'India's direct trade volume with Pakistan amounts to $2 billion'
ISLAMABAD (April 24 2008): Major reforms in infrastructure, education, business climate and efficiency in public sector expenditure in India have been instrumental to a great extent, in raising potential output growth.
This was the crux of special lecture on "Economic Reforms and India's economic performance" by Dr Rajiv Kumar, Director and Chief Executive, Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations (ICRIER) at a local hotel here on Wednesday.
The trade volume with Pakistan directly amounts to 2 billion dollar but via other routes such as Dubai, it might go up to 7-9 billion dollar. India's tax to GDP ratio is low (16 percent) as compared to average in developed countries (35 percent).
There was a tremendous shift in economic integration with the rest of the world from 1980's onwards, though India still faces economic challenges in the face of post-reform economic development.
The notion of self-reliance has been challenged, as the trade deficit grew from 19 percent of GDP in 1990-91 to more than 50 percent in 2007, but that is bridged with entrepreneurial and other remittances inflow from abroad, he opined.
He said one of the reasons could be the reduction in real interest rate as compared to rest of the world. It has a fair bit of impact of all global trends, eg there is negative relation of GDP to international oil prices. But that also shows week planning on the part of alternate energy sources development, as the real oil prices were the highest in 2006 after 1974.
Share of consumption fell in 2000, but still higher than in China. High growth driven by domestic investment, consumption and net exports in China, while net exports contribution was negative in India from 2001-07, he added.
Services sector has the highest share in economic growth of India (more than 61 percent) although agriculture being the major source of employment has only 18 percent.
He said Manufacturing growth rate was higher than services sector in 15 out of 31 quarters from 2000-01. Industrial growth subject to government price control, was lower than those firms, where prices are market-determined.
Analysing the employment situation in India, Rajiv said that overwhelming proportion of workforce is in the fast shrinking agriculture sector, as there is limited labour absorption in the booming services sector. Continued growth in manufacturing calls for employment growth. However, job opportunities grew during 2000-05 in all sectors and 61 million new jobs created during the above mentioned period.
Commenting on Balance of Payments (BoP) he said "widening trade deficit was compensated by rising invisibles surplus. Huge capital inflows continuing and to cross 9 percent of GDP this year. Trend shows that mounting gap represents lost opportunities to raise investment levels. Hence reforms were necessary to raise absorption capacity.
Now the direction of India's trade is major shift towards China. To a question Rajiv replied that there are income imbalances. Performance for reducing poverty, which is 24 percent is not satisfactory.
Responding to a question on role of education and infrastructure in alleviating poverty, he said "poor are intelligent enough to reap fruits of development if given opportunities. Rural infrastructure programme did not achieve in terms of poverty reduction. Money spent on education and infrastructure help the poor far more. This is why they want my (Rajiv) reforms agenda, he maintained.
Democracy is the key strength to overcome external pressures as it distributes resources on the basis of equity, balance.
With all the shortcomings quality of life has improved as 80 percent of the population in India earns 2.5 dollar a day, quoted from Dr Arjun Singh Gupta, but it is a fact.
To a question on rural poverty Rajiv commented that urban poor are more in trouble. Agriculture remains in India a controlled sector with heavy subsidies. Liberalisation would bring better results in the long run along with elimination of the role of middleman who takes major chunk of the profit.
Lastly, he concluded Information Technology (IT) revolution in India was a private sector endeavour, adding that when Chinese visited Banglore they complained to Asian Development Bank (ADB) that government has not briefed us on its IT policy. In fact there was no IT policy, private sector achieved all this. Shahnaz Wazir Ali (MNA) reaffirmed the four point reforms for Pakistan's current civilian democratic government.
Business Recorder [Pakistan's First Financial Daily]