What's new

The sad history of International Mother Tongue Day

CaPtAiN_pLaNeT

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
7,685
Reaction score
0
The sad history of International Mother Tongue Day

The sad history of International Mother Tongue Day – The Express Tribune

By Farooq Tirmizi
Published: February 21, 2011

teachers-Balochistan1-640x480.jpg


The students were shot at by the police during a protest that had been a peaceful one.

KARACHI: Most Pakistanis are unaware that International Mother Tongue Day – observed on February 21 (today) – began as a commemoration of an incident that took place in 1952 on what was then Pakistani soil: the killing of four students in Dhaka by the police.

The students were protesting attempts to impose Urdu as the sole national language of Pakistan and were demanding the equal treatment of Bangla. They were shot at by the police during a protest that had been a peaceful one.

The events of February 21, 1952, were part of a broader movement by the people of then East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) to gain recognition for the Bangla language as one of the national languages of Pakistan. Most felt that, as the majority of Pakistan’s population at the time was ethnically Bengali, the language should be given a greater degree of importance.

Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the first governor-general of Pakistan had emphatically backed Urdu as the only national language of Pakistan.

Bengali political representatives demurred to Jinnah’s pronouncements but were never fully comfortable with it and began to press for recognition of Bengali as a national language.

With the appointment of the ethnically Bengali Khawaja Nazimuddin as governor-general after Jinnah, there was some hope that Bengali may find an advocate at the highest levels of government. So when Nazimuddin gave a speech in January 1952 unequivocally defending the “Urdu only” policy towards national language, it was seen as a deep betrayal by many Bengali intellectuals who had hoped for an acceptance of their demands.

A committee was formed on January 31, 1952, to lead protests in support of Bengali as the national language, under the leadership of Maulana Abdul Hamid Bhashani. A demonstration was announced for February 21, a date which would forever be etched in infamy in the history of Pakistan and Bangladesh.

The government sought to suppress the protests by banning all gatherings of more than three people in Dhaka. When the students gathered at Dhaka University anyway, the police opened fire, killing four students and wounding many others. This only served to galvanise the protesters.

While the government of Pakistan eventually recognised Bangla as a national language in 1956, it was too little, too late. The events of February 21, 1952 have been commemorated every year in Bangladesh.

In 1999, UNESCO recognised the day as a celebration of native languages and multilingualism in recognition of the Bengali language movement. It was formally adopted as a United Nations recognised day of celebration in 2008.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 21st, 2011.
 
.
One stuff really sadden me today there were no article for 21st february here ... despite we post 100s of article every day. So I have decided to post this article from a pakistan's daily news ....site. I would like to know from the pakistanis what they feel about this day ir whether they have any knowledge about this day???? N what is its implication on 1971... as regarding 1971 different parties are playing different roles... such as to the pakistanis this is bhartis interference to its internal matter to the bhartis it is their victory over pakistan and bangladesh would never liberate it self other then the bhartis and so on and in bangladesh also politics goes on regarding this who is the father of nation, who is the speaker of liberation ... n obviously the jammati or rajakar politics.
 
. .
So I think its time to treat Balochis fairly this time.

What are the diff mother tongues in pakistan?
 
.
Pakistan made many mistakes in mistreating our Bangla citizens. No question there.

what is your view on this day about its implication on 1971 and was it a wise decision of trying to make urdu as the only mother language or official language where as bengali was the highest spoken language on pakistan???
 
.
So I think its time to treat Balochis fairly this time.

What are the diff mother tongues in pakistan?

Every citizens needs to be treated farely not only beluchi... same also applies to India... especially the treatment it gives to kashmiri and NE indian people and the minorities.
 
.
I think 1971 took place because the punjabis were not ready to accept a Bangali PM, even though he was in majority.

---------- Post added at 02:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:13 PM ----------

Every citizens needs to be treated farely not only beluchi... same also applies to India... especially the treatment it gives to kashmiri and NE indian people and the minorities.

They have their own state languages. No one is imposing anything on them.
 
.
So I think its time to treat Balochis fairly this time.

What are the diff mother tongues in pakistan?

According to wikipedia this are the languages of pakistan...

Languages of Pakistan include two official languages: Urdu, which is also Pakistan's national language and lingua franca, and English. Additionally, Pakistan has four major provincial languages: Punjabi, Pashto, Sindhi, and Balochi, as well as three major regional languages: Saraiki, Hindko and Kashmiri.
 
.
Every citizens needs to be treated farely not only beluchi... same also applies to India... especially the treatment it gives to kashmiri and NE indian people and the minorities.

Here I mean to point out that Baluchis are the prominent ones who are complaining of Punjabi dominance. Just like Bengalis were in 1971. I am pointing out a similarity not giving categorical and theorotical statements on human rights, equality and blah blah. You need to see this in context
 
.
Can anyone tell me how come lingua franca is one of the official language of pakistan??? It seems little bit absurd to me...
 
.
can anyone tell me what is difference between provincial and regional language viz a viz pakistan??
 
.
Here I mean to point out that Baluchis are the prominent ones who are complaining of Punjabi dominance. Just like Bengalis were in 1971. I am pointing out a similarity not giving categorical and theorotical statements on human rights, equality and blah blah. You need to see this in context

I can understand that... but truely if you look at the future you may will have to accept some separate states in the south and central asia and those are Beluchistan, Kurdishtan, Tibet, xinxiang, Independent NE india and kashmir .... many of you may not like it but it is quite certain as most of the people of these regions want their own country. Hardly any country will be bale to stop that for long.
 
.
what is your view on this day about its implication on 1971 and was it a wise decision of trying to make urdu as the only mother language or official language where as bengali was the highest spoken language on pakistan???

I don't know the details, but I imagine the logic behind chosing Urdu might be that it is a neutral language. Pakistan had five major ethnic groups: Bangla, Punjabi, Sindhi, Pakhtun, and Balochi. If any of their languages were singled out for special treatment, others might demand the same. However, since Bangla by itself was the majority language, a compromise might have been to have Urdu and Bangla as the two national languages.

No easy anwer, I 'm afraid, except that killing the students was wrong, of course.
 
.
I don't know the details, but I imagine the logic behind chosing Urdu might be that it is a neutral language. Pakistan had five major ethnic groups: Bangla, Punjabi, Sindhi, Pakhtun, and Balochi. If any of their languages were singled out for special treatment, others might demand the same. However, since Bangla by itself was the majority language, a compromise might have been to have Urdu and Bangla as the two national languages.

No easy anwer, I 'm afraid, except that killing the students was wrong, of course.

I heard that there were some moves to make arabic or latin as the official language of pakistan as a neutral language. Any detail on that???
 
.
Can anyone tell me how come lingua franca is one of the official language of pakistan??? It seems little bit absurd to me...

Colonial history and pragmatism. You can't really get very far without knowing English.

can anyone tell me what is difference between provincial and regional language viz a viz pakistan??

I assume a provincial language is the official language of a province.

I heard that there were some moves to make arabic or latin as the official language of pakistan as a neutral language. Any detail on that???

Don't know the history, but sounds like a bad idea.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom