Reason Why Army men beaten motor way police officers?

[VCheng]

Tell me if anything comes out, above all Motor way Police was responsible for all the mess.

The motorway police were only carrying out their assigned duties by law.

 

[wOnDeR-ChAp]

The motorway police were only carrying out their assigned duties by law.

No they act erratically as per details available on media, they snatched service pistol even one of the captain made plea to senior officer of motorway to intervene but that officer responded that His mama is Gernail and abuse the captains and rest all you know.

 

[VCheng]

No they act erratically as per details available on media, they snatched service pistol even one of the captain made plea to senior officer of motorway to intervene but that officer responded that His mama is Gernail and abuse the captains and rest all you know.

All of that came much later, after they were prevented from issuing the speeding ticket by the lawbreaker.

 

[wOnDeR-ChAp]

All of that came much later, after they were prevented from issuing the speeding ticket by the lawbreaker.

No motorway police doing all this on the behest of their masters to defame the army and engage them to ward off Panama leaks issues.

 

[VCheng]

No motorway police doing all this on the behest of their masters to defame the army and engage them to ward off Panama leaks issues.

So who was speeding? What is the police supposed to do?

 

[wOnDeR-ChAp]

So who was speeding? What is the police supposed to do?

No one was speeding specially army guys, Motorway police acts cranky because one the motorway Police officer is a nephew of some Gernail and wants to show his power which ended up in a scuffle...as a result better trained, physically fit guys wins. Matter is under investigation on both ends.
I rest my case.
C ya Punk.

 

[AsifIjaz]

That possibility is an excuse. The Major's claims are irrelevant as a matter of law since it is only how he perceived the law enforcement actions. A true officer would have accepted the ticket, not let the situation escalate, and resumed his journey.

Justice must not only be done, but also seen to be done. The outcome of the investigation and the punishment must be made public.

You have again written a post which is uni directional and you are biased and 1000% sure that army personnel was at fault.
1)
Why are the major's claims irrelevant?
He has every right to prove his innocence and deserves a fair trial before he can be called guilty.
He broke a law by over speeding. No one is denying that. So does that makes him pro brawl or a hitman as well??

2) "since it is only how he perceived the law enforcement actions"
Well the same way the patrolling officer perceived the major was trying to influence him by telling him his occupation and rank.

3)
u say "a true officer would have accepted the ticket, not let the situation escalate and resumed his journey"
Well till the major is proven guilty and you are sure that he is at fault then why don't you rephrase your sentence as... A true officer would have accepted the ticket, listen to abusive language, crap about armed forces, not let the situation escalate by saying thank you and resumed his journey.

For heavens sake do you even try to see the other side of the picture. Do you see how hypocrite you sound?

You might be hurt as an idiot of a major has tarnished the reputation of the armed forces and may be tried to influence by acting above the law. I am hurt rather angry as well. But I refuse to take sides and pass judgement till the guilty party is announced.
Please try to be open to alternative argument.

 

[VCheng]

You might be hurt as an idiot of a major has tarnished the reputation of the armed forces and may be tried to influence by acting above the law. I am hurt rather angry as well. But I refuse to take sides and pass judgement till the guilty party is announced.

Let us see whether the said idiot gets his comeuppance fairly or not. It will become evident soon enough.

 

[Saleem]

guys you are missing a very important point: would these motor goons have acted with the same enthusiasm if teh car had belonged to a MNA, MPS, minister or other fuddy duddy???????they would have wet theri pants before they ddi anything.....
secondly what is the SSG guys were on a secret IBO??? and these jokers blew their cover?????

these morons from IG, AIG, DIG SSP SP DSP etc all need to be tried by FGCM and then shot and al theri assets confiscated...

 

[VCheng]

guys you are missing a very important point: would these motor goons have acted with the same enthusiasm if teh car had belonged to a MNA, MPS, minister or other fuddy duddy???????they would have wet theri pants before they ddi anything.....
secondly what is the SSG guys were on a secret IBO??? and these jokers blew their cover?????

these morons from IG, AIG, DIG SSP SP DSP etc all need to be tried by FGCM and then shot and al theri assets confiscated...

What tope seekrat mission requires speeding on the motorway that would attract such attention? If your post proves anything, it is only that such army officers deserve the same contempt the public reserves for those entitled VIPs you mention.

 

[Mugwop]

They will be disciplined army way and these hot shots captains ended up in Siachin and retiring as Major rank.

I doubt that but I hope that they are

 

[wOnDeR-ChAp]

o

I doubt that but I hope that they are

Believe me ask any member who served or relative to army officer that happens in Pakistan army quite frequently, they call that officers mostly captains hot shots or naughty often ended up posting in Siachin and retires only as Major.

 

[Yasir khan Afridi]

I have consulted a retired Naval Captain of the HM’s Navy known to me.

Police officer can arrest anyone including the Prime Minister if found breaking the law in the area under his jurisdiction. I was given to understand that there are no legal restrictions on civilian police arresting uniformed/ serving military personnel unless it was a restricted area where police cannot enter without authorization. Only person beyond the law is the Queen / King who is supposed to be the fountain head of the law of the land.

However once arrested, the military personnel is obliged to inform the Commanding Officer and he /she can demand full access to do so. Normal procedure would be for the service personnel to be handed over to the Military/Naval police and tried by the military. I would expect that generally similar rules apply in Pakistan as well.

Since there is no respect for the law in Pakistan society and army officers/ personnel being members of the same society, also have similar attitude towards the law of the land. In my humble opinion, even if Motorway Police were totally in the wrong, Pak Army Captain should have voluntarily surrendered and taken the case up through the official military channels. Beating up of police officers in the course of their duty should not be condoned under any circumstances.

WELL SAID... BRAVO.... LAW DOESN'T BEND..!

1

Question is not who beat up who but was the police man wrong to ask soldier to hand over his gun. Was the soldier in uniform or civilian clothes, even if he was in uniform didnt we have a history of terrorist dressed as soldiers. I am 100% on the side with the policeman, he was only doing his job and maybe he was risking his life when he saw someone with a weapon he would have been even justified to shoot him on the spot when he refuse to hand him over his weapon. Yet everyone here is siding with the army guy and then we wonder why do we have law and order situation in the country, why do we have VIP culture when you are insisting that Soldier should be treated as a VIP. and before you all open you mouth I do belong to an army family

AGREED....

 

[Djinn]

I doubt that but I hope that they are

Unfortunately their juvenile antics have caused Army a great deal of blow to it's repute on media, unless they are well connected they might face some strict penalty. However that would ultimately rope in their seniors as well, as obviously all this was sanctioned by them. Gen Raheel is kind of an image obsessed person so i wont be surprised if they are punished. On a personal note i don't think they have committed a grave crime and a minor military warning to all army personal involved should suffice.

 

[Saleem]

What tope seekrat mission requires speeding on the motorway that would attract such attention? If your post proves anything, it is only that such army officers deserve the same contempt the public reserves for those entitled VIPs you mention.

if anything your attitude shows the callousness ,,,,it is these top secret mssions that are controlling the criminals while the so called politicians are doing their best to protect and foster the qabza groups manshiat farosh etc.....thes escum haev probably never done ONE honest deed in their lives.....