Fishy,sending $4 billion per year to India from Pakistan

[halupridol]

But the money does through offical channel and has contributed to indian GDP. ther no denying in that


Oh dont worry at all we are very generous people:
http://tribune.com.pk/story/1040155/10-most-generous-nations-in-the-world/

We will continue to help those who are in dire need, even though our situation is not really good. But hey that's what being generous is all about

Oh thanku,,thanku.
But This meager monetary help is nothng compared to the monumental impact u guys have delivered,,abt which i am referring to n which will undoubtedly benefit us in the long run.
Thanku again

 

[X-2.]

I have went through the thread and saw thise posta with suggestion to "do a bit of research". Only if you would that yourself janab.

Pharmaceutical happen to be one of our MAJOR exports since some years now!!

May be you should think of some other products now.

Suppose all of this 5 billions are for business and route through Dubai bit still government Isnt benefit of 1 dollar
It's illegal transfer like rest of billions of bets (sata) other illegal stuff and altogether it could reach to 10 of billions around ....

 

[kaykay]

No, what I route through is perfectly legal


But to be honest, The muslims across the border dont share the same sentiments


My good friend if its illegal, then how comes it shows up in your gdp ? That's what I am saying the legal transferred amount if about 4 bn dollar now imagine the amount of funds transferred through other routes it would easily hit 10 bn


Abdul kalam also said that india would be chupa powa back in 2010

No my friend. This figure is not from Indian GDP or Indian govt....just some agency that too is only guessing without any specifics. Its upto someone to buy it or not.

 

[salarsikander]

But This meager monetary help is nothng compared to the monumental impact u guys have delivered,,abt which i am referring to n which will undoubtedly benefit us in the long run.

Oh. yes Living in delusions is India's famous free time activity

No my friend. This figure is not from Indian GDP or Indian govt....just some agency that too is only guessing without any specifics. Its upto someone to buy it or not.

Well, the figures weren't cooked up in pressure for no reason. Th figure could be wrong though but Aye the money is very real in fact i just sent back in Eid Al Adha

 

[halupridol]

Oh. yes Living in delusions is India's famous free time activity

Call it whatever u want,,,,kapitaan will get what i'm saying or atleast i hope he does

 

[SBD-3]

Rubbish? Proof? Most likely most of this money is being sent from Karachi via MQM's acolytes "creamed" from crime etc to their relatives in India.

Most of the trade settlement between Pakistan and India now routes through Dubai. Goods sent and received through Dubai and payments made as accordingly. Aside from that Bohris and Islamilis do visit India every year alongside the Urdu speaking families in Sindh which are still divided between the two nations.

 

[halupridol]

Ouch,,,,seems i touched a 'RAW' nerve,,,although it wasnt the intention

 

[SBD-3]

Should Pakistani's not come first - plenty of poor there? I am in UK and whenever I can I contribute to good causes in Pakistan. I would not, frankly, even for a second countenance India. The last penny in my charity pound would only go to one place - Pakistan.

Have these people never heard the saying "charity begins at home"? Or is it their home some where else?

By same logic, shouldn't you be spending your charity in UK?

 

[salarsikander]

But This meager monetary help is nothng compared to

this is very wrong @Feroz Alam Khan
Knows how much this help is important with no jobs and their social condition worsening day by day. You cannot simply ignore the situation and dismiss like that. I am sure the member quoted will understand it much better

 

[Indus Pakistan]

By same logic

I have small piece of cherished land in Pakistan. Nothing big. just bit of mud but it's mine. It's gift from my father, his father, his father and his father. They toiled on it. It has their memories and hopes stamped on it. They sweated on it. I would spill blood to defend it. That piece of earth is the reason I come to PDF. In honour of my ancestors.

UK and Pakistan are not at war. UK and Pakistan are not inveterate enemies. I send money back to help my brethren there. Those who are in Pakistan. Those who man the countries armies. Those who spill blood on the borders. Those who guard the border against Indian hordes.

If UK and Pak became enemies and Pakistan wanted to destroy UK then I would face problems. Then I would have to navigate my way out.

However it irks me, that million of us send money to Pakistan and some send money from Pakistan to a sworn enemy - India.

 

[Gregor Clegane]

@salarsikander @Talwar e Pakistan @xyxmt @haviZsultan @X-2.

Pakistan received $2+ billion remittances from India whereas India received $5 billion which means given that India's population is 1.3 billion and Pakistan 200 million, Pakistan per capita remittances from India is far higher than India's from Pakistan.

The World Bank estimates Pakistan received remittances of more than $2 billion from India.

http://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/...pakistanis-sent-5-billion-to-india-last-year/

 

[halupridol]

this is very wrong @Feroz Alam Khan
Knows how much this help is important with no jobs and their social condition worsening day by day. You cannot simply ignore the situation and dismiss like that. I am sure the member quoted will understand it much better

Ofcourse bhai,,5bil USD cant be dismissed,,,n i never dismissed it in the first place,,,,if u look carefuly,i wrote 'compared to'.
Ok let me explain,,as the dangerous thinking think tanky is around n seems he isnt too bright to think it through.
I was referring to the fact tht
Karachites have made sure tht first time in history ppl frm west of indus(blochistan,fata,kpk) to GB,speak a gangaland language(in kapitaans words ) fluently,,,the huge advantage it provides us isnt comparable to any amount of money sent,,,i was thanking karachites for tht

 

[SBD-3]

I have small piece of cherished land in Pakistan. Nothing big. just bit of mud but it's mine. It's gift from my father, his father, his father and his father. They toiled on it. It has their memories and hopes stamped on it. They sweated on it. I would spill blood to defend it. That piece of earth is the reason I come to PDF. In honour of my ancestors.

UK and Pakistan are not at war. UK and Pakistan are not inveterate enemies. I send money back to help my brethren there. Those who are in Pakistan. Those who man the countries armies. Those who spill blood on the borders. Those who guard the border against Indian hordes.

If UK and Pak became enemies and Pakistan wanted to destroy UK then I would face problems. Then I would have to navigate my way out.

However it irks me, that million of us send money to Pakistan and some send money from Pakistan to a sworn enemy - India.

For an emotional piece of writing, i give you full marks. But Pakistan and India are not at war just like Pakistan and UK are not at war despite UK conveniently housing the newly labeled traitor AH. I am often amazed at how quickly the brood of Zaid Hamid has spread all over the internet. If I have an apartment in dubai, doesn't make it my country, my country is where I live, breath and earn my livelihood and call my home. Living in UK while claiming Pakistan to be home is disrespect to your home country.

 

[salarsikander]

gangaland language(in kapitaans words

WTF is gangaland?

@salarsikander @Talwar e Pakistan @xyxmt @haviZsultan @X-2.

Pakistan received $2+ billion remittances from India whereas India received $5 billion which means given that India's population is 1.3 billion and Pakistan 200 million, Pakistan per capita remittances from India is far higher than India's from Pakistan.



http://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/...pakistanis-sent-5-billion-to-india-last-year/

Which is even more shameful. Thanks for pointing that out though.
A country of 200 mn sending 5 bn for a country of 1.6bn where as a country 1.6 cant even reciprocate the same amount let alone exceeding it, Indeed it is shameful

 

[Tamilnadu]

I have small piece of cherished land in Pakistan. Nothing big. just bit of mud but it's mine. It's gift from my father, his father, his father and his father. They toiled on it. It has their memories and hopes stamped on it. They sweated on it. I would spill blood to defend it. That piece of earth is the reason I come to PDF. In honour of my ancestors.

UK and Pakistan are not at war. UK and Pakistan are not inveterate enemies. I send money back to help my brethren there. Those who are in Pakistan. Those who man the countries armies. Those who spill blood on the borders. Those who guard the border against Indian hordes.

If UK and Pak became enemies and Pakistan wanted to destroy UK then I would face problems. Then I would have to navigate my way out.

However it irks me, that million of us send money to Pakistan and some send money from Pakistan to a sworn enemy - India.

You dont have to be irked sir..

Even some of the material for completing your CPEC is purchased from some Indian companies,person experience trust me...

Why do you guys import coal,i was thinking you guys have lot of coal,again personal experiance.

So you can say lot of Payments come from Pakistan..thats the reason your govt dsnt want to give MFN,then your Govt or military cannt sell hate to people.