You said that we can't understand Quran unless we read different things.
I guess I conveyed in wrong manner, I said it helps to understand Quran. My prayers, and without this words means no use of it, so no problem in changing from Urdu to Arabic. 78% have no issue in Islam being used in state affairs and Urdu changing to Arabic. And if we have democracy then it should be implemented isn't?
If you can't understand it in your native language than what's the grantee that you will understand it by enforcing foreign language? Heck majority of people can't even understand Iqbal's poetry properly even though Urdu is our national.
Iqbal poetry is not compulsory, while reading quran, prayer surely is. And these two are meant to be recited in Arabic format, other things can be ignore .. Let me elaborate it in this manner. It's not compulsory to know Arabic, but reading first Quran in English, then Urdu do creates double effort of understanding Quran.
What is the criteria of being scholar these days? Every mullah think that whatever religion he is propagating is true rest are not.
There are two major systems which are running in Islamic world to be called a Scholar who can give fatwa (which is your cause of concern).
First kind Alims (those who can explain to common people for already formed ruling)
1) Madrasa course to become Alims .. (there is lot of things which are missing in this sector even, but for basic stuff they are good enough)
2) Masters in Islamic ruling (this depends upon what ever is your specialization, like bone doctor can't give perception for eye thing)
Then comes those who are known as Muftis The specialist of their field.
Show me where in Quran it's said that make your women Ninja and state should enforced it? Where God has given guidelines to women to safeguard their sanctity, before that there is also guidelines for men and one of those is lower your gaze. If someone is Muslim he/she should follow without any danda.
Already mentioned not enforced by the state, but compulsory for women. When it comes to men we will talk about lowering the gaze etc
In your earlier post you said "Why not" for enforcing beard, now you are taking U-Turn.
Yarr I never said anything about enforcing. I am saying, when it's compulsory, then what is the issue of having it.. read again.. I clear said in my last line, there are two extremes. But to avoid one, you shouldn't start following other one.
I already stated those things, and you have guidance for these aspect in Quran
Only few important ones are there i.e. Murder, Inheritance, Adulatory etc. - and non of those are barbaric like our scholars have made. for rest you can make laws which suites as per your society & time, only thing you have to care is that you don't go against laid principle (which is not be just, don't go to extreme and kind) and you don't need to become Arab to follow this.
no scholar made such thing. It's we our society, which says it comes from some scholars, or think normal molvi of the Scholar with specialization of everything.
Like We don't belong to arab to speak Arabic, even Urdu is not our mother language. It was device in India, Pakistani side were strictly following their own mother languages before 1947.
There is nothing wrong as long as these are ones self beliefs but it is wrong to enforce your views on others. Allow women what she wants to wear(bikni or burka its her choice), similarly allow man to have facial hairs as he like (and no a foot long beard), who are you to decide weather Ahemadi is a Muslim or not
well, you don't understand Quran, so don't jump into this discussion. It's not Me deciding anything, it's an establish fact between whole muslim world that those who don't accept Prophet Muhammad (SAWW) Last prophet is not a muslim. So they are not, like other established facts like E=MC2. or 2+2 is 4 not 2+1
