valid arguments you have put up brother, and just to clear things up, there will be no monetary benefit for providing the services, otherwise whats the point of calling it Volunteer force.
They will be more like vigilant force acting as a deterrent to the local street crime, easing the situation in residential areas. They will not be an independent entity but will operate under local Police station - SDPO will be overlooking the force.
Volunteer Constables will be reporting to DSP thana.
given that volunteers will be the part of Regular police force- so due process will have to followed. On the contrary, a social media drive will play a role here in order to attract the best of the youth. You wont be picking up on every jobless thug out on the street. For starters - the focus should be to bring the unemployed talented youth of the country under the umbrella.
Rather than sitting at home unemployed and getting frustrated this will atleast provide them an opportunity to develop themselves. Because believe me when you are out their on street doing something, you get to learn things. One might not realize it but you develop a sense of responsibility & skills. I have done such a job in UK.
It will require some harsh decisions and commitment to make it work.
the points you have entered are exactly what I have in mind - they are on my list. I will be presenting a well layed out democratic structure of the organization.....
what confusing me is whether to have it as Independent force like Volunteer Constabulary / National Police Volunteer service or make it an integral part of Regular Police force and local stations will recruit its own Force