Will South India break up from India?

[911]

I'm a mallu and communist...
Implementing fifteenth finance commission is the main problem here...
V Bhaskar, who was special chief secretary finance to the government of Andhra Pradesh, and joint secretary, 13th Finance Commission, in his article on Challenges before the Fifteenth Finance Commission published in Economic and Political Weekly, 10 March, 2018 said that while Uttar Pradesh gains Rs 35,167 crore, Andhra Pradesh will lose Rs 24,340 crore. Similarly, while Bihar, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh gains Rs 32,044 crore, Rs 25,468 crore, Rs 14,735 crore respectively Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Karnataka will lose Rs 22,497 crore, Rs 20,285 crore and Rs 8,373 crore respectively.
Why we have to suffer because of the incompetents of Northern states???

Southern states with 20% of India's population have 50% share of domestic tourists per year. How much south states earn from all over the country just for being beautiful.

 

[$@rJen]

Do you really believe each individual in those states actually got that much worth subsidy? Those states are riddled with caste politics and corruption. The reason southern states are able to contribute more is because they can set up their shops all over India and have cities which get much more investments compared to poorer states. And brain drain from these states to south don't help their cause either. Although I agree on the population thing, it should have been done a lot earlier. The more the population, the more the delay in nation becoming a "developed" country. Now we have millions of people living in those states with limited resources, and not just them but the whole country is suffering because of it. This outrage is the proof.

Of course not..

and there's a reason for Why we get the investment. Stability, education and infra... no one asked the north not to have them. I as a Tamilian have no issue in this. but this can't keep and continue right!!! north have to do something about it instead of diverting funds everytime. and of course better would be to use a condom first then the family will have ebough money to spent on Education and rest ( No offense )

 

[Gadkari]

If the chief minister's of these states follow our principles... We are happy to help them... Their priorities are something other... Why we need to help them for their cow politics and statue politics???
Do communist China help India to alleviate poverty here???

LOL... what a pathetic strawman.

What has communist china got anything to do with the SATES WITHIN INDIA ?

Are you seriously comparing kerala to china ? I knew communists were retards, ...... but this is too much.

What moral authority does a communist have to protest against taking money from the rich and giving it to the poor ? Communist kerala has NO RIGHT to demand more, in fact, I am glad that its getting very little since now they will get to PRACTICE what they PREACH.

Got to love Modi fr forcing kerla to get the real experience of being a true "communist" state

Their are certain states who receives more share simply because they are amongst the least developed ones.

nothing to do with discrimination or anything.

This kind of BS is expected around the elections to label the current govt as North Indian hegemonic one.

As usual nonsense from opposition parties since they don't have anything else to offer.

Besides in India people from all states lives in every state, thing to ponder on.

In a fair system, the additional money needs to go with additional checks and balances to ensure that the money is not siphoned away by corrupt politicians. No free lunch and all that.

Of course not..

and there's a reason for Why we get the investment. Stability, education and infra... no one asked the north not to have them. I as a Tamilian have no issue in this. but this can't keep and continue right!!! north have to do something about it instead of diverting funds everytime. and of course better would be to use a condom first then the family will have ebough money to spent on Education and rest ( No offense )

One alternative is to send your women north to get pregnant and come back and give birth in the south.

That way, you can make up for your impotence in producing less children.

Why should a north Indian wear a condom to satisfy your lack of vigor or courage ? (no offense)

 

[$@rJen]

Maharashtra and Gujarat are neither North nor South. The economy of Bombay alone must be bigger than that of most South states and we don't even get decent roads. Obviously, there is a sense of unfairness but it has not boiled down to secession. Nor do I think it will.

Nope... KA & TN's economy is equal to Maharastra's

 

[911]

The outrage will be a lot worse if we really start implementing equity.

People in south somehow believe that people in north are paying less tax compared to south because they see figures as a whole. If the so called equality irrespective of population is implemented (which will never), it will put burden on people who are paying tax which will lead to even slower development of these states.

 

[Lil Mathew]

Southern states with 20% of India's population have 50% share of domestic tourists per year. How much south states earn from all over the country just for being beautiful.

This south-north debate is not good for the countries unity... But the concerns from south India should be taken into consideration...
For example.. Central govt contribution for karnatakas total expenditure is only 29% , but for Bihar is 80%... If you introduce 15 th finance commission, the scenario became worst...

 

[$@rJen]

One alternative is to send your women north to get pregnant and come back and give birth in the south.

That way, you can make up for your impotence in producing less children.

Why should a north Indian wear a condom to satisfy your lack of vigor or courage ? (no offense)

we'll think about it when you stop FREE LOADING.

north need to put cap around it to stop free loading from South NO offense

 

[Gadkari]

People in south somehow believe that people in north are paying less tax compared to south because they see figures as a whole. If the so called equality irrespective of population is implemented (which will never), it will put burden on people who are paying tax which will lead to even slower development of these states.

Distribution of wealth is a natural principle of a "socialist" state. Indian constitution does declare it a socialist state, does it not ?

Now people are getting to experience socialism

I have zero sympathy for those whiners.

 

[$@rJen]

@Gadkari

And you're remark on Kerala's communists... Kerala,TN and most of the south is prospering because we managed to keep RSS and hindu ideology out unlike the most of the northern part.

 

[Gadkari]

we'll think about it when you stop FREE LOADING.

north need to put cap around it to stop free loading from South NO offense

I am not a NI, but let me speak on their behalf.

No Thank you. We will continue to have children and live our life the way we think is best. You can stick it up your @ss No offence.

PS: Keep earning well so that we get to spend it

@Gadkari

And you're remark on Kerala's communists... Kerala,TN and most of the south is prospering because we managed to keep RSS and hindu ideology out unlike the most of the northern part.

Good for you. RSS and Hindu ideology has managed to win the center and that will help them take money from the south and spend it on the north on who voted for the BJP

Poetic justice.

So again congratulations on keeping the BJP out of the south

 

[Lil Mathew]

LOL... what a pathetic strawman.

What has communist china got anything to do with the SATES WITHIN INDIA ?

Are you seriously comparing kerala to china ? I knew communists were retards, ...... but this is too much.

What moral authority does a communist have to protest against taking money from the rich and giving it to the poor ? Communist kerala has NO RIGHT to demand more, in fact, I am glad that its getting very little since now they will get to PRACTICE what they PREACH.

Got to love Modi fr forcing kerla to get the real experience of being a true "communist" state

You didn't comprehent... India is not under China, so why communist China help India... Same here Bihar, UP is not under communist Kerala , why we need to help them as communists... Obviously we will follow Indian constitution... Also we have right to protest against a decision taken by central government against our interests..

 

[$@rJen]

I am not a NI, but let me speak on their behalf.

No Thank you. We will continue to have children and live our life the way we think is best. You can stick it up your @ss No offence.

PS: Keep earning well so that we get to spend it



Good for you. RSS and Hindu ideology has managed to win the center and that will help them take money from the south and spend it on the north on who voted for the BJP

Poetic justice.

So again congratulations on keeping the BJP out of the south

You say you're not from north, then why do you use the term "WE"

lol what's best for you is FREE LOADING !!! Alright then... i don't want to talk about it any more...
Good day

 

[Gadkari]

You didn't comprehent... India is not under China, so why communist China help India... Same here Bihar, UP is not under communist Kerala , why we need to help them as communists... Obviously we will follow Indian constitution... Also we have right to protest against a decision taken by central government against our interests..

Hey you have full right to protest ....... call for a Kerala Hartal and a full bhand to protest

Beyond that, there is nothing much you can do.

You say you're not from north, then why do you use the term "WE"

lol what's best for you is FREE LOADING !!! Alright then... i don't want to talk about it any more...
Good day

I have no compunctions in using the world WE. I use it with pride. LOL at your butt hurt.

Nice having a chat with you ..... I especially liked the part where you showed me how you have kept the BJP out of the south and thus have ensured that BJP can continue to keep spending the money on states that have voted them to power.

SO keep working hard and continue to send US those hard earned INR ...... I will send over some wipes to clean your tears.

 

[911]

@Gadkari

And you're remark on Kerala's communists... Kerala,TN and most of the south is prospering because we managed to keep RSS and hindu ideology out unlike the most of the northern part.

You think Hindu ideology led to overpopulation in BIMARU states? Just to let you know, the population growth have been greater among Muslims. And not just in these states but all over India.

 

[Lil Mathew]

Hey you have full right to protest ....... call for a Kerala Hartal and a full bhand to protest

Beyond that, there is nothing much you can do.

Will wait &see... We will not tolerate dictatorship...