@I.R.A i think iknow which thread u are talking about the battle of qaddisiyyah , i actually dont disagree with decision to lock the thread cause discussion was going in a direction that few more posts later it could have turned into a lot more mess. As of discussion of history about yazeed that wasnt topic of the thread and i think there should be a seperate thread on it or people could continue it here in whatever. Infact on that topic i was thinking of responding to your posts here cause i wanted that thread to stay on yarmook.
Instead of locking maybe i would have liked that moderators delete all unrelated posts made by everyone and tell people to only discuss the topic of the thread and anyone derailing shud be thread banned permanently.
One more thing jo may nay observe ki hai , i have been reading this forum for like last 2-3 years, and had been a silent observer. May nay aik baat bohat notice ki hai aur yarmook thread ka topic dekh kay hee mujhay laga tha kay aisa ho ga n when iopened waisa hee hua, kay jab bhi sahaba aur khaas kar hazrat khalid bin waleed pay thread banta hai, iranian posters kay jhattay thread may akay sahaba ko abuse aur fazool batain kartay hain , akhar may hamesha aik acha or educational thread, iranian sahaba haters ki wajah say lock ho jata hai, aur yeh may nay is forum pay bohat dafa hota dekha hai.
Ab agar aik thread is discussion pay hai hazrat khalid kay war tactics pay tau yeh defence forum hai hum war tactics discuss kar saktay hain , magar us thread may agar deen discuss hona shuru ho jaey ya sahabi ka abuse shuru ho jaey keu k kuch iranion ko masla hai tau yeh koi tareeqa nahi hai. Sahaba kay ooper almost har thread yahan iranian posters ki wajah say hamesha lock ho jata hai. Umer ko abuse karna, abu bakr ko abuse karna, har sahabi ka tau abuse ho raha hota hai.