Panel to decide if Faiz poem is anti-Hindu!!!

[Chhatrapati]

Jamia Students are doing so just to save themselves from the barbaric BJP and RSS goons. What is nationalism according to you? Pinpointing and attacking people on the basis of their belief. Its in Indian National interest to block internet and telephone service in Kashmir and also beat up Muslims because they have no where else to go.

Nah! If you're protesting for secularism in India, you don't go around singing communal poems or raise slogans like tera mera rishta lailaha illalla. That's why the protests got confined to Islamic universities when people started seeing for what it is.

 

[jamahir]

Idols Are Figurative Term and Have Been Used To Imply Any Wrong In Muslim Literature

Yes indeed.

and Faiz Was A Socialist He Did Not Harbour Any Religious Bias

The Right-wingers here already call the Progressives in India as Urban Naxals, meaning the urban sympathizers or supporters of the Left-wing Naxalite movement who are fighting the state in the jungles.

If you're protesting for secularism in India, you don't go around singing communal poems or raise slogans like tera mera rishta lailaha illalla.

So what would you have them rather sing ??

That's why the protests got confined to Islamic universities when people started seeing for what it is.

The protests are more wider than "Islamic universities".

 

[SIPRA]

Yes indeed.

These Chaddi Dhaaris and Sanghis, perhaps, don't know that "but" and "sanam", meaning idol, has been used virtually thousands of times, with different meanings, in Urdu and Persian poetry. Would they now start analyzing all that poetic tradition, and perhaps banning, which doesn't suite their obnoxious narrative?

So what would you have them rather sing ??

"Satyam Shivam Sundaram"

 

[jamahir]

"Satyam Shivam Sundaram"

Heh heh.

 

[SIPRA]

Heh heh.

And that also, in extremely transparent apparel, as was worn by Zeenat Aman, in that song.

 

[Chhatrapati]

So what would you have them rather sing ??

You can sing it, I have no issue with it. But then it's not about secularism is it?

The protests are more wider than "Islamic universities".

Not really. Besides, the protest is bogus. What are they protesting against? A non existent NRC, NPR or CAA?

 

[kingQamaR]

Without our ancestors Islamic conquest and it’s contribution there, India would be far worse even of a shItty place than it’s now. Taj Mahal, And the red fort is just one example they want to keep lol

 

[jamahir]

Not really. Besides, the protest is bogus. What are they protesting against? A non existent NRC, NPR or CAA?

They are protesting against imminent implementation of CAA across India.

 

[The_Showstopper]

Jamia Students are doing so just to save themselves from the barbaric BJP and RSS goons. What is nationalism according to you? Pinpointing and attacking people on the basis of their belief. Its in Indian National interest to block internet and telephone service in Kashmir and also beat up Muslims because they have no where else to go.

Singing National anthem was never a bone of contention for Indian muslims... It was national song which muslims had problem with as it invoked idolatry.

So what would you have them rather sing ??



The protests are more wider than "Islamic universities".

They never had a problem when so-called nationalists used jai shree ram as war cry against Indian muslims, Don't the Indian soldiers invoke their Gods while fighting for secular India, no one has a problem then. Some one rightly said, "Hum uff bhi karte hai toh hojate hai badnaam, woh khatl bhi karte hai toh charcha nahi hota"

 

[Chhatrapati]

They are protesting against imminent implementation of CAA across India.

It is already being implemented. So you're protesting against minorities from Islamic republics and theocracies getting citizenship. Figured.

 

[Chhatrapati]

Singing National anthem was never a bone of contention for Indian muslims... It was national song which muslims had problem with as it invoked idolatry.

LOL! As if Jana Gana Mana is any different, please read a translation, it's interesting. The national song do not invoke any idolatry, it is simply an ode to India. If you have a problem with that then please look into the country you live in, Indian constitution has heavily borrowed many symbolism, quotations from Indic religions. Some are explicit like Ashoka stupa (idolatry), Spoked wheel on flag (Dharma chakra) national motto Satyameva Jayate (Mundaka Upanishad), Motto of Supreme Court Yadho dharma S thadho jaya: - Bhagavat Gita. (total Shirk).

When I open the original transcript of Indian constitution drafted in 1949, on every page you'd see interesting sculptures from Hinduism (Shirk).

I could go on and on about more. Who knows, you people tomorrow may find issues with things like these.

 

[Imran Khan]

 

[SIPRA]

konsi ik but mujhy bhi kaaba e dil main para mila wali ?

حیرت ہے اس نے اپنی پرستش ہی کیوں نہ کی؟
جب آدمی کو پہلے پہل آئینہ ملا..

مجھ سے بچھڑ کے یوسفِ بے کارواں ہے تو..
مجھ کو تو خیر درد ملا، تجھ کو کیا ملا؟

(احمد ندیمؔ قاسمی)

this is anti hindu poem too

Very well sung by Shaukat Ali.

Karaarh laiwanay thee wanjay hen.

 

[Ahmet Pasha]

Kawwa halal hai ya haram??

 

[Imran Khan]

Very well sung by Shaukat Ali.

Karaarh laiwanay thee wanjay hen.

ایسی قاتل جان شاعری بین ہی ہونی چاہیے ۔ سمجھ نہیں آتا کیونکر ارسطو نے شعرا کو انکے مقام سے گرایا۔ اگر یہ دیوتاؤں کی زبان نہین بول رہی تو اور کیا ہے ؟

ترے غم کو جاں کی تلاش تھی ترے جاں نثار چلے گئے
تری رہ میں کرتے تھے سر طلب ، سرِ رہگزار چلے گئے

تری کج ادائی سے ہار کے شبِ انتظار چلی گئی
مرے ضبطِ حال سے رُوٹھ کر مرے غم گسار چلے گئے

نہ سوالِ وصل ، نہ عرضِ غم ، نہ حکایتیں نہ شکایتیں
ترے عہد میں دلِ زار کے سبھی اختیار چلے گئے

یہ ہمیں تھے جن کے لباس پر سرِ رہ سیاہی لکھی گئی
یہی داغ تھے جو سجا کے ہم سرِ بزمِ یار چلے گئے

نہ رہا جنونِ رُخِ وفا، یہ رسن یہ دار کرو گے کیا
جنہیں جرمِ عشق پہ ناز تھا وہ گناہ گار چلے گئے


(فیض احمد فیض)​

Kawwa halal hai ya haram??

حلال ہے اگر کالا نا ہو تو