Charlie Hebdo’s new edition to have Muhammad cartoons

[Dr Gupta]

Lol, seriously and they say they have faith in their god!!

World needs peace and love not more hatred, say for example French mocked Hindu faith how we would react? yes we would not take up arms but there would be outrage and a protest.

The Hindu : International : Hindu rights group demands apology from French firm

 

[VCheng]

Are Muslims ok with artistic , non cartoonist depiction of Muhammed?

As per reza aslan historical y muhammad was depicted in illustrations. Only late 18th century wahabism brought radical extreme narrative.
Even sufi saint like ghalib mocked muhammad

That was then. This is now, and it is a very different mindset.

 

[RescueRanger]

I welcome the cartoons. I don't know what the prophet Mohammed PBUH looked like, they could be drawing any random Arab person for all I care.

I won't find them offensive because they don't represent Mohammed PBUH because no one knows what he looked like.

You cannot censor the world, if you find something unpleasant or distasteful, you have the choice to not click, look, read etc.

BTW I have read satanic verses, and i find it overrated. End of story!

 

[Hulk]

The problem is the same an simple OVER GENERALIZATION attitude worse part is Indians use Indian Muslims to generate the stereotype

What we are saying is simple if Hebdo could do what they like under freedom of speech why are soo many being threatened their chair when they do the same ONLY not against Islam but Jews or even in this case Israel?

What over generalization. You have a full country where others cannot practice their faith. I see two countries as India's neighbor with reducing minority, laws against minority. That's a very big number. Please point me to one country where Muslims treat minorities well? Why there is absolutely no movement by majority Muslims in favor of minorities? I am just pointing out that game has to be fair.

 

[Always Neutral]

View attachment 183509

Both are muslims but I agree one is a terrorist.

 

[boomslang]

Yea they just like hurting the sentiments of more than a billion 'living' people which is alright.

Put your 'big boy' pants on and quit crying.

 

[jbond197]

World needs peace and love not more hated, say for example French mocked Hindu faith how we would react? yes we would not take up arms but there would be outrage and a protest.

The Hindu : International : Hindu rights group demands apology from French firm

They regularly do that and btw there is a huge difference between demanding apology and killing. In this thread itself you can see how a Muslim offended by a stupid cartoon is abusing Hinduism. Well tbh I don't care but then I don't give a $hit for their cries too.. They need to be man enough to not cry over cartoons.

 

[ares]

Nope But I have been attacked by Indians who are more Jewish than any Jew I know!

What?.. did you now? Did these 'Indians' bomb your house, or did they try to gun you down? Were you hurt?

Then why havent "we" seen any cartoons of him as a stand off against extremism?

What do you want to see, cartoons mocking Taliban,Israel, Jesus, Jews, Hindus or Christians?
There are many of each..a simple google search will give you many results.

 

[Rasengan]

the selective criteria is consistent.. it is not different for different people.. for example if you draw vulgar picture of jesus you will unlike to be prosecuted.. however writing defamatory thing about a rich muslim business man can land you in jail if you are not careful.
You might find it illogical(I find it perfectly logical), but you cant say its targetting specific community.
I dont like the holocust denial law though, it shows extreme guilt than anything.

This is your opinion, however if you have studied the political and social transformation of Europe with the last three centuries, then you would notice quite clearly that freedom of expression and even the laws which tend to regulate Europe have been influenced by secularism who simply hate religion as a whole. Secularism is linked to atheism which is governed by a belief system to ridicule and ignore the existence of God. Therefore, in Europe it has become a social norm to mock religious iconic figures so that the religious mindset can be weakened overall. This phenomena has occurred in the western world, however it will never happen in the Muslim world, because the love of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) will always remain in our hearts.

You still did not answer my question on the idea, how freedom of expression is limited if you utilized vulgar language on a police officer on the streets of London. Furthermore why does the law not protect you, if you wrote defamatory words towards a wealthy businessmen...where did freedom of expression go. Does this mean that a poor man of society can never achieve justice and protection because he does not have the financial income to fight against his attackers? Why are children excluded from school, if they use vulgar abusive language to there teachers or fellow students..don't they have the right to exercise there freedom of expression. Why did America not except the mandate of the Palestinians when Gaza declared Hamas as electoral victors in the election? Why did America not respect the mandate of the people in South America, when they elected specific leaders..was freedom of democracy and expression forgotten?

In America your academic work would not be published or taken seriously, if you wrote something which was anti-Zionists. Norman Finklestein did although his career was nearly destroyed as a result, without the help of Noam Chomsky.

 

[Cheetah786]

The only wronged people on earth are Muslims!! Poor guys are victims of so many things!!

What ever helps you sleep at night.

 

[xyxmt]

Well said Sir!! We should take the religions lightly!!! They are causing a great deal of problems in our life.

easier to stop putting your finger in every hole hoping since last one didnt bite, neither would the next.

 

[Dubious]

What over generalization. You have a full country where others cannot practice their faith.

Yet we have a population of Hindus and Christians...we have churches and temples...if they werent allowed to practice these wont exist AT ALL!

I agree we have mad men in our country but over generalization of this form is what I am talking about!

I see two countries as India's neighbor with reducing minority, laws against minority.

Hence proven that Indians equate everything to India...there is a whole world outside India!

That's a very big number. Please point me to one country where Muslims treat minorities well? Why there is absolutely no movement by majority Muslims in favor of minorities? I am just pointing out that game has to be fair.

Bahrain, Malaysia (yes we have the everyday dissatisfied Indians like the dissatisfied uneducated Muslims of UK) Kuwait, Qatar, Dubai (Yes we have the common idiots everywhere yet every Indian will always be ready for a job in Dubai!)

No movement? Just coz your media doesnt cover it doesnt mean it doesnt exist!

Fairness is nowhere! Everywhere Muslims are unhappy coz of alienation (if they were happy then only an idiot would leave their comfort welfare sucking machine and go to die in ISIS)

Likewise, non Muslims are not happy in Muslim majority countries....what fairness are you talking about?

 

[xyxmt]

I knew this was coming. By killing cartoonists the terrorists cannot cower others into submitting to their views. The world cannot let terrorists win.

you don't know it yet, every change comes after some atrocities...its just too early to tell.

 

[Cheetah786]

Both are muslims but I agree one is a terrorist.

So I can assume you are rapist. Cause you are indian or Hindu.

 

[jbond197]

What ever helps you sleep at night.

Dude you got it wrong.. I am perfectly fine you are the people losing sleep over what cartoons charlie will come up with in next edition.