Fishy,sending $4 billion per year to India from Pakistan

[salarsikander]

Well thats why I asked you because Western Union is not allowed to receive money from Pakistan to India and vice versa. Only option is third party banks or countries.....So tell me how exactly you send?

No, Not exactly They do block it sometimes. Moneygram through bank Al Falah. Although during previous tension btw both countries we have had to use different channel fro, Dubai Bank account then to india

Should Pakistani's not come first - plenty of poor there? I am in UK and whenever I can I contribute to good causes in Pakistan. I would not, frankly, even for a second countenance India. The last penny in my charity pound would only go to one place - Pakistan.

Have these people never heard the saying "charity begins at home"? Or is it their home is some where else?

Yes, You are very much right. But in Islam when you do charity you first look at your family, then at your neighbour, then you muhalla etc etc.

And secondly, trust me the condition of poor muslims there is very dire and desperate. People here in pakistan as compared are still much better. It is not that we dont support here,

 

[ghameed]

--------------

 

[GURU DUTT]

No, thanks. Would not want to get kidnapped or something. My heart and soul are in the north. Until and if MQM are cleared and that city comes under stable law and order, I will avoid it.


Well, if they get it from India (illegally) then frankly like Zaid says is 100% true. They are traitors and should be lined up against the wall.

well dont know much about now but till 2007 i my family used to send spare parts for vespa three wheelers to punjab(atari border) and karachi through dubai and the payments were made in gold & hawala through singapore

 

[punit]

well if you happen to go to karachi ask any person dealing in pharma or light machienerry and ask him where he gets his stuff and how he makes his payments ..... cheers TT sirji

my company ( in surgical tools) alone has half a dozen customers in Pakistan and entire money comes from dubai !!

 

[kaykay]

No, Not exactly They do block it sometimes. Moneygram through bank Al Falah. Although during previous tension btw both countries we have had to use different channel fro, Dubai Bank account then to india


Yes, You are very much right. But in Islam when you do charity you first look at your family, then at your neighbour, then you muhalla etc etc.

And secondly, trust me the condition of poor muslims there is very dire and desperate. People here in pakistan as compared are still much better. It is not that we dont support here,

Then how come its remittance from Pakistan of third party country is involved? Also even this is hawala and so illigal. On topic, Actually these money comes and go in the form of undocumented and Illigal business between two countries for eg- Pirated cds, DTH, spare parts, hell even petroleum products as I recall an old article.

 

[Kal Muah]

Then how come its remittance from Pakistan of third party country is involved? Also even this is hawala and so illigal. On topic, Actually these money comes and go in the form of undocumented and Illigal business between two countries for eg- Pirated cds, DTH, spare parts, hell even petroleum products as I recall an old article.

they are forgetting bollywood movies are screened in pakistan too which earns a lumpsum money for India

 

[xyxmt]

what if i told you that most of this money was send through dubai as india sends at least 4 billion worth goods to pakistan through dubai every years even if you forget the ammount of goods which are for pakistan but billed as for being for afghanistan

so Dubai authorities tell you this is from Pakistanis paying for something they bought from you?

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

Zaid Hamid (@ZaidZamanHamid) tweeted at 9:18 am on Sun, Sep 04, 2016:
Some traitor is sending $4 billion per year to India - making Pakistan 4th largest contributor to Indian economy.!! https://t.co/nRJIFhbbIH
(

https://twitter.com/x/status/772333031285788672

)

It's mostly people sending for their relatives - we do it all the time. Also, it's not $4 billion - its $5 billion per year.

 

[GURU DUTT]

so Dubai authorities tell you this is from Pakistanis paying for something they bought from you?

no those who send such stuff to pakistan wia dubai

 

[Great Sachin]

Direct from Pakistan = $4B
Pakistan money via Dubai = #10B

Total $14B. Pakistan keep buying from India and help Indian economy

 

[GURU DUTT]

Direct from Pakistan = $4B
Pakistan money via Dubai = #10B

Total $14B. Pakistan keep buying from India and help Indian economy

and had GOP been a little rational they could have got milions in taxing it if it was leagel

 

[Jaga Badmash]

so Dubai authorities tell you this is from Pakistanis paying for something they bought from you?

Leave them troll who spend 23 hours on this forum now suddenly becomes businessmen exporting goods to Pakistan, even one is saying his company exporting surgical instruments to Pakistan dumb enough to know Pakistan is one of the major exporter of surgical instruments to rest of the world why we import substandard items from India?

Direct from Pakistan = $4B
Pakistan money via Dubai = #10B

Total $14B. Pakistan keep buying from India and help Indian economy

Kindly quote reliable sources to support your claims.

 

[ice_man]

money from indian movie releases and other indian commodities such as PAN leaves 4 billion is not much when you look at the population of both conturies.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

4 Billion is a large figure if it is not clearly declared what is the purpose for the pay

Normally if it is a trade figure then there are ample proof of companies involved in such trade

Would be nice to know more details who is spending 4 Billion in India

 

[Azadkashmir]

see brothers that why we need to get rid of eletronic money/paper. gold and silver and barter trade. so nawaz sharif will get paid in barter for safety so that be two plates of chips, two cups lassi, one tea, 5 ice cream, a whole chicken, ten rotis, two boxes jalaibi. this jus snack time payment but it better than millions transfered in swiss bank.