What’s Muslim about Kalam?

[Srinivas]

So why did he keep a muslim name till his death?

Kalam is not muslim name, it is arabic name.

 

[third eye]

The poster is not difficult to understand if you have been following him.

You are a senior with lofty thoughts and peers. Sadly we newbies have to grow up with these.

Well I have been following posters. Even before clicking on the post one has a fair idea what to expect by reading the names of the posters.

I see a sense of wanting to show some wrong where there isn't any.

Unfortunate approach.

Hindus are cremated. Since he seemed to be a devoted Hindu, will he be cremated? Or buried in a Muslim cemetery while pretty much renounced Islam.

He was buried yesterday.

He wasn't a devoted Hindu or Muslim - He was a devoted Human Being which is far far better .

Only most here cannot comprehend this or chose not to.

So why did he keep a muslim name till his death?

The same reason why Jinnah kept a Muslim name too .. maybe?

 

[Chanakya's_Chant]

Hindus are cremated. Since he seemed to be a devoted Hindu, will he be cremated? Or buried in a Muslim cemetery while pretty much renounced Islam.

He was buried yesterday -

 

[indianBong]

The article was published back in 2002 when Dr. Kalam became the President - The article happens to be 13 years old.

Rafiq Zakaria was an Indian politician and Islamic religious cleric. He was closely associated with the Indian independence movement and the Indian National Congress party. He was known for his advocacy of conservative Islam.

Interestingly he happens to the father of Fareed Zakaria - host of CNN's famous weekly public affairs show "Fareed Zakaria GPS".

Some other gems of that period include -

Assaduddin Owisi on Dr Abdul Kalam's appointment as President of India in 2002.

​

rediff.com Special: Muslims react to A P J Abdul Kalam's candidature for President

Yet another pearl of wisdom by our own Sagarika ‘Orange’ Ghose - where she calls Dr Kalam as Bomb Daddy (on lines of ‘Sugar Daddy’), calls him a ‘secularism ploy’ of Sangh and almost calls our scientists the symbols of a facist state. According to her, science & tech are a ‘Hindu libido’ thing.

This is what Sagarika Ghosh wrote about APJ Abdul Kalam in 2002 in Hindustan Times -

And of course these crocodile tears after 13 odd years...

​

Scientist are usually atheist or agnostic... AK may have been same...the above mentioned fools dosen't know that.... no wonder india is lagging behind in science and tech...

 

[The_Showstopper]

He is more muslim than those who kil

What’s Muslim about Kalam? Dr Rafiq Zakaria
Publication: The Asian Age


Dr A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, who will be our next President, is by all accounts a great scientist; his contribution to India’s defence is of the highest order; he is rightly called the Missile Man; every Indian feels proud of him; he is in every respect a Bharat Ratna. But because he was born a Muslim and bears a Muslim name, he should not be put in the same category as the two former Muslim Presidents, Dr Zakir Husain and Mr Fakruddin Ali Ahmed. Both of them were as great a patriot and Indian to the core as Dr Kalam. But they were also Muslims in the real sense of the word; they believed in the tenets of the Quran and faithfully followed the traditions of the Prophet. They worked for the uplift of the Muslims as much as for the progress of India. They were ardent followers of Gandhiji and had sacrificed for the cause of India’s freedom. They opposed Jinnah’s Two-Nation theory and were close associates of Maulana Azad. They had full faith in India’s composite culture and never hesitated to be a part of her ancient heritage.

Withal, they were also deeply involved in the hopes and aspirations of Indian Muslims; they engaged themselves actively in the emancipation of their community. Dr Zakir Husain built up the Jamia Millia Islamia and was for some time the vice-chancellor of the Aligarh Muslim University. Similarly Mr Fakruddin Ali Ahmad always took up the cause of the Muslims, both in Assam and in the rest of the country.

I am afraid, Dr Kalam has kept himself completely away from Muslims; he refused to mix with them and even when invited to participate in their nationalistic activities, he politely declined. As chairman of the All-India Khilafat Committee I requested him to be the chief guest at the mammoth Prophet’s birthday celebrations in Mumbai, which is attended by more than ten lakh Muslims every year, but he refused. This was, in fact, started by Gandhiji in the wake of the Khilafat and the Non-Cooperation Movement in 1921 to promote Hindu-Muslim unity. It has been attended by most of our national leaders both during the Freedom Struggle and after Independence, even Prime Ministers and other highest dignitaries have graced the occasion by their participation. Likewise, Dr Ishaq Jamkhanwala, president of Anjuman-i-Islam, which was founded by the third Congress president, Mr Justice Badruddin Tyabjee, tells me that his invitation to Dr Kalam to visit the Anjuman to deliver the famous Seerut lecture to pay homage to the Prophet was turned down by him. He has hardly shown any interest in the affairs of the Muslim nor has he had any affiliation with the practices and conventions of Islam. He was one of the founder trustees with me of Maulana Azad Educational Foundation, floated by Government of India for promoting and aiding education among the Muslims; but Dr Kalam showed no interest in its work.

Dr Kalam feels much more at home with the Hindus. His Hindu friends, with whom he has spent a good deal of his life, have testified to the fact that he is far more attracted to Hinduism than Islam; I find nothing wrong with it. But for God’s sake, don’t describe him as a Muslim President and take credit for having obliged the Muslims for giving them this great honour. K. Rama Rao, former director of Defence Research and Development Laboratories (DRDL) writes: “I have known him for more than three decades, but find him the same, from the simple and unassuming fellow who shared a room with me in 1954 to the one who became my boss in the ’80s. He would stay up late at night, eat vegetarian food and never show any signs of being a Muslim. I have not seen him offering prayers during namaz nor fast during Ramzan.” Likewise R. Aravamudan, former director ISRO’s Satellite Centre, Bangalore: “We lived in Indira Bhavan Lodge in Thiruvananthapuram. People there called him Kalam Iyer because he moved around with Brahmins and had similar eating habit. The only non-vegetarian food he ate occasionally was egg masala along with Kerala parottas. He would not talk much about his parents or siblings.”

Dr Kalam never reads the Quran but every morning he goes through the Gita and is enchanted by it. He is sincerely devoted to Krishna. He recites the Hindu mantras on every occasion. Namaz does not appeal him nor has he ever fasted in the month of Ramzan. He is a strict vegetarian and a life-long brahmachari. His roots are really in Hinduism and he enjoys all the sacred Hindu scriptures. Hence the credit for his elevation, in communal terms, should go to the Hindus; to give it to the Muslims would be wrong. In fact Dr Kalam himself would be happy if he is not described as a Muslim President and his name is not linked with Dr Zakir Husain and Mr Fakruddin Ali Ahmad.

This does not mean that he is not a good man or inferior to the two Muslim Presidents; I am only objecting to the appellation. He is in fact most worthy to be President. He is great in the true sense, and his simplicity, humility and honesty will add lustre to the highest office of our country. I wish him all the best; may God, of whatever denomination Dr Kalam believes in, be with him.

He is more muslim than those who kill in the name of Islam......

 

[mujhaidind]

I feel personally dirty, almost touched by the filth myself, unclean, defiled really, for reading such a thread started by a so-called Indian, at a time we are still in state mourning for one of our greatest sons.

@jamahir

Why arent you mourning Yakub Menon?

 

[KingMamba]

Funny I am pretty sure Indians on pdf used to point to him as a successful Muslim in India whenever they wanted to score some points.

 

[doppelganger]

Why arent you mourning Yakub Menon?

Why are you mourning the judicially sanctioned execution of a terrorist ?

Are you a family member or a fellow terrorist or a slightly detached disgruntled Indian muslim sympathizer with a victim complex?

 

[Kaniska]

Of course....i can agree with his frusration..He did not support any terrorist and greatest mistake he has done for which the author and his supporter's heart is broken is that he build nuclear bomb which can checkmate Pakistan??? Is it not an enough reason to label him as Non Muslim???

 

[mujhaidind]

Why are you mourning the judicially sanctioned execution of a terrorist ?

Are you a family member or a fellow terrorist or a slightly detached disgruntled Indian muslim sympathizer with a victim complex?

Why are u praising execution of an innocent man who was hanged for being Muslim.

 

[Brickwall]

For those who considers him Muslim or hindu, he would himself prefer to call him INDIAN....that was his identity, that what every indian is proud of him.

Some people following religious scriptures is more important then being better Nationalist or human being.

 

[doppelganger]

Why are u praising execution of an innocent man who was hanged for being Muslim.

I think you are confused.

I was and am utterly disgusted with a so called Indian playing religion politics over the body of a departed jewel of India.

Simple. Very base sentiment. Revulsion. Nothing complicated or intellectual.

 

[airuah]

Why are u praising execution of an innocent man who was hanged for being Muslim.

So the definition of innocent Muslim= a person who kills others with a gun or bombs. Interesting.....so are you an innocent Muslim or something else?

 

[Koovie]

May be because he knew his Genealogy; that his Ancesters were Hindus, forcefully converted by 'Zinda Pir' Aurangjeb.....
Further, Muslim or not, he was a true Indian...

His ancestors were also cavemen from Africa who danced around trees.... so whats your point?

 

[PathanBangladeshi]

For those who considers him Muslim or hindu, he would himself prefer to call him INDIAN....that was his identity, that what every indian is proud of him.

Some people following religious scriptures is more important then being better Nationalist or human being.

Abdul Kalam was of foreign origin like us Bangladeshis.