What's new

Does India Need ASAT Weapon?

IND151

BANNED
Joined
Oct 25, 2010
Messages
10,170
Reaction score
3
Country
India
Location
India
773px-IS_anti_satellite_weapon.jpg







Anti-satellite weapons (ASAT) are designed to incapacitate or destroy satellites for strategic military purposes. Currently, only the United States, the former Soviet Union, and the People's Republic of China are known to have developed these weapons.

Having such weapon will boost Indian Power Projection capabilities multifold and such weapon may prove trump-card for India

My question is: does India need ASAT Weapon?

Discuss it
 
. .
^^ so you do agree we need such weapon?

What about the sanctions which may follow after the test?
 
. .
^^ so you do agree we need such weapon?

What about the sanctions which may follow after the test?

i agree bro. imo there wil be no sanction on india. bcoz usa and russia is in our favour. and china cant sanction us.
 
.
We need every weapon China or USA has. Though we do not have any evil intentions but why take a risk. If economy allows, we should be equally capable if not more
 
.
773px-IS_anti_satellite_weapon.jpg







Anti-satellite weapons (ASAT) are designed to incapacitate or destroy satellites for strategic military purposes. Currently, only the United States, the former Soviet Union, and the People's Republic of China are known to have developed these weapons.

Having such weapon will boost Indian Power Projection capabilities multifold and such weapon may prove trump-card for India

My question is: does India need ASAT Weapon?

Discuss it

Having an ASAT is not difficult...we can have one tomorrow if we want...what is difficult is testing them...there is a moratorium on testing it for the possibility of the debris causing damage to other satellites.

Chinese ASAT test reportedly caused debris damage to some Russian satellite.

We will have to face a lot of flak for harming other satellites which is a definite possibility.
 
. .
Having an ASAT is not difficult...we can have one tomorrow...what is difficult is testing them...there is a moratorium on testing it for the possibility of the debris causing damage to other satellites.

Chinese ASAT test reportedly caused debris damage to some Russian satellite.

The debris is the biggest hurdle, such debris may cause problem to several satellites.

But capability to deploy ASAT weapons is needed for India(if not much needed).
 
.
Well we don't need such weapons at present but no one knows the future. Anyway I believe that we can make ASAT weapons but its unlikely that it would be tested publicly in near future.
 
.
^^ what do you mean by "publicly" ? such test can't remain hidden
 
.
China talks more than its capabilities while India talks less then its capabilities.Anyway everything need not be announced
publicly.Acting friendly is what both Chanakya and Sun Tsu have taught.

http://'India attains the capability to target, destroy space satellites in orbit ...

India Takes on China

'India attains the capability to target, destroy space satellites in orbit'
Sandeep Unnithan April 28, 2012 | UPDATED 22:23 IST

The Agni V launch from Orissa
The Agni V launch from Orissa's Wheeler Island.
India now has the capability to target and destroy space satellites in orbit. "Today, we have developed all the building blocks for an anti-satellite (ASAT) capability," scientific adviser to the defence minister and Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) chief Vijay Saraswat told India Today. This capability has given India a deterrent against China. In January 2007, a Chinese asat missile destroyed an unused weather satellite.

The test opened a new flank of vulnerability in India's $12 billion (Rs.60,000 crore) space infrastructure. India has 10 satellites including the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) new Radar Imaging Satellite (RISAT) 1. Launched on April 26, the spy satellite can identify one-metre wide objects from space. China's alarming test spurred India's quest for a similar satellite-killing system.

The successful April 19 trial of 5,500 km-Agni V Intermediate Range Ballistic Missile that Saraswat calls a "game changer", is another step towards the capability to target objects in space. The missile scaled a height of 600 km before re-entering the atmosphere. "DRDO will field a full-fledged ASAT weapon based on Agni and ad-2 ballistic missile interceptor by 2014," says a top government source who does not want to be named. This weapon is unlikely to be publicly tested.

Click here to Enlarge
This was confirmed by Saraswat who says that India will not test this capability through the destruction of a satellite. Such a test risked showering lethal debris in space that could damage existing satellites. Instead, India's ASAT capability would be fine-tuned through simulated electronic tests.

Most military satellites orbit up to 2,000 km above the earth's surface in low earth orbit (LEO). Seeking to guide India's responses to this emerging threat, Space Security Coordination Group (SSCG) was set up in 2010. Chaired by the National Security Adviser Shiv Shankar Menon, SSCG involved representatives of DRDO, Indian Air Force (IAF) and National Technical Research Organisation (NTRO). Besides laying down the Government's space policy, this body will also coordinate response on an international code of conduct in space.

The US responded to the Chinese test by downing an unused satellite in 2008. In June 2010, the US indicated that they would consider a new treaty for restrictions on space-based weapons. A new treaty would foreclose India's options for testing asat weapons. Indian analysts say it could lead to a new restrictive regime on space weapons, like the present treaties on testing and possession of nuclear weapons and long range ballistic missiles. The SSCG has directed DRDO to accelerate its ASAT capability.

Another key ASAT milestone capability will be reached with the first test of a PDV interceptor later this year. This slender two-stage missile can destroy incoming ballistic missiles at an altitude of 150 km. The Ballistic Missile Defence (BMsD) project that aims to protect the country from hostile ballistic missiles has, in fact, developed the three critical elements required to destroy satellites. A long range radar able to detect them and a missile that can inject a "kill vehicle" or warhead into an orbit that actually homes in to destroy it. All these elements have been developed under the BMD programme.

The DRDO's Long Range Tracking Radar can scan targets over 600 km away. The 'kill vehicle' has been developed as part of the ballistic missile system. It has both electronic and radio-frequency guidance that can home in on ballistic missiles and satellites. "Unlike a ballistic missile, a satellite has a predictive path. A satellite has a diameter of 1 meter while our BMD system can track and destroy targets less than 0.1 metres," says Saraswat.


Read more at: 'India attains the capability to target, destroy space satellites in orbit' : NATION - India Today
 
.
I think India is descending steeply into the slippery slope of Arms race. Boy's Toys mentality seems to have gripped the Defence forces and DRDO and all kinds of fantastic, futuristic gizmos are being planned while the Infantry does not even have proper gear or decent rifles.
 
.
I think India is descending steeply into the slippery slope of Arms race. Boy's Toys mentality seems to have gripped the Defence forces and DRDO and all kinds of fantastic, futuristic gizmos are being planned while the Infantry does not even have proper gear or decent rifles.

I have read your posts in other threads , why the pessimistic approach .

We are spending less than 2% of our GDP on defence . As our economy grows , the % can remain the same while the spending will increase .

As for infantry , they are taking necessary measures and we have the F-INSAS program for that .
 
.
I have read your posts in other threads , why the pessimistic approach .

We are spending less than 2% of our GDP on defence . As our economy grows , the % can remain the same while the spending will increase .

As for infantry , they are taking necessary measures and we have the F-INSAS program for that .

That's because we are veering off to fantasy la-la land of futuristic weapons instead of getting the basics in order.

Few points to ponder:

1. Our nuclear arsenal is widely stated to be lesser than Pakistan . Pakistan is producing Weapons grade Plutonium at a much higher rate.

2. It is widely suspected that the yield of Pakistani bombs is also better.

3. India certainly does not have thermonuclear weapons. One dubious test followed by claimed computer simulation does not a thermonuclear arsenal make. What credible deterrence exists without thermonuclear weapons.

4. We are inducting delivery systems with minimal testing.

In my view, it is needed to take hard decisions such as resumption of testing, increased fissile material production etc rather than talking about achieving technologies which are clearly useless to us.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom