Do you support Bangladesh plans to move Rohingya refugees to a uninhabitable flood prone island?

[Śakra]

This Island south of Bangladesh is particularly chosen to Push Ronhingya in to India through sea route . India be aware .

Just like BSF deals with banglerdashers so will they with rohinjoes

 

[prashantazazel]

Flood prone? Build walls around it. The Dutch have already provided a template.
The laziness and extreme lack of innovation and hardwork of people of this subcontinent is apalling.

 

[Russell]

It's an awesome plan...and those shedding tears on here are welcome to take them off our hands. You wanna give up your room, house, land...go for it.

If not...stfu.

I wouldn't have taken them in the first place.

 

[Arefin007]

i support population exchange of chakmas in cht for rohingyas in arakan

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Flood prone? Build walls around it. The Dutch have already provided a template.
The laziness and extreme lack of innovation and hardwork of people of this subcontinent is apalling.

We don't even need to build any wall around it. This particular island emerged from the bay just 1 decades ago.So it is still not a matured island.Farther slitting of soil around it and vegetation growth will make it mature and habitable.But it will take some more years.Govt. is trying to make it habitable by encouraging human settlement, to develop the island govt. is investing 300 million dollar there.Many speculating that, govt. is trying achieve two objective by developing that island. One is to relieve some pressure on existing Rohingya camp and another is to make ready the island for future military base or settlement by Bangladeshi citizen.There were many island in the mouth of Bay of Bengal like this which gradually became habitable often with human intervention and now many lakhs of Bangladeshi citizen are living there.

Look at this map, numerous island in the southern Bangladesh.All these island were like the one in which Rohingya settlement is discussed.But they were gradually matured and developed to become human habitation.Many of these island are now full fledged sub district or Union parishad(administrative unit composed of several villages).

 

[Valar.]

Wow, simply wow!

I am really surprised by many BD posters here. Instead of sticking to the topic about their country and people and discussing a flawed plan about an flood prone island, they resort to petty insults, drag other countries into it, accuse people of being false flaggers, etc,. Someone is asking others to shut up, someone is asking others to take their refugees(are they even considered refugees yet in BD?), someone even went as far as suggesting sending their Buddhist population to Myanmar in exchange for Rohingya Muslims. And then the same people brag about so called religious harmony in BD.

Please try to understand that this thread is about Rohingya in Bangladesh, not about Afghans/Rohingya in Pakistan or Rohingya in India or Syrians in Turkey and Europe. So, kindly stick to the topic.

If you think by just asking a poll question and disagreeing with you lot is 'BD bashing' and ganging up on you then just think if this stupid plan of yours doesn't work out well and thousands of people die, what would be the reaction of the world?

Kindly, remove your petty nationalistic glasses and take a look at it with humanatarian point of view. Thanks.

 

[TopCat]

i support population exchange of chakmas in cht for rohingyas in arakan

Chkmas are BD citizen and they are not willing to go to any savage country.

I wouldn't have taken them in the first place.

your brain probably did not evolve to the stage of human. Not sure about your physical appearance though.

 

[Arefin007]

Chkmas are BD citizen and they are not willing to go to any savage country

chakmas can live with their bamar bros tit for tat and problem solved

 

[TopCat]

chakmas can live with their bamar bros tit for tat and problem solved

Chakmas has as much right to this land that any bengali have. We are not savage like bamars.

 

[Mage]

Are China or Pakistan countries that are majority Bengali Muslims?

And don't give me the cost argument, Turkey already offered to pay for everything. China accepted hundreds of thousands of ethnic Chinese refugees from Southeast Asia (especially Vietnam) in the 1980's when we were much poorer in per capita terms than Bangladesh today. And we had a billion more people to take care of back then as well.

Like I said, if even their fellow Bengali Muslims are throwing them back to Myanmar to be killed, what can you expect from anyone else?

Bengalis are the third largest ethnicity in the world after Han Chinese and Arabs. Little Bangladesh haven't take the responsibility for all of them. Besides they are considered Rohingyas not Bengalis.

Wow, simply wow!

I am really surprised by many BD posters here. Instead of sticking to the topic about their country and people and discussing a flawed plan about an flood prone island, they resort to petty insults, drag other countries into it, accuse people of being false flaggers, etc,. Someone is asking others to shut up, someone is asking others to take their refugees(are they even considered refugees yet in BD?), someone even went as far as suggesting sending their Buddhist population to Myanmar in exchange for Rohingya Muslims. And then the same people brag about so called religious harmony in BD.

Please try to understand that this thread is about Rohingya in Bangladesh, not about Afghans/Rohingya in Pakistan or Rohingya in India or Syrians in Turkey and Europe. So, kindly stick to the topic.

If you think by just asking a poll question and disagreeing with you lot is 'BD bashing' and ganging up on you then just think if this stupid plan of yours doesn't work out well and thousands of people die, what would be the reaction of the world?

Kindly, remove your petty nationalistic glasses and take a look at it with humanatarian point of view. Thanks.

Actually think it from materialistic POV. Humanity doesn't feed us. How can we accommodate other when we can barely accommodate our 160 million people in our small land?

 

[Valar.]

Actually think it from materialistic POV. Humanity doesn't feed us. How can we accommodate other when we can barely accommodate our 160 million people in our small land?

Do what you do best lil' man - keep on sending your surplus population to neighbouring countries illegally in millions upon millions(some might die by border forces though). Or you can always immigrate to some scandinavian country, live happily ever after there and in free time, log on to internet forums and act like a BD nationalist, well wisher, pseudo scholar or what not.

On a serious note, I doubt it BD is gonna feed them. First the world and especially Turkey is gonna feed them and then when they are able, they are gonna feed themselves. After all, even poor Biharis are feeding themselves too, right?

 

[Well.wisher]

It's so cruel dude .

It's an awesome plan...and those shedding tears on here are welcome to take them off our hands. You wanna give up your room, house, land...go for it.

If not...stfu.

I wouldn't have taken them in the first place.

Dude , helping someone isn't giving up on land , house .
If they were here in my country , in my city .. I'll let them live with me in my own room . I'll let the poor kids families live in my house . I'll providing them education .. everything basic of human rights .
It's not about them , it's about u . What kinda person u r .

 

[livingdead]

Noooo, unless govt builds necessary infra..

throw them in sea why should i care them ? they are useless people failed to merge live and settle peacefully and useful to their own country .

dude, if you are a minority who looks and speaks completely different language, its difficult to 'merge' with majority... especially if political system of majority does not see your people as equal...

 

[UKBengali]

A slumdog have the audacity to bad mouth China's political system, what a joke. you kind better learn to how to behave yourself, otherwise we can easily send you back into pre-stone age, and nobody will or could save you.

99% of Chinese support our government's position on myanmar, just like 99% of Chinese cursed our government's decision to allow in 20k your rohinya brothers to settle along our border, as a result, the governor of Yunnan province got sacked immediately. Don't worry, we will soon send them back to maynmar, and it seems burmese has expertise in dealing with them.

Never dreaming to cause any trouble in myanmar in any form, or we will totally wipe you out, literally. You government knows which direction the wind is blowing , it explain why they behave like this now.

What a dumb turd you are. You got 2 thanks from Indians with one claiming he is Pakistani.

China is still a developing country and BD is at where China was in the 1990s so do not forget your roots . Most Chinese are humble but does look like this extends to you.

I was not being critical of China's political system at all since democracy is a curse when a country is still developing. Look at the examples of Taiwan, S Korea, Hong Kong and Singapore as they all developed while under dictatorship. BD has semi-dictatorship now and this is why we are finally seeing sustained 7% GDP growth and also building up of infrastructure in numbers like bridges, roads, railways, power plants and ports.

My point was just trying to explain why some Chinese will never think for themselves and blindly support the Chinese communist party. Despite the fact that a lot of BD posters here are critical of the current BD government's handling of the Rohingya crisis we understand that a change in government now will be a disaster while the country is still so poor.



You have made anti-Muslim remarks on this forum but are you aware that the famous Chinese admiral Zheng He was born into a Muslim family? Looking at your posts I doubt whether you know much about Chinese history.

China will only grow to become a world power rivalling the US if it can carry the Muslim world with it. There are many fast growing and large Muslim countries like Turkey, Iran and Indonesia. It is critical that these countries come on-board as all the Western countries(includes most of S America), Japan, India and maybe even Korea will line up with the US in any confrontation between China and the US. Your current for convenience Russian "ally" will at most be neutral but may even take sides with their white Western brethen if they come to some accommodation.

Being friends with N Korea(already back-stabbed China), Myanmar(who knows when that mess of a country will back-stab China) and Pakistan(only because of India) is not going to be enough to allow China to develop into a fully industrialised country.

I do not of course expect this post to get into your simple and bigoted mind.

 

[Doctor Strange]

The burden of refugees in BD is immense. The price hike and chaos in the country is unbearable. But the refugee management in the country is top notch. Bangladesh took more refugee than Europe in a short span of time. One New Zealander was vising the refugee camp, you can see for yourself the situation there.