Clutch
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2008
- Messages
- 17,023
- Reaction score
- -3
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The core principles of Islam have been remain same since Hz Adam (AS). Then there are grey areas like how much we have to follow an aspect, like Hijab. Then there are issue which are community based.Ideas evolve, Islam is also a progressive evolution of ideas and so also will Islam evolve.
Islam is Islam.
You are either with Islam; or you are with the Enemies of Islam.
AllahuAkbar
The core principles of Islam have been remain same since Hz Adam (AS).
Then there are grey areas like how much we have to follow an aspect, like Hijab. Then there are issue which are community based.
Just, we can't change the core as the Creator knows what is everlasting for humanity (primitive to modern times).
Islam is Islam.
You are either with Islam; or you are with the Enemies of Islam.
AllahuAkbar
May be you shouldn't ask the same thing again and again.You're just regurgitating the same nonsense,
See you did this again. This has already been replied in previous posts. You didnt seem to read it properly. All the best this time.come back to me when two Bengals overlook their religious differences and get united on ethnic basis.
Do you mean that Jinnah wasnt smart enough to understand this and hence created ONE Pakistan for Indian Muslims instead of TWO (Or multiple states)?The originnal plan of Ch Rahmat Ali had many Muslim countries/states in sub-continent, as it have been from centuries. In fact, India is the first time as a unified (w/o vassal states) country came to being in 1947.
Pakistan was never meant to have, Bengal in it. It was named Bengalistan. The name Pakistan is Pak-stan, comprising initials from Punjab, Afgania (KPK), Kashmir, Sindh and tan from Baluchistan
View attachment 769575
@Clutch @Reichsmarschall
Islam is Islam.
You are either with Islam; or you are with the Enemies of Islam.
AllahuAkbar
Allahu Akbar without condemning the wrong people who scream that.
I am actually very open minded about all that. But for all the islamaphobes out there such as Hindutva who wish we divide us... I say screw you... There is only One Islam and we are all One.
Islam is Islam.
You are either with Islam; or you are with the Enemies of Islam.
AllahuAkbar
@merzifonlu is Turkish so he may not understand your allusion to Hindutva but what he says is right. And he may be Muslim too. Understand what he says.
Jinnah didn't do the partition. He accepted whatever given as challenge.Do you mean that Jinnah wasnt smart enough to understand this and hence created ONE Pakistan for Indian Muslims instead of TWO
The 'Pakistan' created for Muslims is still there (Pakistan + Bangladesh). The secular 'India' created is no more, it is fascist/hindutva India.Jinnah created ONE Pakistan for Indian Muslims, and that one doesn't exist anymore
Bangladeshis are Muslims and don't want to live with their brethren just across the border, hence why Bangladesh exists. Despite being created on ethnic lines they still don't want to include their ethnic brothers from other side.why does Bangladesh exist in the first place?
Bangladeshis are Muslims and don't want to live with their brethren just across the border, hence why Bangladesh exists. Despite being created on ethnic lines they still don't want to include their ethnic brothers from other side.why does Bangladesh exist in the first place?
Bangladesh exist because they dont want to be a part of India? Or do they exist because they DIDNT want to be the part of Pakistan?Bangladeshis are Muslims and don't want to live with their brethren just across the border, hence why Bangladesh exists. Despite being created on ethnic lines they still don't want to include their ethnic brothers from other side.
Even if India wanted to integrate bangladesh the bengalis wouldn't agree to it just like the kashmiris.Bangladesh exist because they dont want to be a part of India? Or do they exist because they DIDNT want to be the part of Pakistan?
Mind you, both are different things. Now think about it as honestly as you can. You dont even need to reply , just answer it for your own sake.
PS:
1. India never wanted to integrate Bangladesh. So if they dont want to be with Indian union makes absolutely no difference at all.
2. Pakistan of 1947, wanted to keep Bangladesh in the Pakistan Union. That makes all the difference.
These 2 things will help you make an informed decision.
But we never wanted it and never proposed such union at all. So I don't know why are we even talking about it!Even if India wanted to integrate bangladesh the bengalis wouldn't agree to it just like the kashmiris.
If I am not wrong, Khan was thinking about 2 wings under federal union (not separate countries). Not too sure though, so you could well be right here.Actually the president ayub wanted to make separate country in 60s because running two wings separated by 1000 Miles of enemy territory was proving to be difficult and inefficien
There you go. The reluctance to accept the election results. That was the cause of break up (India was not the cause of it, just to be clear. The guys in Delhi only took the opportunity).Only reason bangladesh separated is because of geographical reasons and bhuttos reluctance to accept election.
just happened this week I'm glad partition happenedWithout Jinnah, We'd all be forced to chant Jai Siri Ram...countless people gave their lives for us to openly say Allah ho Akber in free and carefree environment.