Who Needs An Islamic State?

[muse]

But if the Amir ul Momineen can be desposed of he is indulges in a activity incompatible with his status.... Is that not acceptable?

It's about the equality of all citizens before the law - not whether the Amir can be deposed or impeached - after all, there is presumably more to your theocracy than just the Amir, right??

 

[haywards]

Islamic Law is From God and better than any man made cartoon system

So, go and protest in our country to impose it strictly with other ppl and lead them.
I'll be very happy if it get happen.

 

[Doctor09]

Islam is the best religion that speaks about the rights of minorities and their protection in Islamic state.........
And if you want to bring SHARIA LAW then you should first make ALL THE SCHOLARS of different SECT agree on the all basic laws which is very difficult thing........every sect has a little bit different opinion about certain laws......so first make a law upon which all ULLAMAS are agreed and then implement this sharia law........Islam is not confined to Mosques only its teaches us about every aspect of our life.....it even tells us how to deal in trade, how to treat minorities and even tells us how we run GOVT

 

[untitled]

It's about the equality of all citizens before the law - not whether the Amir can be deposed or impeached

Well I have stated above he can be brought to court for any reason and is answerable to a judge

 

[TARIQ BN ZIYAAD]

until 20th century minorities did exist in khilafa system, and when they were oppressed in europe they came to our lands and found the refuge and peace.

I would suggest to our non muslim friends to not comment on this thread plz

TARIQ

 

[Doctor09]

what's wrong in it , u cannot become president of U.S just bcoz u got ur P.R few yrs back. it is not oppression.

---------- Post added at 11:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:27 PM ----------


islamic law itself was made on earth by it's natives.

you should be careful about bold part
islamic law is explained in our HOLLY BOOK ( QURAN ) ThAt is from Allah and that is our belief if u are disagree to this then keep it to yourself

 

[muse]

Well I have stated above he can be brought to court for any reason and is answerable to a judge

I think you are having a comprehension problem -- Equality of all citizens before the law -- it's not about your Amir. By the way, would the people of the state be "Citizens" or "Subjects"?

 

[alphamale]

Well I think it is.... If that person is the most suitable person for the JOB... Better than any native born.

u contradicted urself , the same ques i was asking why minorities can't get top jobs in a state with single state religion, even if they may be better than majority.

 

[untitled]

I think you are having a comprehension problem -- Equality of all citizens before the law -- it's not about your Amir. By the way, would the people of the state be "Citizens" or "Subjects"?

Citizens

 

[alphamale]

you should be careful about bold part
islamic law is explained in our HOLLY BOOK ( QURAN ) ThAt is from Allah and that is our belief if u are disagree to this then keep it to yourself

i don't want to say anything now, i got my answer

 

[untitled]

u contradicted urself , the same ques i was asking why minorities can't get top jobs in a state with single state religion, even if they may be better than majority.

Because the country claims to be an ISLAMIC STATE/REPUBLIC/EMIRATE....
It wants to ensure its outlook....

So you prove my point too .... a secular states in the examples I have quoted are no different form Religious ones

 

[muse]

What would be the purpose of the theocracy?

 

[Doctor09]

a non muslim cant be the head of Islamic state because he does not know about the teachings of Islam and he does not believe in the SUPREMACY OF ALLAH which is the key thing..........

 

[muse]

a non muslim cant be the head of Islamic state because he does not know about the teachings of Islam and he does not believe in the SUPREMACY OF ALLAH which is the key thing..........

Which is why he cannot be equal before the law - Which is why the theocracy is an idiot proposition

 

[Doctor09]

i don't want to say anything now, i got my answer

yeah you should be keep quiet.......