Shocked: What is this? Only for Pakistanis

[Rafi]

WTFk is the problem here, for me the creator is present everywhere - he is omnipresent. The fundos have their priorities all wrong.

 

[nastikan]

Kindly do not troll



Just because it is does it make it right...you still didnt answer my question...Just because it happens does it mean it is right?



And you are gonna go after them? Dude that site has been famous for a bit NO ONE endangered their lives since ....not gonna happen coz we posted it on PDF

I'll believe when Pakistanis stop killing in the name of blasphemy and "culture".

 

[muse]

Our Arabized crazies are into projecting Islam as Morose, as joy less - as if Islam was against art and culture, but of course we know what these people find joy in, spreading fitna, Takfir and bacha baazi

 

[Pakistani E]

And then people start calling me names when I say a lot of Pakistanis are hypocrites. I don't talk out of thin air you know, And I have seen worse, far far worse.

 

[muse]

The question was more on what are they dancing about with the Nabi's birthday banners in the background....If it was the prophet's bday and they were dancing ....It is very disrespectful mind you...that is all...

Be reasonable talon, Since when is dance disrespectful of anyone?? And please tell us, is the concept of "Birthday" Islamic? For instance, did the prophet "celebrate" (think about the word, about what it means) his birthday? Yes or no?

Obviously not, since such a cultural construct did not exist in 7th century arabia -- does it mean we should not celebrate birthdays??

Dance is in our culture - the very symbol of our cultural heritage is the famous "dancing girl" figurine -- please lets not be more arab than the arab - lets be Muslims but Pakistani Muslims where Islam and our heritage and our culture are in harmony, not one interpretation trying to dominate everything because the reaction will be such that the interpretation in question will cease to exist (we will make sure of it) long before Pakistan and Islam in Pakistan will cease to exist.

 

[Major Sam]

So Boys and Girls, for all those who took exception, Please explain what was so objectionable?

i have question if you dont mind... can you read urdu?

 

[Azazel]

holy banner ke agy dance chal raha hai

I've heard of holy cow,But never heard of a holy banner.In fact I never understood the rationality of this concept of holiness at all.

 

[Major Sam]

Be reasonable talon, Since when is dance disrespectful of anyone?? And please tell us, is the concept of "Birthday" Islamic? For instance, did the prophet "celebrate" (think about the word, about what it means) his birthday? Yes or no?

Obviously not, since such a cultural construct did not exist in 7th century arabia -- does it mean we should not celebrate birthdays??

Dance is in our culture - the very symbol of our cultural heritage is the famous "dancing girl" figurine -- please lest not be more arab than the arab - lets be Muslims but Pakistani Muslims where Islam and our heritage and our culture are in harmony, not one interpretation trying to dominate everything because the reaction will be such that the interpretation in question will cease to exist (we will make sure of it) long before Pakistan and Islam in Pakistan will cease to exist.

M agree with u there is no concept of celebration of Hazrat Muhammad S.A.A.W Birthday.... but point here is only this me and every one don't have any problem here with dancing we have problem with the combination of banner with whats happening at front and portraying islam in wrong way. just remove the banner and do as they want as dance is not something new in our culture.

My objection is don't mix up islam with every thing. if you dont wanna obey then also dont try to portray it in wrong way. thats it.

i think every one will be agree with me on this.

 

[Dubious]

Be reasonable talon, Since when is dance disrespectful of anyone?? And please tell us, is the concept of "Birthday" Islamic? For instance, did the prophet "celebrate" (think about the word, about what it means) his birthday? Yes or no?

Obviously not, since such a cultural construct did not exist in 7th century arabia -- does it mean we should not celebrate birthdays??

Dance is in our culture - the very symbol of our cultural heritage is the famous "dancing girl" figurine -- please lets not be more arab than the arab - lets be Muslims but Pakistani Muslims where Islam and our heritage and our culture are in harmony, not one interpretation trying to dominate everything because the reaction will be such that the interpretation in question will cease to exist (we will make sure of it) long before Pakistan and Islam in Pakistan will cease to exist.

Did you see the video? I am talking about the occasion based on the banner and the song and the dance...

I believe you welcome that after going off to UK but mind you OUR CULTURE AND HERITAGE is with HAYA not with begayriti...

I'll believe when Pakistanis stop killing in the name of blasphemy and "culture".

troll kindly keep to the topic.....

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

I only see people dancing?

A Pakistani muslim girl dancing to Indian music in Islamic republic of Pakistan. That seems to be the issue here.

 

[Dubious]

Our Arabized crazies are into projecting Islam as Morose, as joy less - as if Islam was against art and culture, but of course we know what these people find joy in, spreading fitna, Takfir and bacha baazi

No where in Islam does it say give WRONG IMPRESSIONS about Islam....If people say ALLAH HU AKHBAR and blow themselves is wrong impression then so is what was happening in the video!

 

[muse]

we have problem with the combination of banner with whats happening at front and portraying islam in wrong way. just remove the banner and do as they want as dance is not something new in our culture.

My objection is don't mix up islam with every thing. if you dont wanna obey then also dont try to portray it in wrong way. thats it.

i think every one will be agree with me on this.

Yaara once again, a fight over "the truth" -- apparently Islam is and can only be What you say it MUST be -- be reasonable, such attitudes are not a risk to everyone else, they are risk to those who hold them -- consider, don't the Talib say the same thing? Don't they want the rest of us to follow what they say is Islam? And look at our response, we will wipe them out.

You can say hey I think it's "INAPPROPRIATE" TO ME, but if you begin making claims on behalf of all Islam, expect a problem. We should have learned by know that this constant warring over "the truth" is not what we should be doing -- And honestly if it was so offensive, people would not be watching the video to comment, isn't that so?

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

we are not talking about dance
look at the back ground the banner is about the birthday of Holy prohet (S.A.W)

Well that's wrong then

 

[JonAsad]

I believe some body some where made a mistake- should hv atleast removed the banner-

The dancing bachi has nice figure though-

A Pakistani muslim girl dancing to Indian music in Islamic republic of Pakistan. That seems to be the issue here.

That is not the issue- Lol-
Lol- per apki innocence per aik chumi denay ko dil ker reha hai-

 

[Major Sam]

Yaara once again, a fight over "the truth" -- apparently Islam is and can only be What you say it MUST be -- be reasonable, such attitudes are not a risk to everyone else, they are risk to those who hold them -- consider, don't the Talib say the same thing? Don't they want the rest of us to follow what they say is Islam? And look at our response, we will wipe them out.

You can say hey I think it's "INAPPROPRIATE" TO ME, but if you begin making claims on behalf of all Islam, expect a problem. We should have learned by know that this constant warring over "the truth" is not what we should be doing -- And honestly if it was so offensive, people would not be watching the video to comment, isn't that so?

I am agree with most of your part..... Here they just showing how much illetrate these people so u can judge if teachers are like this then what about the students.

My mean is its not to go there and kill these people. but there are red lines in islam. if you cant follow give respect to them. thats what i only want. its not their fault its just Jahalat. As what people do at shrines....