What will a secular pakistan look like?

[FaujHistorian]

I doubt it will ever happen because the majority of us feel safe under the banner of Islam.

Ask NWA refugees if they feel "safe" under the banner of Islam.

hahaha.

Man you guys think before you post? really?

 

[shuntmaster]

This is your wish.

Isn't it

My wish is Pakistan became a secular republic. My opinion based on reality is that Pakistan will continue to remain an Islamic state.

 

[qamar1990]

My wish is Pakistan became a secular republic. My opinion based on reality is that Pakistan will continue to remain an Islamic state.

that is the truth but this is hypothetical..

 

[Imran Khan]

Impossible.

The moral values of our society are based on religion and that is why it will be impossible to separate state from religion.

That is why pakisan is deep in mess lookat it religion make it sick. Mullah barking on oad speekers hate speeches blood everywhere and militry bombing with jets and artilry guns own land what more sign we are waiting for

 

[FaujHistorian]

if we get a secular pakistan where religion and politics are not mixed, what might it look like?
healthy, tolerant and hence prosperous.

how will it benefit pakistan?
Our future generations will have a nicer country than what we got.


how will it be bad for pakistan?
Secularism is not a magic wand. If we don't follow principles based on humanity and kindness. it will be bad from every perspective. Just like now. .

if we get a secular pakistan in 5 years, what can it achieve in a decade? what will it lose?
We can be an economic power like China.

list the pros and the cons!
See above

 

[qamar1990]

Ask NWA refugees if they feel "safe" under the banner of Islam.

hahaha.

Man you guys think before you post? really?

bro why are you trying to derail this thread? lets stick with the politics of it. lets not bring stuff like that in here.
those NWA refugees will probably choose hardcore sharia just so you know.

 

[Kompromat]

It would disintegrate.

 

[Shabaz Sharif]

Ager Secular mulk hi chaiye tha , tu india se alag kyun hue the ??? answer this question and you will get your answer

Secular Pakistan is the future, but mullah Pakistan any day over being with Bharoti scum.

 

[shuntmaster]

that is the truth but this is hypothetical..

If you really want to see how Pakistan would look like if it became a secular republic, then look at Bangladesh.

 

[Shabaz Sharif]

if we get a secular pakistan where religion and politics are not mixed, what might it look like?
healthy, tolerant and hence prosperous.

how will it benefit pakistan?
Our future generations will have a nicer country than what we got.


how will it be bad for pakistan?
Secularism is not a magic wand. If we don't follow principles based on humanity and kindness. it will be bad from every perspective. Just like now. .

if we get a secular pakistan in 5 years, what can it achieve in a decade? what will it lose?
We can be an economic power like China.

list the pros and the cons!
See above

India is secular and still shitiest and poorest country in the world. Secular Pakistan mean equal rights for every citizen and Islam to be kept away from politics, nothing more.

 

[FaujHistorian]

My wish is Pakistan became a secular republic. My opinion based on reality is that Pakistan will continue to remain an Islamic state.

Wish nice things for your neighbor and pray for better times.

If your neighbor is prosperous, you will be even more prosperous.

 

[qamar1990]

if we get a secular pakistan where religion and politics are not mixed, what might it look like?
.., tolerant...

i agree with this, if we stay the same we will never be tolerant.

how will it benefit pakistan?
Our future generations will have a nicer country than what we got.

does secularism really ensure that?
look at india and even some countries in africa.
even turkey a country that has been secular for 100 years is not" developed" yet.

how will it be bad for pakistan?
Secularism is not a magic wand. If we don't follow principles based on humanity and kindness. it will be bad from every perspective. Just like now. .

elaborate a bit...

if we get a secular pakistan in 5 years, what can it achieve in a decade? what will it lose?
We can be an economic power like China.

how does secularism ensure this?
we could become an economic power by staying the same as well, can't we?

 

[FaujHistorian]

India is secular and still shitiest and poorest country in the world. Secular Pakistan mean equal rights for every citizen and Islam to be kept away from politics, nothing more.

secular (read inclusive) society combined with export industry means prosperity.

India may not be a good model, but there are plenty of other societies that are inclusive and export oriented. And see if they are prosperous or not.

So let's go beyond India centric discussions.

Thank you

 

[greatone]

Secular Pakistan is the future, but mullah Pakistan any day over being with Bharoti scum.

Bharati "scum" as you put has no intention of cleaning up your shit-hole of a country.
We wouldn't touch you with a flagpole, get it through your skull my dear troll.

 

[qamar1990]

If you really want to see how Pakistan would look like if it became a secular republic, then look at Bangladesh.

whats there to look at?
they are in the same situation as us if not worst.