Charlie Hebdo’s new edition to have Muhammad cartoons

[ares]

Chances of someone killing for Mullah Omar in Paris is far less than someone killing for Prophet Mohammad(PBUH). In fact only a hardcore terrorist would kill for Mullah Omar in Paris. That doesn't similarly apply to Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) where even a normal muslim might go towards violence for those bigoted cartoons.



Where it doesn't target a particular religion as a whole. When you target Prophet Mohammad(SAW) then you target whole of muslims instead of one particular sect or group.



Obviously. Is it really that hard to understand that you are asking such stupid questions here? Indian IQ can't even understand such a simple logic?

SO basically, you argument is, it is just a number game.

If your numbers are small, you can offended, but one better not offend a large group..because some them will resort to terror.

This is something equal opportunity critics do not believe in..and these acts of terrorism will not deter them..infact they will only grow stronger.

 

[Dr Gupta]

Brahman is beyond time,space and form you can not mock nor can you hurt it for the self is Brahman and ever lasting

 

[Dubious]

Quick question for all those people who critic their decision of publishing the cartoons have not used derogatory language worse than the cartoons about other religions. I have personally seen many people here who do that. My point is that one way of asking the same is being good yourself and then ask others to be good to you. I however find most such people insulting others day in day out and want zero tolerance when it comes to them.

Good question ...here is 1 for you to ponder....Who was trigger happy + providing weapons to BOTH sides during gulf war? African wars? Korea? Vietnam? Jordan? Egypt? Syria? Iraq? Afghanistan? Can we apply the same? Or is it only applicable to be thrown at Muslims but not for reflecting?

 

[Dr Gupta]

Aum. Lead me from unreal to real;
lead me from darkness to light;
lead me from death to immortality.
Aum... peace, peace, peace.)
— Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 1.3.28

 

[ares]

But you are yet to say Hebdo did wrong but you are quick to defend a random Jewish cartoon?

I am not defending, draw away, it is very well within the limits of your freedom of expression..or have you been attacked by any jewish groups for demonizing them is your cartoons?

It is way ok to exercise you freedom (as every bloody person tries to say) on where they wanted to ...they said that the pen is REFUTING THE EXTREMIST...So why not draw an extremist? Why offend a larger group? THAT is my question...

you are afraid of Mullah Omar and offending him But it is fine to offend 1.5- 1.7 billion and claim you are fighting Mullah Omar but not the 1.5- 1.7 billion?

When you lie you are against extremism and givign them an answer by the pen and then giving 2nd to 3rd thoughts of the consequences about that BUT say screw that lets get a bigger audience and NOT thinking of the consequences of that is strange, dont you think?

Actually we are not afraid of anyone neither Mullah Omar and his band of followers nor 1.7 billion Muslims.
Because we are doing nothing wrong. Equal opportunity criticism is about criticizing every one equally, no matter, how many or how powerful they are.

 

[Hulk]

Good question ...here is 1 for you to ponder....Who was trigger happy + providing weapons to BOTH sides during gulf war? African wars? Korea? Vietnam? Jordan? Egypt? Syria? Iraq? Afghanistan? Can we apply the same? Or is it only applicable to be thrown at Muslims but not for reflecting?

Sorry, I do not have understanding of that subject. However, I see people saying here that drawing a carton which might not even be offensive is bad but I have all rights to insult other religions. The problem is Muslims want no rulea on them but want to dictate rules on others all the time. If you want your request to be heard you should be more appecptable to others too.

 

[Rasengan]

Exactly. Today we would ignore these cartoons Tomorrow there would be complete movies and even TV shows targeting and mocking our Prophet Mohammad (PBUH). Some people in the west need to control their bigotry for a billion plus humans of this world. We won't change our position on Prophet Mohammad(PBUH). It is simply not possible for us.

The problem in the western world is that secularist have a deep rooted hatred against all religions because they are atheist and the concept of God is alien to them. Christianity has weakened in Europe, because there love for Jesus (PBUH) has decreased over the last three centuries, because they have allowed satires to mock there religious icons. The secularist have the same dream with Islam, where they want Muslims to have no love for the Holy Prophet (PBUH) and don't respect Allah. Even if we take Islam out of the equation and somebody in Asia or in the Middle East insults your mother, then it can lead to conflict because a person who does not protect the honor of his family especially the female relatives of his clan can never be considered a real man with respect. Since the Holy Prophet (PBUH) is above everyone else in our faith, then any offense towards him would definitely under no stances can be accepted by Muslims. If they want to criticize Islam no problem, however it should be within the parameters of an academic debate. The last time a group was demonized in this fashion in Europe led to extermination of 6 million Jews.

 

[KingMamba]

Some bigots free speech is not bigger than a billion plus people's sentiments.

Christian sentiments were also hurt by some cartoons they drew.

 

[Always Neutral]

These people are no less than the killers. They are also extremist in their heads.

Is your faith so weak? There are some good cartoons on jews and christ and the pope too. Not to forget world leaders? After all Mohamed was a man just like all the others he has made fun off.

 

[Dubious]

Sorry, I do not have understanding of that subject. However, I see people saying here that drawing a carton which might not even be offensive is bad but I have all rights to insult other religions. The problem is Muslims want no rulea on them but want to dictate rules on others all the time. If you want your request to be heard you should be more appecptable to others too.

The problem is the same an simple OVER GENERALIZATION attitude worse part is Indians use Indian Muslims to generate the stereotype

What we are saying is simple if Hebdo could do what they like under freedom of speech why are soo many being threatened their chair when they do the same ONLY not against Islam but Jews or even in this case Israel?

 

[manojb]

Are Muslims ok with artistic , non cartoonist depiction of Muhammed?

As per reza aslan historical y muhammad was depicted in illustrations. Only late 18th century wahabism brought radical extreme narrative.
Even sufi saint like ghalib mocked muhammad

 

[Dubious]

I am not defending, draw away, it is very well within the limits of your freedom of expression..or have you been attacked by any jewish groups for demonizing them is your cartoons?

Nope But I have been attacked by Indians who are more Jewish than any Jew I know!

Actually we are not afraid of anyone neither Mullah Omar and his band of followers nor 1.7 billion Muslims.
Because we are doing nothing wrong. Equal opportunity criticism is about criticizing every one equally, no matter, how many or how powerful they are.

Then why havent "we" seen any cartoons of him as a stand off against extremism?

 

[Cheetah786]

 

[Dubious]

Are Muslims ok with artistic , non cartoonist depiction of Muhammed?

Honestly speaking many would be uneasy but many would only do a march...the very fact that some extremists (esp those who just came from ISIS and were in jail for drugs and just happen to be Muslims) might get high!

 

[jbond197]

A cartoon can make a Muslim an extermist?? LOl Muslims are weak.

Lol, seriously and they say they have faith in their god!!