The Future of Kashmir? "Seven" Possible Solutions!

[Beskar]

sorry with too many posts....but kashmir is hot cake topic...

Lets see if we can conclude in another few days the best resolution (short term or long term) as a small group. If we fail to do so how can you expect billion ppl going to agree??

My short term resolution is Azad Kashmir should merge with pakistan completely. So both countries first stop cross border terrors. It looks like the idea is in Indias favour. But what ever violation happen in kashmir India cant point to pakistan. Now all inida telling is kashmir violation is due to cross border terrors. think about this point.

The only problem with adopting Short-term solutions is that it would delay the long-term process which already hasn't been sorted out for decades. That's not a feasible solution at all! Kashmir-issue should be sorted out properly and once for all! Otherwise, a short-term solution will further escalate another Generation of disputes.

 

[Omar1984]

The only solution is to have a fair plebiscite in each and every city, town, and village of Pakistan's Jammu & Kashmir and India Occupied Jammu & Kashmir. The ultimate choice for the people living in each of those cities, towns, and villages....Pakistan or India?

And we respect the plebiscite and move on with our lives.

 

[Salahadin]

pakistan should go for# 2

 

[roopesh]

The only solution is to have a fair plebiscite in each and every city of Pakistan's Jammu & Kashmir and India Occupied Jammu & Kashmir. The ultimate choice for the people living in each of those cities....Pakistan or India? And we respect the plebiscite and move on with our lives.

hahaha we give the people of Azad Kashmir their freedom, no one sends troops into Azad Kashmir and forces them to do anything. Pakistan is not like India, and I'm glad the people of Azad Kashmir are making Indians worry

Lol...we both cant even agree with each other....how could you expect India to agree??? All you want is tomorrow morning u want kashmir in your hands. thats not going to happen and you are not willing to listen anyother. I am saying india not ready to loose kashmir. SIMPLE.

Now see Azad kashmir, its a strip across LOC. India claiming that terros enter from this area. Pakistan is telling its Azad kashmir so It wont control. So reducing the violation in this area is in hands of pakistan. Azad kashmir air and land is in the pak military control. Why does pakistan not supporing to stop cross border terrism?

India at this moment is claiming that all kashmir violation is becoz of cross border terrirsm....simple...so pak has a responsibility to show to the world that the it doenst have a role in kashmir violation. ZARDARI internationally agreed that they are terrors.

 

[Beskar]

pakistan should go for# 2

If only it was that easy lol. Both countries will never agree to loosing big chunks of lands to their rivals. The only way both of them would swallow their pride, would be if there's an Independent state of Kashmir.

 

[roopesh]

I have another idea. How about pakistan putting effors to make its kashmir economically stronger ???? best infrasture place in the pakistan? This will force India to take counter actions to develop its kashmir economically.
U have to make kashmir economy depends on pakistan.

 

[Beskar]

I have another idea. How about pakistan putting effors to make its kashmir economically stronger ???? best infrasture place in the pakistan? This will force India to take counter actions to develop its kashmir economically.
U have to make kashmir economy depends on pakistan.

If you're talking about the bullet-riddled infrastructure on the Indian side of Kashmir, then yes, we don't have that.

Secondly, Infrastructures tend to grow stronger if the region isn't under a dispute for the past 6 decades.

 

[Omar1984]

If only it was that easy lol. Both countries will never agree to loosing big chunks of lands to their rivals. The only way both of them would swallow their pride, would be if there's an Independent state of Kashmir.

Jammu and some parts of Ladakh would never want to leave India, Northern Areas would never want to leave Pakistan.

Kashmir Valley would like an independent Kashmir, Azad Kashmir would like to reunite with Kashmir valley, but some people in Azad Kashmir, especially pahari speakers, would never want to leave Pakistan.

Only solution is a fair plebiscite in every town, city, village of both Pakistan's Kashmir and Indian Occupied Kashmir.

 

[Beskar]

Jammu and some parts of Ladakh would never want to leave India, Northern Areas would never want to leave Pakistan.

Kashmir Valley would like an independent Kashmir, Azad Kashmir would like to reunite with Kashmir valley, but some people in Azad Kashmir, especially pahari speakers, would never want to leave Pakistan.

Only solution is a fair plebiscite in every town, city, village of both Pakistan's Kashmir and Indian Occupied Kashmir.

I was referring to solution 6. Independent Kashmir valley. That way, our Azad-Kashmir wouldn't have to leave Pakistan.

 

[roopesh]

Jammu and some parts of Ladakh would never want to leave India, Northern Areas would never want to leave Pakistan.

Kashmir Valley would like an independent Kashmir, Azad Kashmir would like to reunite with Kashmir valley, but some people in Azad Kashmir, especially pahari speakers, would never want to leave Pakistan.

Only solution is a fair plebiscite in every town, city, village of both Pakistan's Kashmir and Indian Occupied Kashmir.

Omar do you have any suggestion to improve the situation or any temp resolution to pass for better peace for kashmir ppl. All you want to say is conduct elections..let ppl decide..etc...its not going to happen.

 

[A1Kaid]

Well Berzerk there are two additional options as well...

1) Co-Governance as first proposed by Fmr. Pres Musharraf he suggested BOTH Pakistan and India govern Kashmir together, with a joint governing body...Knowing both countries are against giving up any part of Kashmir he (Musharraf) proposed this idea.

2) The long awaited plebiscite!


Quite frankly a Kashmiri Plebiscite which can result in either ceding to Pakistan or independence but not ceding to India as we all know Kashmiris hate Hindu Indians for many agreeable reasons may be a good solution but as you know Indians know plebiscite means the end of there long bloody occupation.

Though I support dividing India, supporting separatist movements, attacking Indian outposts in the Mountain, intelligence gathering, calling upon the Mujahideen, economic sanctions from many Muslim countries against India, Geo-strategic warfare...

As you know after weakening India, we capture Kashmir honorably and just like the Mujahideen of the past would have done.

We must deliver the most painful pressure that this shameful country India has ever received.



SNIPER ON THE ROOF!!!

 

[Black Stone]

I think either Independent Kashmir or Status Quo because the other solutions require losses of land by Pakistan and India which neither of them are willing to.

 

[roopesh]

Though I support dividing India, supporting separatist movements, attacking Indian outposts in the Mountain, intelligence gathering, calling upon the Mujahideen, economic sanctions from many Muslim countries against India, Geo-strategic warfare...As you know after weakening India, we capture Kashmir honorably and just like the Mujahideen of the past would have done. We must deliver the most painful pressure that this shameful country India has ever received.

Wow! Here you go...The best solution ever found..Nice formula..Is this something not been implemented so far. I think you are already in action for a long long time. Muhahideen is active all the years. Good luck dear...u have a simple task of destoying 1 billion ppl.............

In the same forum we will discuss "IS A1KAID PAKISTANI OR NOT".

 

[Omar1984]

Omar do you have any suggestion to improve the situation or any temp resolution to pass for better peace for kashmir ppl. All you want to say is conduct elections..let ppl decide..etc...its not going to happen.

Why cant the people of the land decide their own fate. Its their right.

 

[Awesome]

We should consider the independence scenarios. Especially the 1st one. Sure we'll lose territory but not to each other and instead to the real people of Kashmir. That would make that region big enough to economically sustain itself.