What's new

China won, but never wanted, Sino-Indian war

But....but what???? you keep talking about 62 conflict with India just to get few thanks from your own and Pakistani members in this forum? ...you say, it was your victory..I say, no, you pulled out the way you say japanese...if it was your victory, why did you pull out? For you information, most of the part of India was unaware of any such war with Chinese until they learned about it in their school text books....and you call it WAR VICTORY..what a BS claim u ppl ve been making over and over again!!!

No some like to talk of the 62 war to troll indians, India was already defeated 1962 believe what you like but it's reality, same with Japans surrender, as one of your other country men said forgetting 1962 and focusing on the present and I agree with him.
 
.
As a first, China need to clarify what it is doing in Srilanka, Coco islands of Myanmar, Nepal and in Kashmir.

Sri lanka came to china for weapons and help we helped them against LTTE and invested in them, Naval & Maritime base on the Coco Islands, Pakistan asked china for help to develop kashmir.
 
.
Why are there two threads running on the forum on the same topic ? Can the Intl. moderator please combine the two ?
 
.
This article is from the Govt of China's official propaganda newspaper.

China won, but never wanted, Sino-Indian war


be807ae1-ec3f-40b9-971f-5352fcb1bf81.jpeg



By Hong Yuan

It has been half a century since peace returned to the Sino-Indian border following the end of the border war in 1962. But 50 years ago, when China faced several difficulties both domestically and internationally, the Nehru administration, encouraged by the US and the Soviets, brought more trouble to the Sino-Indian border between 1959 and 1962.

China initially tried to avoid military confrontation, out of respect to India's ancient culture and sympathy that it had suffered a similar painful past of oppression by colonial powers. However, India's persistent provocation eventually breached China's bottom-line, and the People's Liberation Army (PLA) was forced to join the battle in self-defense.

Under the command of the central military commission, Chinese soldiers fought bravely and selflessly despite harsh conditions. They not only broke India's offense, but also destroyed its elite forces, such as the Seventh Brigade of the Fourth Infantry Division, and captured Brigadier John Parashuram Dalvi.

But when the sound of China's artillery reached New Delhi, the PLA decisively halted its military operation and pulled back its troops. The PLA's performance in the war shocked Western strategists and did its country proud. Its victory has also brought peace on one of China's most important borders for half a century.

War is a negotiating approach, but not a goal. Similarly, China's decision to fight back against India in the 1962 border war was to strike a peace with its neighbor. Therefore, while fighting with the Indian troops, China constantly urged the Indian government to end the conflicts and solve the border issue on the negotiating table.

China's peaceful intentions were further testified by its unilateral ceasefire on November 22, 1962, and its withdrawal of troops a few days later to 20 kilometers from the line of actual control since November 7, 1959.

China also carefully treated Indian prisoners of war. Injured Indian soldiers were given proper medical treatment and were sent back to their homeland. Chinese soldiers were even ordered by their commander to polish seized Indian weapons and return them back to the Indian army. This was unprecedented.

Then Chinese leader Mao Zedong believed the battle with India was also a political combat, and the real target was not Nehru but the US and the Soviets that had been plotting behind the scenes against China.


As to Nehru, Mao wanted to wake him up from the superpowers' influence by giving him a heavy punch, so that he would come to his senses and end the war. War is an extreme means of communication between civilizations.

The Sino-Indian Border War was not only a special interaction of two ancient civilizations, but also an unfortunate tragedy between two formerly colonized and oppressed states.

Mao understood this from both a historical and philosophical perspective, and so gave India room to maneuver and think during the war. By calling for a unilateral ceasefire when in an advantageous position, pulling back troops and returning prisoners of war and well-maintained weapons to India, Mao wanted to send a message of peace to India, and to lay a good foundation for long-term friendship.

Some in India argued that these peaceful gestures were made to humiliate the Indian army. Such an understanding is narrow-minded.

The Chinese and Indian civilizations have generally been in a friendly relationship for 2,500 years. In ancient times, Chinese Buddhists believed that India was the paradisiacal home of Buddha, and this positive feeling about India has never faded.

Now, the two countries have found more similarities. They both suffered gravely from colonial invasion and oppression in the 18th and 19th centuries, and they are both now powerful emerging countries and key members of the BRICS.

These similarities and historical bonds indicate the border issue between China and India can be solved, as the issue was a result of former colonial rule.

Fifty years ago, the Indian government was blinded by selfish interests, and wanted to force the Chinese to accept an illegal border line created by colonial powers. This was boldly rejected. Today, both countries need to learn from their ancient friendly ties and the lesson from the war. For the Chinese, they love peace but they will also firmly defend their land.

China won, but never wanted, Sino-Indian war - Globaltimes.cn

cmon at least they are saying it today.....who knows wat happens tomorrow.....maybe situation becomes better for good

but please no bargaining on arunachal ...... u guys have many beautiful places...let this piece of heaven be ours.
 
. .
Sri lanka came to china for weapons and help we helped them against LTTE and invested in them, Naval & Maritime base on the Coco Islands, Pakistan asked china for help to develop kashmir.


Srilanka - agreed as I have not read anything on the contrary.

Naval and Maritime base on Coco Islands - care to clarify the purpose?

Kashmir - Disputed area designated by UN - so what has China got to do here? As a responsible power and also one who has a seat in Security council, shouldn't China consider staying out of Kashmir?
 
.
forget history is not wise. History contributes to moral understanding and prevent people fall into the same trap twice.
 
.
Srilanka - agreed as I have not read anything on the contrary.

Naval and Maritime base on Coco Islands - care the clarify the purpose?

Kashmir - Disputed area designated by UN - so what has China got to do here? As a responsible power and also one who has a seat in Security council, shouldn't China consider staying out of Kashmir?

Helping Sri Lanka and China string of pearls.

The maritime is mostly for the PLAN communication it ties in with the string or pearls includes china energy needs and keeping them safe.

China was invited into Kashmir by Pakistan to help develop Roads ties in with the string of pearls other then that noting. if Pakistan tells Chinese engineers to leave they will leave.

but back to the topic.
 
. . . .
The maritime is mostly for the PLAN communication it ties in with the string or pearls includes china energy needs and keeping them safe.

China was invited into Kashmir by Pakistan to help develop Roads ties in with the string of pearls other then that noting. if Pakistan tells Chinese engineers to leave they will leave.

but back to the topic.

My last posting unrelated to the topic.

So no clarity around what China is doing.That is what I am pointing to my fellow Indians - do not talk about cooperation yet. build yourself economically and militarily and initiate cooperation with like-minded countries. Think about the cooperation with China after you have built yourself up.
 
. .
My last posting unrelated to the topic.

So no clarity around what China is doing.That is what I am pointing to my fellow Indians - do not talk about cooperation yet. build yourself economically and militarily and initiate cooperation with like-minded countries. Think about the cooperation with China after you have built yourself up.


There has been alot of talk in India about China string of pearls and it's encirclement of India but thats far from it, it's to cover China's energy needs, For cooperation with India it's already happening pretty good relations the border issue is minor.
 
.
There has been alot of talk in India about China string of pearls and it's encirclement of India but thats far from it, it's to cover China's energy needs, For cooperation with India it's already happening pretty good relations the border issue is minor.

China has 3 different routes for its energy needs at its disposal.

1. One through the Malacca straights to reach middleeast
2. Energy partnership with Russia thereby 68 billion cubic metres of gas and 300 million tons of crude oil from Siberia.
3. Gwadar port through Pakistan through Karakoram highway.

and maybe

4. Land route through Myanmar


China maybe has legitimate needs with securing 1,3 and 4 as Karakoram passes through Gilgit and Malacca can be cut out.


But again India needs to watch out and build herself .
 
.
Back
Top Bottom