Thank You Imran Khan for This....

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Mr Dawar is just stating a fact. Pukhtun = Afghan. I don't know why some people have a problem with this. He's a Pakistani citizen but he is ethnically Afghan like all Pukhtuns. Pakistan is confideration of different ethnic groups and respecting that fact will work in favour of Pakistani unity while trying to suppress the truth and basic human rights through false propaganda will weaken Pakistan.

Pakistan is confideration of different ethnic groups i.e Pakhtuns, Sindhi, Punjabi, Balochi, kasmiri etc. National identity of all these ethnic groups is Pakistani

Afghanistan is confideration of different ethnic groups i.e pakhtuns, Uzebks, Tajiks etc national identity of all those ethnic groups is Afghan

Word Afghan should not be use for Pakhtuns but should use for all those Afghans who hold Afghan nationality irrespective of their ethnic groups. Word " Pakhtuns" is ethnic identity of Pakhtuns. Saying Paktuns= Afghan is same like saying India or Pakistan is ethnic identity of Punjabi/Sindhi lol or India or Bagladesh is ethnic identity of Bengali. Those who believe in loy pashtunistan brainwash Pakistani pashtuns with these terms because they dont accept present realities of border and still living in durrani empires

 

[Zibago]

Problem with PDF members and all Pakistnais is that when they talk about PtM , they talk about Pashtoon also. These two words shouldn’t be in a single sentence. Pashtoon have nothing to do with PTM similarly PTM have nothing to do with Pashtoon. Pashtoon just aik muhra hy.

Problem with OSP,s people dont understand ground realities
The people rooting for ptm dont care about Pashtuns they just want to use them for political goals they failed in

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Aur @Areesh siasi supporter kisi kai bhe hoan,aqal sai pedal hotey hain.

Siyasi supporter hona ek baat ha . Ghulam hona dosri baat . Jo ghulam ha uss ki pehchaan yea ha k woo apni leader k har baat aur policy ko defend karey ga kisi na kisi excuse se aur aese ghulam aur slaves har political party main hain. Yea tu apne baap ko na shorein agar wo in k leader ko criticise karey

 

[Shapur]

Pakistan is confideration of different ethnic groups i.e Pakhtuns, Sindhi, Punjabi, Balochi, kasmiri etc. National identity of all these ethnic groups is Pakistani

Afghanistan is confideration of different ethnic groups i.e pakhtuns, Uzebks, Tajiks etc national identity of all those ethnic groups is Afghan

Word Afghan should not be use for Pakhtuns but should use for all those Afghans who hold Afghan nationality irrespective of their ethnic groups. Word " Pakhtuns" is ethnic identity of Pakhtuns. Saying Paktuns= Afghan is same like saying India or Pakistan is ethnic identity of Punjabi/Sindhi lol or India or Bagladeshi is ethnic identity of Bengali. Those who believe in loy pashtunistan brainwash Pakistani pashtuns with these terms because they dont accept present realities of Pakistan and still living in durrani empires

Yes Pakistan is a confideration of different ethnic groups but Afghanistan is not a confideration. We don't have provinces names after ethnic groups like Pakistan. Afghanistan is similar to Turkey as it's named after it's majority ethnic group "Afghan =Pashtun", just like Turkey is named after Turks eventhough millions kurds, and other ethnic groups live in Turkey. The non Pashtuns of Afghanistan are classified as Afghan by citizenship but not ethnicity.
Seperating the word Afghan and Pukhtun doesn't make any sense as in many historical works these two names are used interchangeably and by disassociating from the name " Afghan". Pukhtuns will be a deprived of their real historical identity.
Imagine that an Uzbek Turk from Afghanistan claiming that he is more related to Afghan history than a real Afghan from KPK just because his citizenship is Afghan now. It doesn't make any sense. A pakhtun from KPK has much more right over the word Afghan than any Uzbek Turk from northern Afghaniatan

 

[El Sidd]

And the word "Afghan" is an abuse or kind of swear word in most of pakistan, so if someone from kpk wants to associate himself with a swear/abusive word like "afghan" then no one can help them.

Not true.

Afghans are respected in Pakistan generally.

 

[Zibago]

And the word "Afghan" is an abuse or kind of swear word in most of pakistan, so if someone from kpk wants to associate himself with a swear/abusive word like "afghan" then no one can help them.

Hell even kabuli engine indicates an inferior product
Kabuli is a genuine insult in Kpk

 

[Shapur]

And the word "Afghan" is an abuse or kind of swear word in most of pakistan, so if someone from kpk wants to associate himself with a swear/abusive word like "afghan" then no one can help them.

Then maybe Pakistanis need to read more about what their national poet Iqbal says about Afghans/Afghan......

 

[El Sidd]

Hell even kabuli engine indicates an inferior product
Kabuli is a genuine insult in Kpk

Cool.

Do Panjabiyan and Hinduaan next.

Thanks.

Then maybe Pakistanis need to read more about what their national poet Iqbal says about Afghans/Afghan......

Its not true dude. Afghans are treated mostly with respect but respect is mutual or a two way street.

Ofcourse there are some issues as there always are any society but they are societal issues not political.

 

[Crusher]

Then maybe Pakistanis need to read more about what their national poet Iqbal says about Afghans/Afghan......

I don't give much damn about poetry, I am into engineering.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Yes Pakistan is a confideration of different ethnic groups but Afghanistan is not a confideration. We don't have provinces names after ethnic groups like Pakistan. Afghanistan is similar to Turkey as it's named after it's majority ethnic group "Afghan =Pashtun", just like Turkey is named after Turks eventhough millions kurds, and other ethnic groups live in Turkey. The non Pashtuns of Afghanistan are classified as Afghan by citizenship but not ethnicity.
Seperating the word Afghan and Pukhtun doesn't make any sense as in many historical works these two names are used interchangeably and by disassociating from the name " Afghan". Pukhtuns will be a deprived of their real historical identity.
Imagine that an Uzbek Turk from Afghanistan claiming that he is more related to Afghan history than a real Afghan from KPK just because his citizenship is Afghan now. It doesn't make any sense. A pakhtun from KPK has much more right over the word Afghan than any Uzbek Turk from northern Afghaniatan

There are different ethnic groups reside in all neighbouring countries including Pakistan, India, Afghanistan etc. Name of provinces dont matter at all because you have pakhtuns living in Punjab, Sindh snd balochistsn. Dont confuse national identity with ethnic Identity. History of this region has been different under different empires and rulers in the past. Stop living in the past and accept present realities. You are either Afghan national or Pakistan national. There is nothing Afghan by ethnicity or Afghan by citizenship. Pakistani by ethnicity or Pakistani by citizenship. When non pastuns afghan tell others that they are Afghani then they dont tell them that they are afghans by citizenship and came from tajikistan .

 

[Maarkhoor]

Main Afghan hoon"

Pashtun

Means I was Bacha and now I am Bacha Baz....In punjabi I (Mohsin Dawar) was g@ndu and I will remain G@ndu...
@DESERT FIGHTER

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Then maybe Pakistanis need to read more about what their national poet Iqbal says about Afghans/Afghan......

Our poet also wrote " Sare jahasn se acha hindustan humara " yet later on changed his stance and demanded separate land for Muslims. Our national leader Quiad was supporter of united India at one stage and later demanded seperate land for Muslims. You are also no more living in durrani emipre or ranjit era so better accept what is reality of today

 

[Maarkhoor]

And my problem is with the whole state, parties are backing them up, government is quiet and if that's not enough our DG ISPR is asking them questions rather than doing anything, which makes it clear that we have the required evidence and everything and yet we aren't doing anything. If Pakistan is to prosper we need to get rid of all corrupt political and such terrorist scums.

PTI made alliance with these sc@m bags.....seat adjustments....Since I.K need KURSI not Pakistan...simple ...longer period....Bro

 

[shahbaz baig]

Oppositions strategy
Hakomat bahana fouj nishana.

 

[hussain0216]

Not true.

Afghans are respected in Pakistan generally.

Not really

Crooks
Prostitutes
Illiterates
Terrorists