What's new

Pakistan-Bangladesh relations thaw

. .
Rhetorics and bragging.
Dada shukar manno hum nai mentor bola warna apnara mantri Memon tou kuch aur bol raha thaa.
Bhaijan ( we don't use dada, West Bengalis use it) , it's Momen,not Memon. However, the problem of AL ministers ( BNP ministers were same though) are they are beta personality.

They day and night seek blessing from PM. He thought that Hasina will be happy, but the reality is Hasina is actually opposite of the popular belief.

Now you see Momen has changed his tone and overtly showing his tension towards India. But still don't take his tension seriously too ; nothing from Bangladeshi politicians should be taken seriously as they are basically clowns.

Just take our words ( common folks) , we represent Bangladesh, not the ministers.
 
Last edited:
. . .
Pakistan made a mistake by openly condemning the trial of razakars in Bangladesh. What Bangladesh does to it's own citizen should not have concerned Pakistan. That condemnation and Parliamentary resolution condemning the decision of trial process in Bangladesh give a very bad taste to Bangladeshi govt. and people. It clearly shows that, Pakistani establishment still does not fill guilty about it's action in 1971, rather condone those who committed atrocity upon common people of Bangladesh. If you can not show remorse of your wrong action then at least keep quiet. For the bad relation between the two countries, Pakistan is equally responsible.

Remember, Sheikh Hasina visited Pakistan in 1998 when she was PM in first term. Even after 2009, when she returned to power, did not show any hostility towards Pakistan either in words or deed. It is only after Pakistan decided to interfere in Bangladesh's internal affairs, that she and her govt. became hostile. You need to understand, 1971 genocide is an emotional issue for all the Bangladeshi. As a decent human being, you should not show any disrespect to that. If you can become that mature, then Bangladesh-Pakistan relation will flourish over times.
Indo-Pak relations..... corrected.
 
. .
Pakistanis are racially neither indian or bengali.
I don't say that they are racially similar. However I don't recognize race system though. And we Bangladeshis enjoy a multi racial ethnicity ( we have a good portion of fair skinned people) ! Indians do the same too. There are huge differences between north and south Indians. BTW, aren't Indian punjabi and Pakistani punjabis look similar? So what's the difference other than religion, you know it better.

What about the sindhi people of Pakistan? They are not fair skinned,but brown to dark skinned! So what is their race according to your theory?

What about the people of khyber pakhtunkhwa? They aren't majority yet fairer skin comparing others right? So what is actually Pakistani race and Indian race I am unable to understand.

If you are talking about stature, still there are huge difference between north Indian and south Indians. So what is actually Indian race and Pakistani race, please elaborate! And also what is Bengali race! Are you taking language as different race? Still it doesn't justify your theory because in Pakistan and India many languages are recognized!
 
Last edited:
. .
I don't say that they are racially similar. However I don't recognize race system though. And we Bangladeshis enjoy a multi racial ethnicity! Indians do the same too. There are huge differences between north and south Indians. BTW, aren't Indian punjabi and Pakistani punjabis look similar? So what's the difference other than religion, you know it better.

What about the sindhi people of Pakistan? They are not fair skinned,but brown to dark skinned! So what is their race according to your theory?

What about the people of khyber pakhtunkhwa? They aren't majority yet fairer skin comparing others right? So what is actually Pakistani race and Indian race I am unable to understand.

If you are talking about stature, still there are huge difference between north Indian and south Indians. So what is actually Indian race and Pakistani race, please elaborate! And also what is Bengali race! Are you taking language as different race? Still it doesn't justify your theory because in Pakistan and India many languages are recognized!


indian Punjabis make up less than 3% of indians population. Wheras Pakistani Punjabis make up 55% of Pakistan's population. Due to Pakistanis intermarrying with the Tribes West of us, Pakistani Punjabis now share very little in common with indian Punjabis who have been intermarrying with Dravidian indians. Punjabi is now more a linguistic term rather than a racial/ethnic one. So less than 2% of india's population has ANY DNA or genetic link to the Pakistani races/ethnicities. However, around 35-40% of Pakistan's population has racial/dna links to at least 40% of Iran's population and over 70% of Afghanistan's population. That in NO WAY makes us Afghan or Iranian just as it doesn't make us "indian". india and bangladesh may be made up of different races and ethnicities but they are COMPLETELY different to the races and ethnicities that make up Pakistan.

The Pushtun are not a minority in Pakistan but just under 40%. The Sindhi in Pakistan are a minority but they too have been intermarrying with the Western Tribes of Pakistan and look different to the indians of a similar name. I know as I have been to Pakistan over 35 times. Last time being August 2019.
 
.
Where can I find the policy papers? Perhaps @bluesky too will be interested. Please post some link if the policy papers are available for public.

Here are some to start with. Keep in mind that there is no " Bengali notebook " which will put everything in one page for you. You have to do the synthesis by going through the thesis and anti-thesis. No analysis can be done without doing the synthesis first. Common people don't know how to do it.

Walk Street Journal
https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-go...t-chinas-empire-building-megaplan-11554809402

The Chinese Journal of International Politics
https://academic.oup.com/cjip/article/11/1/81/4844054


https://www.the-american-interest.com/2015/06/09/burma-in-play/

https://asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/C...Myanmar-divert-US-attention-from-human-rights

https://www.globalresearch.ca/balkanisation-myanmar-and-the-us-pivot-to-asia-directed-against

https://www.globalresearch.ca/oil-g...ing-the-rohingya-crisis-against-china/5610568
 
Last edited:
. . .
Why invest in futile efforts?

Bangladesh has a trajectory dissimilar to Pakistan's in the 21st century. There is little to gain from this adventure and such low level projects should not be given mainstream attention.
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom