Nisar Khoro wins: another era of destruction begins

[PakSarZameen47]

As things are right now, PTI can either appeal to the Urdu speaking masses of Sindh or the Sindhi speaking masses. A party that can unite both and get them to leave their differences behind seems impossible for now.

What about dividing sindh and all other provinces into smaller administrative units?

 

[fitpOsitive]

Ethnic politics is a disease. What about PTI, anyway they can make in roads here?

The formula to Sindh is: get sindhi speaker candidates in all other parts of sindh. For Karachi hyderabad, get urdu speaker candidates on-board. If PTI has to take mustafa Kamal on-board then I think its not a big deal. Even Jamat e Islami can help.

 

[MelloryOlephanto]

What about dividing sindh and all other provinces into smaller administrative units?

The people who have spent decades capitalising on provincial identities and getting rich and powerful would object to that.

 

[PakSarZameen47]

The people who have spent decades capitalising on provincial identities and getting rich and powerful would object to that.

It might cause a few hiccups but once done they will never be able to capitalise om ethnic politics, could wipe it out for good

 

[Maula Jatt]

Let me give you a summary at history of how Sindhis were before and after the coming of PPP as a political force in power.

Before 1971, there was no Sindh province as Pakistan was under one unit system and Karachi was separated from Sindh before that. Sindhi language was banned in education and administration from 1948. Demographic changes in nearly every urban centre of Sindh during partition, where Karachi, Hyderabad, Mirpurkhas, Sukkur, Khairpur, Nawabshah, Tando Alhayar and Tando Adam became Hindustani Muhajir majority cities. Quota system for Hindustani Muhajirs which made their majority in bureaucracy of Sindh. Sindhi’s were basically orphans with not even a separate administrative unit to call their home.

After 1971 as soon as PPP came in power, it drafted a constitution where Sindh was made a separate province with Karachi as its capital.
Sindhi language was made official language of Sindh and revived in education and administration, where from 3 class to 12th class Sindhi is an compulsory subject in private schools, In 1998 there were 47,444 schools in Sindh out of which 36,750 had Sindhi as medium of instruction. There are billboards, documents such as FIR, CNIC, B-Form, Land papers etc can be made in Sindhi language. Language would only die if we let it die. All attempts of Hindustani Muhajirs failed at others from abandoning their language except for maybe Punjabis.
Urban-Rural quota system was introduced which ensured Sindhi majority in bureaucracy of province.
18th amendment was introduced which gave more autonomy to provinces and Sindh local bodies act took away most of powers of Hindustani Muhajirs.

We’ve come a long way.

I respect what people of Sindh want out of PPP and it's their right - no objection
but I fear they might be playing with your sentiments to hide their incompetency- for a province with the highest per capita GDP this is absolutely atrocious, per capita budget is also pretty high

You can do anything you want as its a federation but stats coming out of Sindh are really bad
this is too high a cost imo