Which space launch systems are better? India or China

[Banglar Lathial]

It's shameful that no Muslim majority country except Iran has ever launched their own satellites on their own launch vehicles. This is just another proof that Muslims need to think big and act accordingly. If you are stuck with the meagre or medium size budgets, nations, talent pools of individual Muslim majority countries, you are not going to become a big player.

Incidentally, Indonesia plans to launch its own satellite on its own launch vehicle in 2014, do not know if that will be successful. Even there, the space agency is underfunded despite a booming Indonesian economy.

 

[gslv mk3]

is it worth arguing with indian on these? they like compare china's present with their unknow furture!
Below is new wind tunnel, New Rocket needs them, that's the basic for many vehicle, Just enjoy it.

We also have those and a project like that....

http://www.space-travel.com/reports/ISRO_to_Set_Up_Sub_Systems_Integration_Facility_999.html

SAGA-220 is a supercomputer built by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO)with a maximum theoretical speed of 220 TFlops.

 

[UKBengali]

Anything wrong in keeping a higher goal?

Yes there is if the target is not realistic.

China's economy looks set to grow at least as quick if not quicker than India for the next ten years. They will keep progressing at the rate India is at. The gap will at least stay constant.

China can set the US as a goal as the Chinese economy is growing much quicker and so the gap should narrow.

(Money + Trained Manpower) = Technological growth > leaving out outside help.

The gap between (Indian Money + Trained Manpower) and (Chinese Money + Trained Manpower)will not close at all in the next decade and so their will be no relative Technological Growth with respect to China.

 

[chauism]

Yes but since 1996, China hasnt built any heavy launch rocket. Their LM3b is not advanced as the gslv mk3. Any rocket enthisiasts whould know why. U cansearch up on ur own. Their new LM5 is very advanced as mk3 but can carry heavy weights.

The bottleneck or the difficulty for Chinese heavy lifting rocket in recent years is ironically having nothing to do with the rocket technology. It is the location of its lauching sites, and their geography. China hasn't progressed beyond LM4 is because any bigger rocket would not be able to pass the mountain tunnel from its production facilities in Beijing or Shanghai by train to the lauching sites. Until the completion of lauching site in Wenchang, Hainan where the rockets can be transported by cargoship via ocean route, there is no way China will be able to deploy LM-5 rocket.

 

[Banglar Lathial]

Adding to the above the 4th area : Usage of space assets for Military and intelligence.

This seems to be suspect. Why Canada and South Korea that has no SLV of their own is listed, but Iran that has sent payload on its own SLV is not listed?

 

[gslv mk3]

Yes there is if the target is not realistic.

China's economy looks set to grow at least as quick if not quicker than India for the next ten years. They will keep progressing at the rate India is at. The gap will at least stay constant.

China can set the US as a goal as the Chinese economy is growing much quicker and so the gap should narrow.

(Money + Trained Manpower) = Technological growth > leaving out outside help.

The gap between (Indian Money + Trained Manpower) and (Chinese Money + Trained Manpower)will not close at all in the next decade and so their will be no relative Technological Growth with respect to China.

You decided that?????
Our scientist from ISRO are among the best in the world......tell us more about acheivements of
Bangladesh Space Research and Remote Sensing Organization

 

[UKBengali]

You decided that?????
Our scientist from ISRO are among the best in the world......tell us more about acheivements of
Bangladesh Space Research and Remote Sensing Organization

This is not about BD at all but China and India.

Stop diverting the topic to cover up the fact that some silly claims have been made that India can or will match China soon in space technology.

 

[Abdi-Karim Elmi]

Anything wrong in keeping a higher goal?

Whats is the plan for india's moon mission?

 

[kurup]

Atleast manufacture your own cryogenic engine before comparing India with any other country's space programme.

Maangay taangay ki cheezon ko jor jar kar samaan aasman pe bhej dena space programme nahin kehlata.

Comes from a country men who doesnot even have a space program ...........

vallorudem satellite vallorudem SLV ketti vittaal space program aavilla.......

 

[gslv mk3]

This is not about BD at all but China and India.

Stop diverting the topic to cover up the fact that some silly claims have been made that India can or will match China soon in space technology.

Who started to divert the topic???

Unfortunately bragging seems to be an Indian obsession.

 

[Ticker]

Who started to divert the topic???

You did......

 

[gslv mk3]

Comes from a country men who doesnot even have a space program ...........

vallorudem satellite vallorudem SLV ketti vittaal space program aavilla.......

erinakki pattiyude chirinakkunna pattikal

You did......

Example of an off topic post...

Nice post buddy...:
In Space launch vehicles both India and China are in paralell tracks. though i would happily agree that China is 10 years ahead....

India's GSLV uses solid fuel,hypergolic fuel and cryogenic engines in it 4 stages
Chinas Long March uses hypergolic fuel and cryogenic engines .

Both India and China are planning to replace them..

aim?
to make much cheaper launch vehicles having high similarity between stages...and using semi cryo and cryogenic engines

China

Long March 5 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Long March 5 (LM-5, CZ-5, or Changzheng 5) is a Chinese next-generation heavy lift launch system that is currently under development by China Academy of Launch Vehicle Technology (CALT). Currently, six CZ-5 vehicle configurations[1] are planned for different missions, with a maximum payload capacity of 25,000 kg to LEO[2] and 14,000 kg to GTO.[3]

India

Already developed a successful high thrust semi cryogenic engines....

The YF-100 is currently China's most powerful LOX & kerosene rocket engine. Development began in the 2000s, with testing directed by the China National Space Administration (CNSA) commencing in 2005. The engine had been successfully tested by mid-2007.

India

Geosynchronous Satellite Launch Vehicle Mk III - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The GSLV-III or Geosynchronous Satellite Launch Vehicle mark III is a launch vehicle currently under development by the Indian Space Research Organization. It is intended to launch heavy satellites into geostationary orbit, and will allow India to become less dependent on foreign rockets for heavy lifting.

India is developing a 2000 kN semicryogenic engine ready by 2014-2015 for testing

Example of an on topic post

Atleast manufacture your own cryogenic engine before comparing India with any other country's space programme.

Maangay taangay ki cheezon ko jor jar kar samaan aasman pe bhej dena space programme nahin kehlata.

 

[Ticker]

Example of an on topic post

Whats wrong with this post ....


>>>Atleast manufacture your own cryogenic engine before comparing India with any other country's space programme.

Maangay taangay ki cheezon ko jor jar kar samaan aasman pe bhej dena space programme nahin kehlata.<<<

 

[gslv mk3]

Whats wrong with this post ....


>>>Atleast manufacture your own cryogenic engine before comparing India with any other country's space programme.

Maangay taangay ki cheezon ko jor jar kar samaan aasman pe bhej dena space programme nahin kehlata.<<<

great!!!
we would ask SUParco(superduperco) help for it......
India has 3 cryogenic engines
CE 7.5 used in GSLV
CE 20 to be used in GSLV Mk3 based on gas generator cycle...
CE 600 under development based on gas generator cycle...

Gas generator cycle based engines are much simpler.....

 

[Ticker]

great!!!
we would ask SUParco(superduperco) help for it......
India has 3 cryogenic engines
CE 7.5 used in GSLV
CE 20 to be used in GSLV Mk3 based on gas generator cycle...
CE 600 under development based on gas generator cycle...

Gas generator cycle based engines are much simpler.....

Iskay baad kya hoga Kaaliya.