SalarHaqq
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Dec 29, 2019
- Messages
- 4,569
- Reaction score
- 2
- Country
- Location
that's very weak argument by the way i only examined the article you post and from it conclude he was at Mosaddeq house with coupe leaders and the ones who designed it between Mosaddeq arrest and Sha'aban Ja'afari attack on his home . also i post a photo of him with sha'aban Ja'afari some week after the coupe when every one was aware of his role in coupe.
Reposting this multiple times won't change the fact that it's a scattered bit of information put at the service of a CIA-orchestrated narrative.
he was not revolutionary , if anyone Mr. khomeini heared his words was Ayat-Allah Borujerdi which when told to Imam don't continue political activity , he stop them till the day he was alive and after his death , he continued his fighting.
he was not revolutionary , he only cared for power , if it come wit England he was with them , if it was USA , then he support them , if Zahedi would have given him power , he'd followed him and funny fact , all of them used him and then throw him away.
But the Islamic Republic officially disagrees. Why should I not take its word over that of the CIA, MI6 or Mossad? Manipulative spin from the latter I shall be more than glad to leave to whoever wishes to buy into it.
and not all clerics worth the clothes they wear . there are few who like mr. Modarres , mr. Khomeyni , Mirzay-e-shirazi dare to stand against despots and monarchs and don't fear telling the truth and don't step back even when their life is threatened . even mr. broujerdi who everyone said don't interfere with politic , banned pepsi-cola because its brand in Iran owned by Bahaiis .
Anti-clerical secularists have a problem with the unchallenged historic impact of the Islamic revolutionary clergy in leading the Muslim nation of Iran towards self-determination and dignity, as well as in fending off imperial bullying and exploitation. However liberals won't be able to alter the reality, nor the perception of the majority.
wrong my argument only based on the article you post , a photo that is authenticated and et'telaat newspaper.
using only the data mentioned in the same article , nothing from CIA or BBC documents
...but relying on foreign-backed talking points in the commentary.
for kashani there is evidence from Iran sources , so you understand why i accept one and why i brush another one aside as forgery , if you can bring evidence on the other one far it be from me to deny the facts
Above all there's an interpretative, enemy-designed twist on the data. Both when it comes to ayatOllah Kashani and Imam Khomeini. In this regard there's a decisive similarity between these two cases.
so you claim , you accept what is according to your narrative and deny what is against yours , that is some interesting sort of discussion , no doubt you always win in discussion , well at least in your mind. here even you don't accept my cross-examination of the article you yourself posted. so tell me how am i supposed to have a discussion with you . by be a yes , ok , you are right person ?
Is anyone forcing you to have this discussion if you aren't happy with it? As a matter of fact you first quoted me and continue to do so.
by using what question it brought to my mind , please describe an approach acceptable to you and not a CIA designed one in your mind that allow examining the data so I use that
again i use your own article , I use Iranian newspaper , if you even don't accept Iranian news paper of the time , then what narrative we can use for the time reference , the person family who benefit from a special narratives ?
let just discuss the article you yourself post here , or that also is CIA and MI6 handiwork?.
As said I'm not too interested in engaging into vain nitpicking on this issue, since the general picture should be clear enough to anyone willing to connect the dots in regards to the smear campaign launched 4-5 years ago by you-know-who against the legacy of ayatOllah Kashani.
In the meantime, I'd recommend enjoying the AyatOllah Kashani expressway in Tehran. Wise choice of a name by the Tehran municipality, since the mojahed who happened to be the main driving force behind the nationalization of Iran's oil industry must be honored indeed.
Last edited: