will turn it into a jewel pakistani kashmir is worse off then indian kashmir .

 

[INDIC]

Because Sindh was a Muslim Majority State/Province. Punjab was also a Muslim majority State, so it should have come to Pakistan as a whole. The whole division of Punjab and Bengal was unjust as they were both MUSLIM MAJORITY STATES.

So, you got Muslim majority districts from Assam province for your East Bengal province. Tharparkar, Umarkot and Mirpurkhas were all bordering Rajasthan it was to be the part of India.

 

[BATMAN]

Bottom line is you aint getting an inch of Kashmir. You guys train and send terrorists, and when we kill them you start crying human rights. Its a cowardly ****** game played by the Pakistani Govt and Army, but we are not going to fall for it. Train and send as many terrorists as you want, we will kill them all and not a single inch of Kashmir will be yours. You can keep crying for the human rights of these terrorists, but we wont spare them.

No it is Indian army who want to kill Pakistanis and are doing it via their proxies...ie. BLA TTP
Stop lying. Both terrorist organizations are products of RAW and are killing ONLY Pakistani soldiers.

Unfortunately, motherfucker Iftikhar ch. released this terrorist..

 

[Armstrong]

Not an acceptable excuse.

Now for your little education: Pakistan had surplus energy only 4 years ago and future plan of energy was laid out in 2002 power policy of Pakistan.
Apparently, Pakistan's present problems are because of Zardari & Rehmna Malik.

Yeah the funny thing is that our present condition when we're fighting an insurgency in Balochistan, militancy in KP and Zardari in Islamabad, gets extrapolated as reflective of our condition for the 65 years of our existence !

If countries start falling apart because of power outages then India in the '90s, Bangladesh and Pakistan of the present and even China of the '60s and '70s would have long fragmented. Yes...we've got problems...big problems and yes it begets a lot of resentment from Us - the People, but that resentment is a far-cry from 'Lets create another country...eh ?' !

And besides....we didn't fight for a 'Pakistan' for economic reasons....we fought for it for reasons our friends still don't understand !

 

[neutral_person]

The rule was that those States with Muslim Majority had to go to Pakistan. All the States of West Pakistan had Muslim majority including Punjab, so according to the guiding principle there should not have been any division of Punjab. Similarly Bengal was a Miuslim majority area and there was no Justification of division of Bengal.

Both East Punjab and West Bengal were stolen by India in contravention to the guiding Priciple of Partition.

Firstly the rule was a dumb rule that Muslim league created to maximize how much land they can get, and Congress (more importantly the British Govt in charge) never accepted it. So yeah, it was what the Muslim League wanted so they could mazimize and take over Hindu/Sikh areas in Punjab and Bengal.

You are making a dumb argument now and even you shoudl know it. Hindus like me who have ancestors in present day Pakistan would never want to be a part of an Islamic nation where we are 2nd class citizens. We (Hindu/Sikh Punjabis) would have revolted and joined India later on anyways.

 

[kumarkumar1867]

Be careful what you ask for because you might get it....

Modi might make you lose few more states of India..

lol we never lost any state in 65 years ...You broked in two pieces in 1971 .We know modi will not get chance but if given chance I bet Modi will solve kashmir issue with in 2 year..and his solution will ensure pakistan breaking into pieces. Imagine if PA gets its hands off kashmir what will conditions in Pakistan??

 

[Pakistanisage]

It is frightening to think what would have been the condition of kafirs ie pandits,buddists in islamic republic of pakistan if you got all the land .. In india kashmiris are less than 10% of our muslim population .. If more than 90% can live happily then kashmiri muslims should have no probs

Really ? The 90% Happy include the 3000+ Gujarati Muslims Massacred on Modi's orders.

So the 3000+ innocent Indian Muslims who were Slaughtered died HAPPY ?

Or the Muslims butchered during the Ayodhya Massacre were dying HAPPILY by the Hindu Fundamentalists.

Are'nt you even Embarrased making such Bogus and BS claims ?

Or are you so brainwashed that you have lost sight of right and wrong ?

 

[zip]

Life is cruel .. We lost our people , our land but we are still moving on ..so move on rather than dreaming for land which was never yours and never will be ..

 

[Armstrong]

we don't believe in two nation theory. it was seen by rest of the world when Pakistani ppl didn't let a Bengali as pm.and was adamant in making Urdu, national language when majority was of Urdu and Bengali.
the theory was broken by Pakistani's and they still don't know that it doesn't exist.

Oh laalay...there have been 4 Bengali PMs, 1 Bengali President and 2 Bengali Governor Generals in Pakistan's history ! And Urdu was chosen as our National Language simply because it was 1) a non-partisan language i.e it wasn't associated with any ethnicity and was a minority language (even now only 9% of Pakistanis speak it as their mother tongue). And 2) it was and remains our lingua-franca....everyone from the deserts of Balochistan to the peaks of Skardu can and could understand it in varying degrees. I blame Pakistani Leadership for a lot of wrongs done to the Bengalis but the Urdu-Bengali controversy is one whose blame lies at their feet not ours !

 

[BATMAN]

There is no excuse pakistani kashmir is worse off thats why I've suggest it to be gifted to china, they will turn it into a jewel pakistani kashmir is worse off then indian kashmir .

Problem is you Indian growup with flase history. You are beyond fix.

There are 500k Indian army soldiers posted in Kashmir and you call it better?

Apparently Indian Kashmir is worst than Syria and is like this since last 60 years.

 

[neutral_person]

Really ?

So the 3000+ innocent Indian Muslims who were Slaughtered died HAPPY ?

Or the Muslims butchered during the Ayodhya Massacre were dying HAPPILY by the Hindu Fundamentalists.

Are'nt you even Embarrased making such Bogus and BS claims ?

Or are you so brainwashed that you have lost sight of right and wrong ?

Im sorry how many Muslim Bengalees did you guys kill again in 1971? was it 3 million or something if I am not mistaken?

What about Balochistan, where you guys are killing and raping all the time, that they want to separate?

What about your treatment of Ahmadis?

What about the targetted Shia killings?

What abour the ethnic violence in Karachi between Mohajirs and Pathans?


Are you not embarrased at making such BS and bogus claims? Or are you brainwashed whats right and wrong?
Pakistan has killed so many more Muslims than India, that the less you talk the better. Look at yourself first.

 

[Pakistanisage]

Funny you say that when 69% of Kashmiris voted last election, and most of them selected Omar Abdullah as their CM. Omar Abdullah is very pro-India. Please get your half facts out of here. The only ones who want to separate are the Pakistani Punjabi Taliban scum, who we will kill and eliminate if they dare to break India, Inshallah.

The 200,000 Kashmiris you have butchered are not Punjabi Taliban , my friend. They are from Sirinagar valley and are Kashmiris. I think you need to come out of Denial, Son.

 

[NeutralCitizen]

Problem is you Indian growup with flase history. You are beyond fix.

There are 500k Indian army soldiers posted in Kashmir and you call it better?

Apparently Indian Kashmir is worst than Syria and is like this since last 60 years.

One I'm not indian what I've stated is proven fact and two syria is better with a baathist then having letting it turn into an islamist country that will fall into decay.

 

[SamantK]

Yeah the funny thing is that our present condition when we're fighting an insurgency in Balochistan, militancy in KP and Zardari in Islamabad, gets extrapolated as reflective of our condition for the 65 years of our existence !

If countries start falling apart because of power outages then India in the '90s, Bangladesh and Pakistan of the present and even China of the '60s and '70s would have long fragmented. Yes...we've got problems...big problems and yes it begets a lot of resentment from Us - the People, but that resentment is a far-cry from 'Lets create another country...eh ?' !

And besides....we didn't fight for a 'Pakistan' for economic reasons....we fought for it for reasons our friends still don't understand !

I agree to the first statement of yours but for your second argument that why you wanted Pakistan, you wanted it and got it. Crying now about Kashmir is immature even for your families who are present in Pakistan..

 

[PakiRambo]

Problem is you Indian growup with flase history. You are beyond fix.

There are 500k Indian army soldiers posted in Kashmir and you call it better?

Apparently Indian Kashmir is worst than Syria and is like this since last 60 years.

Why are they throwing rocks at a guy with a GUN!